@Full_marx @Karthikdeva Im not sure i can answer that as im not sure how those various check boxes relate to various castes. So im afraid I dont understand the situation well enough to understand that screenshot.
Was it required you fill in that information or optional? It seems marx suggests that is on the form as an optional field more to get aid. Assuming marx is right then I'd imagine it is optional. If its a requirement then that would disagree with marx assertion.
If marx is correct and it is illegal to search for a persons caste information then wouldnt it be trivial to just lie on that form?
If it is illegal to look up someones caste it would seem this is in direct contradiction to what Karthikdeva stated... Obviously i have no idea which is true. But if it is illegal to lookup someones caste that seems to be a good first step to abolishing it.
I dont think anyone ever said that you need to show a caste certificate to enter a temple. I am mostly just curious how templed enforce it at all. But I think that was answered earlier as small villages tend to know eachother and their caste wel.
Welcome to the community. Let me know if you have any questions or just want to chat. In the meantime see here: https://qoto.org/about/more
Read that link, it answers the questions you just asked and others. If you are still confused let me know and I'll be happy to explain further.
Seems it could just be solved by keeping the certificates but making it so you cant publicly search the certificate record. So it can only be known what caste someone is if they volunteer that information. That seems as though it would address both sets of concerns here.. though maybe im missing something.
So if im born outside of india, and thus castless, can i enter a temple that says "no untouchables"?
If i had children in india would they also lack a caste?
Wouldnt it make more sense to help people based on their ambitions, ability, and financial ability to help themselves.. if someone is poor and tries to be a good student shouldnt we help them just as quickly if htey are a low caste as we would if they were a high caste?
Similarly wouldnt the problem be simply solved by making the caste certificate system no longer searchable to the public?
So just go to your local Tehsildar office and ask for the caste of some random guy who moved in (even if he was born half way across the country) and they will provide that information as it is recorded from birth... damn.. and they still require that recorded from birth. wow....
What about me as someone who is not indian and never born into a caste of any kind. If i went to india would i be treated the same as an untouchable?
You said it is recorded on your certificate. So Birth Certificates have your caste on it and it is still the case?
So basically its just assumed based on where you currently live.. If a high caste person lost their money and moved to a poor village their children would be treated as untouchable despite their history as a higher caste?
If someone happens to gain financial freedom (I know the deck is stacked against them) and move to a different small village and move into the area of higher caste, most people would just start assuming they were of that caste as well?
If someone new to the village claimed to be of higher class, and in fact was not, where would one go to get access to the "public record" to verify that? Where is this public record stored and how to citizens query it in order to apply their prejudice?
Interesting. But how did they learn what the persons caste is when they first moved there, even if it was three generations back or something.
It seems like one of those things that would be easy to circumvent by just never telling people in the first place.
How is that discrimination enforced? If you travel to some small town and try to enter a temple, and they say you cant for being "untouchable" how do they know you are untouchable in the first place?
I think he may be just trolling and not mean what he says.. Either way im ignoring this guy now, i suggest you do the same.
Jeffrey Phillips Freeman
Innovator & Entrepreneur in Machine Learning, Evolutionary Computing & Big Data. Avid SCUBA diver, Open-source developer, HAM radio operator, astrophotographer, and anything nerdy.
Born and raised in Philadelphia, PA, USA, currently living in Utrecht, Netherlands, USA, and Thailand. Was also living in Israel, but left.
Pronouns: Sir / Mister
(Above pronouns are not intended to mock, i will respect any persons pronouns and only wish pronouns to show respect be used with me as well. These are called neopronouns, see an example of the word "frog" used as a neopronoun here: http://tinyurl.com/44hhej89 )
A proud member of the Penobscot Native American tribe, as well as a Mayflower passenger descendant. I sometimes post about my genealogical history.
My stance on various issues:
Education: Free to PhD, tax paid
Abortion: Protected, tax paid, limited time-frame
Welfare: Yes, no one should starve
UBI: No, use welfare
Racism: is real
Guns: Shall not be infringed
LGBT+/minorities: Support
Pronouns: Will respect
Trump: Moron, evil
Biden: Senile, racist
Police: ACAB
Drugs: Fully legal, no prescriptions needed
GPG/PGP Fingerprint: 8B23 64CD 2403 6DCB 7531 01D0 052D DA8E 0506 CBCE