Show newer

@zeccano TYhere is nothing wrong with asking questions, or even doubting asserted truths until you understand them.

What I'd recommend though is rather than assuming things you dont understand from some authority to be false, recognize it is perfectly ok to say "I dont know because I dont have the information yet". We shouldnt be afraid to say we dont know.

So to answer your question about "well how do we know that the gravity just doesnt effect the clock in a predictable way that winsteins equation is fitted to"... well we have to realize two things..

1) while in isolation this may be possible we have to realize it is at least a very odd coincidence and unlikely to happen very often, considering the equation was not arrived at through trial and error.

2) we confirm the equation in other ways, using other equipment that works in entierly different ways and it still agrees with the equation. One coincidence may be possible at a strech but for them all to be a coincidence is unreasonable.

For example we can also do this test using velocity difference rather than gravity difference. Considering there is no sensor that exists that could measure velocity internally (without looking at an external frame of reference) its unlikely this would have any effect mechanically on the clock internals. But even if it somehow did what are the chances that, yet again, the distortion would be exactly the same as the einstein equations.

Hell we can test it without even using clocks, for example by measuring length constriction or any of the other properties that dont have to do with time.

One coincidence I might buy but when all the different properties all match the equation when measures in a thousand different ways, well there comes a point you have to stop making excuses for what you see and except that it is how the universe works.

Finally the equation actually does involve "space time", you just think it doesnt because, as you said, you dont understand the math. The permiability of free space is the constant that represents space-times intrinsic quality to carry EM waves through it. This constant is at the heart of the einstein equations. In this way space-time is inherently a part of the equations as permiability of free space is an intrinsic property of space-time.

The non euclidean aspect is a bit hard to explain, your friend on the forumn isnt wrong mind you, he is right, but its a very tricky thing to explain simply because your getting into advanced math territory. But to put it simply, things dont really behave much differently in space than they do here. I think its best not to think about curved (non-euclidean) space time, not because its wrong, but only because its a very confusing way to see things when your just starting to learn this stuff.

@pschwede I'm not sure if a bit is a viable analogy. A bit has meaning on its own, thoughts do not, they only make sense within the entire system of thoughts (the one idea)

@pschwede you dont get ideas, you just happen to understand the "one" idea a bit more than you did before :)

@esperera_98 Thats what I've been saying all along, clearly I need a better mirror!

@pschwede I dont think those two options represent a distinction, as such only one idea, but that one idea encompasses everything.

@Sphinx Most call it holland, the whole country. Strictly speaking Holland is only a region in the NL. There are a small minority of dutch people who actively dislike the term holland as being used for the whole country, mostly the people outside of holland proper.

@pschwede None of these options are correct, the correct answer would be "only one"

I miss my Opossum friend back in the states. He lived in a little house i made for him in the yard though he was wild. I almost had him eating out of my hand when I left.

friends don't ask friends to install proprietary software

@p

Your counter argument really doesnt address mine. WD-40 was originally patented, knowing that they would get a patent for a period before running out is more than enough motivation to invent.

I never said that patents needed to be made perpetual to be an incentive. They should have a limited time period, just as they do now, and that is enough to be an incentive.

The whole point is you have a period of time you make a shit ton of money, then after that you still make money (As the brand leader) but you will make much less. Sure its still worth to sell it and make it, but thats only because the patent period already covered your bills (and some extra) for the cost to invent it in the first place.

@design_RG @teknonomicon

There was a guy once who make x/0 = ø then use that everywhere. But his way of doing it was mostly nonsense.

@bulent lol, well im not sure if the teaching is valuable for the time invested or not. I change my mind on that from day to day.

@teknonomicon

I'm all for reform, but i think the problem for muich of the world is we can not get to a good end through incremental change.. the changes that need to be made are harmful in isolation but beneficial when done together, and they exist across many disciplines (for example in this case welfare reform would have to happen simultaniously with healthcare reform)

@design_RG

@teknonomicon

Its very complex. if we just did away with patents and did nothing else to address the problem you would quickly find new drug discoveries would become non existant. The problem is just way more complex than that. Patents just look like its a solution in much the same way that free moneyh looks like the solution to poverty. Neither really work because they fail to address the complexity of the problem

@design_RG

@Rovine Sounds like a very cool idea.

I often consider what i'd do if i had access to go back in time. What would I bring, what knowledge would be useful to me, etc.. so many elements

For starters, in treality if any of us went to the past we would die of disease within a week. Our immune system arent adapted to the strains of virus that existed even a few hundred years ago. So like the native american's who encountered the european settlers most of us would jsut die off.

Moreover, if we survive most of our knowledge would be useless as most of it relies on tools or foundations not availible. Consider electricity for example, how would you even go about building a strong magnet, high quality copper wire, and all the other stuff you need to make an electric generator?

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.