Show newer

@cowanon well respected journals are ones that use scientific consensus, rigorous analysis and the caliber of the scientists it attracts is on par with other journals.

Journals arent always even associated with universities. Generally we dont really rank journals much. Its credible or its not. You make that call by looking more closely at its peer review process.

But ea you get the idea.

@max

Its amazing you cant see the problem with "Oh my science just proved there are 10+ more planets than we first knew about, I dont like this so quick lets redefine the word"....

@null0x0 @Vamp898@social.tchncs.de

@max

If we had kept the original definition of a planet then many more objects other than pluto would have been added to the list.. **that** is science, you observe facts, and as you do you admit the consequences of that.

Thats not how it went down with pluto however. There was nothing in the definition of a planet that would exlude Pluto at the time. Yes, lots of people did want to exclude pluto at the time, but this was motivated more by their bias to not include other objects in the list of planets, rather than strictly adhering to science and admitting they were, in fact, planets as well.

What happened was because scientists felt uncomfortable with the existing definition which would cause us to have dozens or more planets within our solar system, they wanted to change the definition because they arbitrarily decided they wanted there to be relatively few planets. So instead of using the data to dictate what something is or is not (science) they went the other way around, changed the definition of the word and therefore redefined what was and was not a planet not through science but an arbitrary act of linguistics.

IF we use the original language for planet, the one that was used prior to 2006, then pluto would simply have been called a "Secondary planet" (along with several other bodies) and the other planets we know of would be "primary planets". This would of course, as a distinction, would have been science, not linguistics, since it was based off discovery rather than an arbitrary act of linguistic gymnastics.

@null0x0 @Vamp898@social.tchncs.de

@max

Few decades off there buddy...

I guess when you dont have a leg to stand on the only thing you have left to resort to is name calling... way to go, I guess that is going to be the hill you die on.

@null0x0 @Vamp898@social.tchncs.de

Is Pluto a planet?

@max

Not all consensus is science, all good science involves consensus.

This was not science it was consensus, the fact that science does involve consensus is irrelevant to that.

This was us deciding what we wanted the definition of a word to be, again, that has nothing to do with science.

We didnt discover or learn anything new about planets that resulted in this change. We made the change for no other reason then we liked the new definition better.

Again that isnt science.

You seem to be under the impression we learned something new about pluto and then from that determined it wasnt a planet.. No thats not what happened at all. We knew for a VERY long time about plutos orbit and its nature.

We changed a definition of a word, thats it, nothing was discovered that caused the change.

I think you dont understand why or what happened that caused planet to be redefined...

@null0x0 @Vamp898@social.tchncs.de

@max

Well no its not. Science is not anyting that involves consensus, that is just democracy. They are defining a word here, and not based off any discovery or anything we learned experimentally.

We redefined the word because we liked the new definition better, because it felt more "useful" to us. That isnt science, nothing about that has much to do with science really, its just linguistics.

What is unique here is they decided to appropriate an existing word, and redefine it to mean something similar but new. Usually when we need new vocabulary words in science for convenience we dont redefine words already in common usage (particularly among non-scientists). We create new ones.

But yea, in the end, this wasnt really a scientific process in any meaningful way.

@null0x0 @Vamp898@social.tchncs.de

@freemo All the parts needed to build this keyboard, in one page. Some options regarding case desired.

keyhive.xyz/corne

@chikara The issue being that words are defined by usage, not committees.

@design_RG Nope, single man. Would be too hard to narrow down my love for the women in my life down to any one woman exclusively. Luckily I am honest about that fact so no guilt either :)

@design_RG I'm usually too drunk to be bothered :) I love weddings, as long as it isnt my own :)

I have a hankering to do something with linear algebra or at least something with imaginary numbers..

"Weddings are basically funerals with cake." -- Rick & Morty

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.