Show newer

@SheChanges

Ok, please remove me from future tagging in this conversation, thank you.

This is the third time I asked, next time is a block. Thanks again.

@Moonbuggy @Robotpuppy

@SheChanges

I linked a peer-reviewed meta study that clearly stated the figure is 1.7% - 4% and likely conservative.

Meta-studies are peer-reviewed themselves and a mechanism to determine consensus.

@Robotpuppy @Moonbuggy

@DecayHeat

To save you some time there isnt any**one** study that picks the 1.7% number. There are a lot, and a good deal of consensus and peer-review showing that number is at **least** 1.7%.

To save you some time I linked below a meta-study (meta studies are peer-reviewed and are themselves collections of many/most of the studies on the subject and aim to find consensus).

The study passed peer review and cited a figure between 1.7% - 4% as the consensus among scientists (which means they also agree on the definition). It also suggests this number is conservative. Here are some quotes from the linked paper:

Research has generally estimated that 1.7% to 4% of people go on to actually have intersex variations (Carroll, 2005; Fausto-Sterling, 1993; OII Australia, 2012b)

Given that many elements of sex (chromosomes, genes, hormones) are not apparent without testing, current estimates of the incidence and types of intersex variations seen in humans may be conservative.

journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/

@Moonbuggy @Robotpuppy

@Moonbuggy

My gender (masculinity/maleness) certainly isnt subtle, your right. My sex however (my genitals) however are not showing in the picture, and thus there is no indication what it might be.

@DecayHeat @Robotpuppy

@DecayHeat

To save you some time there isnt any**one** study that picks the 1.7% number. There are a lot, and a good deal of consensus and peer-review showing that number is at **least** 1.7%.

To save you some time I linked below a meta-study (meta studies are peer-reviewed and are themselves collections of many/most of the studies on the subject and aim to find consensus).

The study passed peer review and cited a figure between 1.7% - 4% as the consensus among scientists (which means they also agree on the definition). It also suggests this number is conservative. Here are some quotes from the linked paper:

Research has generally estimated that 1.7% to 4% of people go on to actually have intersex variations (Carroll, 2005; Fausto-Sterling, 1993; OII Australia, 2012b)

Given that many elements of sex (chromosomes, genes, hormones) are not apparent without testing, current estimates of the incidence and types of intersex variations seen in humans may be conservative.

journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/

@Moonbuggy @Robotpuppy

@Moonbuggy

No, all you know is that my gender is male (I present myself as a male to you externally). You have no clue what genitals I have. But based on my gender, and with no knowledge of any kind of my genitals, you were still successfully able to pick pronouns.

@DecayHeat @Robotpuppy

@DecayHeat

Language is weird like that. there is nothing objective or factual about any one definition other than general usage.

There are no doubt some people who might personally object to the word. They are welcome to do so of course. But there are medical definitions all the same.

@Moonbuggy @Robotpuppy

@DecayHeat

Agreed the 1.7% figure refers to all intersex people (people where the factors that determine ones medical sex do not all agree). For that context it is accurate.

However as you point out being visually identifiable as intersex at birth (specifically having ambiguous genitalia severe enough to be recognized on a new born) is a much smaller subset of the entire intersex community. This too would be a valid point.

Ultimately it depends on context which of these figures are relevant. But if we are talking generally about all intersex then the 1.7% figure makes the most sense.

@Moonbuggy @Robotpuppy

@Moonbuggy

Glad we agree then that ones outward appearance is all you need to know to determine what pronoun to use and demonstrating my point that knowledge of ones genitalia is not a factor in choosing that language

Q.E.D. at its finest

@DecayHeat @Robotpuppy

@DecayHeat

If she would have engaged respectfully I would have been more than happy to read any links and discuss the points. But it was clear she had no intention of doing so, so I wouldnt waste my energy on a one-way discussion.

The figure, as with any fact, is certainly up for discussion.

@Moonbuggy @Robotpuppy

@Mrkhvoice

Nope, just prefer to engage with people who have a difference of opinion **and** do so respectfully.

You are now blocked.

Have a good day.

@ReSistingPink@spinster.xyz @Moonbuggy @Robotpuppy

@Lemondrizzle

When did I say or suggest that gender was equivalent to attire?

You seem to not understand the words being used in this conversation and just making assumptions about what they mean that are not the same as the actual meaning.

@Robotpuppy @Moonbuggy

@Mrkhvoice

Please remove me from tagging in this conversation, thanks

@ReSistingPink@spinster.xyz @Moonbuggy @Robotpuppy

@Mrkhvoice

As I made very clear I am not respectful because you didnt treat me with respect. Prior to that I engaged you respectfully. Sadly you lost that respect when you didnt return it.

@Moonbuggy @Robotpuppy

@Lemondrizzle

Please remind me in what langauge someone needs to see your genitals before they can determine what pronoun to use? Never in any language in the history of languages has someone went "oh wait I never saw the persons genitals so I dont know what pronoun to use"... It has literally **never** been the criteria for pronoun usage. Outside of medical discourse

@Robotpuppy @Moonbuggy

@ReSistingPink@spinster.xyz

I will listen to anyone who gives me the same curtosy. That clearly does not include claire however.

@Mrkhvoice @Moonbuggy @Robotpuppy

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.