1) the bible makes no mention of trans people and in no way clearly supports your point. You must rely on your own opinion and interpritation of what the passages mean to draw the conclusion you did, so no the bible is still not an authority in that case, as it is still dependent on you.
2) IF the bible condones medicine for healing, then hormone therapy can be seen as medicine trans people take to heal
You may disagree on #2, and again you have that right, but it is clear that the science on this in either direction is non-conclusive.
As i said before, I would argue that kids should be allowed to get a tattoo or smoke, presuming they can demonstrate they understand their decision. This demonstration should not be based on age but rather how a person speaks and acts.
I'd say the same for an adult. If someone is 40 years old and clearly is speaking in a way that they cant understand what is going on around them, then they should be denied a cigerette.
I have long held that rights should not be age-dependent as they currently are but should be granted based on ones demonstration of coherence.
if you think it is self-harm then your argument has less to do with what god wants and more to do with if its self-harm or not. Incidentally invoking self-harm as something to be avoided is a perfectly fine way to reason about it without needing the question of god to enter in in the first place.
At that point the debate is reduced simply to if it is self-harm or not. Which has the same property as what i described before, namely, that it is your opinion if it is self-harm and that it is not settled science either way. Maybe its harmful, maybe its not, its not as simple as you suggest. It is also very individualistic.
Perhaps, perhaps not. What means do you have to determine if what god wanted you to be was a transitioning adult?
Since you learn and change every day how could you know what god wants you to be and what he doesnt.
If you take an antibiotic are you going against what god wanted you to be (A dead man with a bacterial infection)?
That is a very good question. As a parent if a child smokes I feel you probably raised your child poorly. This is best addressed not by physically preventing them from smoking but by teaching them why it is a bad choice.
the fact is most parents dont raise their kids very well, and part of that is exactly that mentality of having the last say about their body. Most kids who go and smoke tobacoo likely do it in defiance for a parent who doesnt give the child the responsibility and teaching to make the choice correctly.
So yes in society we do prevent kids from smoking, but we have it alllll backwards.
As far as I know god wasnt particularly clear in the bible what his thoughts were on transgendered people or hormone therapy.
So lets be clear, it is your opinion of what god thinks is sin, and you are welcome to that opinion, but that is not the same as you invoking god as an authority. He simply didnt say either way if it was a sin or not.
How do you feel this passage supports your PoV. As I stated, if the challenges faced are placed there by god for you to overcome, then by NOT taking the chance to solve the problem when you have the means (even if that means hormone therapy) then you are working against your maker, since the maker is the one who created the earth, the challenges, and the tools to address them.
Well god is hardly unique to christianity. God is a figure in most religions.
That is the single biggest driving thought in my own acceptance of children going through hormone therapy, body autonomy, combined with the fact that hormones are only fully effective pre-puberty, while they do work to some extent post-puberty they are far less effective and sometimes, especially in older adults, have no effect at all.
In the end the only one who will have to deal with the consequences is the child, so they should have the final say unless they have demonstrated (not through age but demonstrated) they are not of sound mind and body.
Has anyone bothered to actually weigh the trauma of not having the final say about your own body?
I am not trans, but I can relate rather indirectly. As a kid i had a deep rooted fear of needles, as im sure many kids do. I refused to get them no matter how needed it might be, but my mother insisted.
As a result she took me to a doctor and they strapped me down as I kicked and screamed and bit so they could draw blood. They eventually got the needle in me and I was too violent for them to get the vein and they gave up (might have helped that i kicked the doctor right in the balls as he tried to tie me up, no regrets). She tried this with a few other doctors all with the same result.
By the end of this ordeal, having no say over my own body, I was deeply fearful of all doctors even my own mother. I refused to go to a doctor, if she pulled up to a hospital or doctors office I would escape or tie myself into the car. To this day if i am in a hospital or doctors office i feel a sense of panic, which luckily I can overcome. But it is clear this violation of my body led to some degree of psychological harm.
I did later on have a doctor my mom brought me to who recognized this. He took me as his patient but made it clear to my mom he would refuse to do any treatment on me without my consent (and hers of course). When they needed to take blood and i refused he took a therapist type approach and isntead of forcing me let me know in the end it was up to me but also explained what that meant, the reprocutions i might face if i refused and some ways he could protentially help to make the expiernce better (including numbing agents). Eventually this worked and helped to offset a good deal of the trauma and eventually volunteers for the medical help I needed. Being on my terms and getting the last say was critical.
I think most children are far far more capable of rationalizing the future and the consequence of their actions that most people give them credit for.
Seems to me if we talk about god terms then we have to recognize that god often gives us challenges for the sake of overcoming them. He certainly doesnt expect you to keep things "as they are" lest be in sin. Changing the state of things, changing your own self, is not against god, it is the mostly godly thing one can do, presuming you work towards a state in which you better yourself.
So to me the whole argument "you were born that way dont mess with it" seems anti-god, not pro god. If he wanted you to be born perfect then there would be no need for any form of self-betterment of any kind. and self betterment always inherently means changing who you are in some way.
Would that also apply if you go on a diet and loose weight. Shouldnt you just accept that god made you overweight and therefore dieting would be a sin
Or is it more likely that dieticians, diet plans, and medical help to loose weight is as much tools that god puts at your disposal as hormone therapy would be?
@Surasanji What exactly did demand the pizza do?
#2220 "Imagine Going Back in Time"
I wonder what the trendy adults in 2019 who are too cool for Pokemon will be into. Probably Digimon!
https://xkcd.com/2220/
Still trying to find a style i like for the double L... Thoughts on this one?
@jump_spider Cheese has no place in grits as far as im concerned :)
@freemo you are our contact number 100 🎉🎉
@imvectech YAY!
Jeffrey Phillips Freeman
Innovator & Entrepreneur in Machine Learning, Evolutionary Computing & Big Data. Avid SCUBA diver, Open-source developer, HAM radio operator, astrophotographer, and anything nerdy.
Born and raised in Philadelphia, PA, USA, currently living in Utrecht, Netherlands, USA, and Thailand. Was also living in Israel, but left.
Pronouns: Sir / Mister
(Above pronouns are not intended to mock, i will respect any persons pronouns and only wish pronouns to show respect be used with me as well. These are called neopronouns, see an example of the word "frog" used as a neopronoun here: http://tinyurl.com/44hhej89 )
A proud member of the Penobscot Native American tribe, as well as a Mayflower passenger descendant. I sometimes post about my genealogical history.
My stance on various issues:
Education: Free to PhD, tax paid
Abortion: Protected, tax paid, limited time-frame
Welfare: Yes, no one should starve
UBI: No, use welfare
Racism: is real
Guns: Shall not be infringed
LGBT+/minorities: Support
Pronouns: Will respect
Trump: Moron, evil
Biden: Senile, racist
Police: ACAB
Drugs: Fully legal, no prescriptions needed
GPG/PGP Fingerprint: 8B23 64CD 2403 6DCB 7531 01D0 052D DA8E 0506 CBCE