Show newer

@miguel31416 I'm sure some people might incorrectly see it as a mockery. Then again I'd say pronouns like "Xhe" which are also popular with some people would have a far greater tendency to be seen as a mockery, though just as incorrect in that assumption.

If someone wants to incorrectly see something I do as a mockery, especially considering how vocally supportive I am of the LGBT and specifically Trans community, well, thats on them. Its not my job to stop people from drawing false conclusions.

@Drew@radical.town

That wouldn't work, it would still notify the person they follow and open them up to attacks from them.

I know for me the way I mostly use subscriptions is to follow accounts that I think is worth seeing the content so I can call them out on prejudice or hateful speech but without following them, which they might take as a sign of endorsement or otherwise use against me.

I, as do other users, have every right to privacy and protection in that situation.

@arteteco

@Drew@radical.town

You said if i had anything constructive to add I should.. so I do have one other point.

Subscriptions are a protection of our users privacy more than it is a violation of yours. So it is a privacy-minded feature.

A person has a right to keep who they follow private from the public, and even from the people they wish to follow. It is not uncommon someone is attacked for following someone. Subscriptions allow for the protection of a users privacy so they are not forced to share who they follow or need to deal with the oppression or attacks that may go with that.

@arteteco

@eletrotupi

In fact the more I think about it the more I realize mister is really never, in and of itself, used to show hierarchy in modern society. Though there is a closely related practice that is. That is, when one person shows more respect to the other than what is given in return. This respect can be expressed in many ways, one of which is using language that denotes respect to the other where that language isnt returned, such as the use of the term "mister" or "sir". Similar practices are using someones last name where they use your first name. In some asian cultures it is expressed by how deeply you bow, one person bowing deeper than the other.

But this is not the same as saying mister denotes hierarchy, in and of itself it doesnt.

@Drew@radical.town

@eletrotupi

When I get a letter in the mail to go to court and it is addressed to Mr. Freeman" IS the court telling me I am superior to the court? No

Yes sometimes, in some contexts it is used to mean hierarchy, the vast majority of the time it does not. In fact it is considered proper in any formal conversation to use mister regardless of hierarchy and typically goes both ways in polite, formal, discourse.

So yes I do recognize that in a select number of situations it could be used as a sign of hierarchy, however the majority of times it is not, and this is the way in which it is used here.

You also forget this isnt one way, you can request I use any pronouns you wish as well, so if you want to be called Sir, Mister, Madam, or any other respectful pronoun I would honor it in return, clearly demonstrating there is no hierarchy.

@Drew@radical.town

@Drew@radical.town

I'm sorry you feel I'm talking past you. PErhaps you can explain what you mean by that so I can try to stop doing it.

If you are just refering back tot he fact that we brought the already existing RSS functionality into the client itself as subscription.. then yes I suppose we are done unless you have new information to add on that I cant possibly see how it is a privacy violation.

@arteteco

@Drew@radical.town No one is trying to own you.

Generally when we use language what matters is the meaning of the words in the here and now. Sometimes that is effected by the past in various ways, language is weird, often the modern day meaning has little resemblance to what it meant 500 years ago.

I am using those terms in the way the general public uses it, nothing more. The fact that it was used in some cultures int he past to denote a hierarchy is largely unrelated to its modern day use.

As for it not being a pronoun, thats a different issue. As with most words it would depend on how it is used. Int he sentence "Mister Freeman talks too much" Mister would **not** be a pronoun, you are right, however in the sentence "You talk too much mister" then it would be a pronoun. Remember a pronoun is a word that acts as a noun but is a substitution for a proper noun. In that sentence mister would be in its pronoun form.

@Drew@radical.town

To repeat, the way in which we archive posts is exacty the same as radical.town and all other mastodon instances. So if you have concerns about how the data is archived it has little to do with QOTO and is an issue for the wider fediverse community. I'd be happy to hear whatever solutions you might want to propose.

@arteteco

@MOTT So you can stay up to date about a persons posts who you may not want to follow.

@Drew@radical.town

How so? Our archival practices are the same as all Mastodon clients. The only thing that makes us unique is that we have a VERY high federation score (we federate with virtually the whole fediverse), and we dont clear out cache. But its just normal mastodon in terms of archival features.

In what way do you feel we are the same as they are?

@arteteco

@Drew@radical.town It can be used to show authority but that is not its only use. It also is equally valid as a sine of respect towards someone who does not have any authority. This is the way in which I mean it, to denote respect, not authority.. Mister, abbreviated Mr is a common title of respect, not authority. Sir is sometimes used for authority, but more often it is just a sign of respect.

I agree I am no better than you, nor am I above you in any hierarchy.

I will provide the definitions here so you can see it does not imply hierarchy or authority (At least the definitions I am using).

Just to be clear here is the definition of Mister:

an informal form of address for a man

And the definition of Sir:

used as a usually respectful form of address

@Drew@radical.town Whats up? I'm not being sarcastic, if you have concerns I'd like to hear it.

@Drew@radical.town Why does this upset you? I want pronouns that denote respect, same reason i use the gender pronouns other ask for, respect. Do you find this wrong? Do you not feel you would want to respect my pronouns?

@Drew@radical.town Why does this upset you? I want pronouns that denote respect, same reason i use the gender pronouns other ask for, respect. Do you find this wrong? Do you not feel you would want to respect my pronouns?

@Drew@radical.town Unfortunately the fediverse is a open standard (activitypub). The standard itself does not define protected accounts in the way you wish. There are many clients out there of various flavors most of wich do not handle protected accounts in the way you wish it to be handled.

Within this standard the only real option you have is to post things as follower only, if you post publicly, according to the standard, you are giving people permission to view the post. Neither the standard now priacy concerns grant you the ability to tell other people how or if they can automate their own client.

You cant expect or demand that everyone run a client identical to mastodon. A lof of the fediverse isnt mastodon.

@Drew@radical.town Allowing someone to be notified of a post they otherwise have permission to see, that you granted them permission to see, is not an invasion of your privacy. If you make something public you are explicitly stating it is not private.

Removing an invoice from others (the need to manually go to your feed to read it) is not a violation of your privacy IMO. You still have complete control over the privacy of your posts.

@Drew@radical.town Nope, you misunderstood.

If someone subscribes to an account they can **only** see the posts they would be able to see by manually going to the account and viewing the timeline. In other words, public posts. Your follow-only posts are still protected. The subscription system just allows you to see those posts in your home timeline rather than needing to manually go to the user's timeline to see it.

Likewise search results will not show up that you dont have permission to otherwise see.

Hope that puts your concerns to rest.

@Drew@radical.town @arteteco @mngrif @design_RG

Wait what, we have strict rules against ban evasion... who is dodging bans?

@feld

I'd be happy to show you peer reviewed studies that show wait times in many socialistic countries are months longer than in the USA, I'm a data scientist after all I can backup what I say and I pick m words carefully.

They passed peer review so not really sure what you mean by "debunked" but your welcome to counter them if you have evidence sure.

@sean

@feld

My words were very specific.. you said I made a bald face lie, please quote the phrase you think is a lie.

I'm not sure what Australia being #1 in "outcomes" whatever that means contradicts with anything I said, so really I have no idea what your saying right now, sorry. Please be more specific so I can understand you and I'll try to respond again.

@sean

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.