@cwebber As someone who refuses to work on viral licenses like GPL and the related CC licenses I agree. I'm all for fixing the viral nature but am worried people will make it worse. I'm happy to just use apache or MIT until someone solves it.
Soon social media might fall under the laws of Common Carrier. Personally I would be ok with that.
care to play with some programming languages:
Here is a web page that lets you have a compillation environment for a whole bunch of them without having to install anything. Pick your language from the drop down.
@Absinthe Also worth noting the several full IDE in a browser too, Eclipse chi I think was one (great ideal i like this one) but also many others out there
I heard about all the special ways the Jews get around the rather strict rules imposed on the Sabbath. This particular one has always stuck with me for the levels of engineering that likely went into it.
http://privateinvesigations.blogspot.com/2012/03/its-shabbat-phone-how-to-make-kosher.html
#podcast Wednesday: You are not so smart is a brilliant podcast about the research behind decision making, biases, how people change their minds, tribalism, how you fool yourself and confabulate post hoc reasons for your behaviour and more.
Personally, I'm a long time fan and it changed my perception of my self in a decisive way. Way more humble about how sure I am about my ideas.
Give it a shot!
@johnlitt I generally find after good sex or good food is when i am the most motivated personally
@Gargron What is it including gab? I should check what percentage of the network they are, im curious now.
That is not a distinction, if the food can not be shared then by extention of that fact they are not allowed to try it.
Even from a legal perspective it is the same. Whoever actually facilitates the person trying the food is the one illegal, it doesnt default to the chef or the consumer.
The reason you see it as the developer is just because in most cases if there is a violation the link which provided access to the software (which wasnt allowed) is most likely provided by the developer. However if this access is provided by someone else, anyone, even if the user themselves is the one sharing it without the authors permission, then the act of sharing it is illegal even for the user.
@zig@functional.cafe @cwebber
No I wouldnt say that would be a correct analogy. A more accurate analogy would be the following:
Some chef sometime int he past wrote a recipie for a delicious meal, he put a note at the bottom that says "only people who provide a list of ingredients (allergy information included in that) are allowed to cook this food and share it with others".
Then if someone makes a meal based ont he recipie (and with their own modifications of course) and uses a can of food that does not itself list the ingredients, so he is unable to list the ingredients as a result, is therefore in violation.
The GPL would basically mean that such a chef is free to make the above meal for himself and enjoy it and eat it, but other people would **not** be allowed to try his food without it being illegal.
@zig@functional.cafe @cwebber
If you can be sued then no, you can't, legally, offer it. I take that as a moot point and not a valid counter argument.
It prevents the access of users by making it legal for such access to exist. There is really no way to talk our way around this obvious point, user freedom is limited as they do not have access to software they otherwise would have.
@zig@functional.cafe @cwebber
No your missing the point. As I said if the software i created pulls in a non-compatible license or is closed-sourced then NO a user **can not** down load it because no download can be provided since the source code can not be provided under the GPL.
As such it limits the **users** freedom since access to any such software is denied to the user, despitethe developer being perfectly free to use and have access to it.
The fact the the GPL limits user freedom by denying them the freedom to download the above mentioned software, since it can not be provided to the user, is exactly the point.
Limiting the developers freedom to distribute the software in synonymous with limiting the users freedom to obtain such software.
@zig@functional.cafe @cwebber
But he can't. If i as a developer modified the code and do so by bringing in non-0compatible license code, while I am a developer and most free to do that and run the code for my own personal uses with no concern, **users** are not allowed to download and use copies of the software I would otherwise be happy to share.
It isnt reducing my freedom as a developer, im plenty free to use the modified closed-source software. It is only the user-base that is not allowed to have a copy.
@zig@functional.cafe @cwebber
I dont see that as protection of the user or giving the user freedom at all, it is taking away their freedom, the freedom of the user to download modified applications if they want to (even when it doesnt provide the source code).
@zig@functional.cafe @cwebber
No, I disagree. I am specifically and explicitly talking about user freedom, it just so happens that companies and developers are part of that group.
I as a developer (even under the GPL) and quite free to develop the software however I wish with little regard to the license. It is only if a user wishes to use what I have done as well (download a copy from me) that the licenses get invoked, and thus their freedom I care about.
@zig@functional.cafe @cwebber
I'm not sure the problems with it are entierly why id refuse to contibute to software that uses them.
Obviously virality of licenses has caused hosts of issues with open source projects in the past. Namely if you want to pull in dependencies or even just talk to it on the same computer it can cause hell for legal departments or personal legal issues. In the end it presents a barrier where I feel one does not need to exist and can be rather damaging.
My personal issue goes well beyond the technical ones though. Basically when I say free I mean free, as in freedom.
If someone wants to write some software that uses my own, and then they want to make money specifically off their own software, regardless of if it uses mine as a library, Why should I care. Making money isnt evil, and your only close sourcing your own contributions/modifications, so by my own moral standards it would be wrong of me to object. But I also find that if you try to control the behaviors of others that is itself not a character trait I see as positive out of the gate.
@zig@functional.cafe @cwebber
While I'd still view the parity license as viral by nature, and wouldnt personally use it, I do see it as a improvement over AGPL. I would not even contribute to software that has any form of viral aspects to its license.
That said I also agree that it is not really a legal document and unlikely to standup to well in court. Which for me adds to why I'd personally avoid it.
@zig@functional.cafe @cwebber
Jeffrey Phillips Freeman
Innovator & Entrepreneur in Machine Learning, Evolutionary Computing & Big Data. Avid SCUBA diver, Open-source developer, HAM radio operator, astrophotographer, and anything nerdy.
Born and raised in Philadelphia, PA, USA, currently living in Utrecht, Netherlands, USA, and Thailand. Was also living in Israel, but left.
Pronouns: Sir / Mister
(Above pronouns are not intended to mock, i will respect any persons pronouns and only wish pronouns to show respect be used with me as well. These are called neopronouns, see an example of the word "frog" used as a neopronoun here: http://tinyurl.com/44hhej89 )
A proud member of the Penobscot Native American tribe, as well as a Mayflower passenger descendant. I sometimes post about my genealogical history.
My stance on various issues:
Education: Free to PhD, tax paid
Abortion: Protected, tax paid, limited time-frame
Welfare: Yes, no one should starve
UBI: No, use welfare
Racism: is real
Guns: Shall not be infringed
LGBT+/minorities: Support
Pronouns: Will respect
Trump: Moron, evil
Biden: Senile, racist
Police: ACAB
Drugs: Fully legal, no prescriptions needed
GPG/PGP Fingerprint: 8B23 64CD 2403 6DCB 7531 01D0 052D DA8E 0506 CBCE