@prasoon Do you happen to have any better figures to compare?
I've seen different figures to approach this problem and while admitidly they do vary wildly it seems in most cases the tax evasion of the middle class and poor tends to be much higher than that of the rich.
If you think about it makes sense really. If you dont make much money its pretty easy to get away with working under the table. No one will ever even know. Ont he flip side its hard to do when your dealing in billions. Just think of all the lower income people you know who work under the table and cheat on 100% of their taxes. Rich people lying on taxes happens too sadly, but they have a lot more eyes on them and a lot more to risk, so they would naturally do less of it.
Obviously if you have any figures that might contradict what I'm saying I'd love to see it.
@prasoon If you truly just mean the whole of the informal economy.. namely those businesses the government cant regulate because there is no paper trail.
That absolutely is still tax avoidance. If someone is washing windows on a street corner they are legally obligated to report their income ont heir tax returns. But since ther eis no paper trail if they lie, while technically illegal, they can be certain they wont be persecuted. So they can easily get away with it.
But it is still absolutely tax evasion and is technically illegal even though impossible to actually enforce.
Just because they can get away with it doesnt make it any less of a Tax Evasion.
@prasoon Before I respond to this see my earlier question.
@prasoon informal economy tends to be a bit of a loaded term that can mean anything from, a job that is illegal and thus can not be taxed in any meaningful way, to jobs that technically require you to post your wages, but easily slip under the radar (such as washing windows on a street corner).
Can you give examples of jobs you consider part of the informal economy that would not be tax avoidance?
taxes, uspol
Sorry billion, your right.
So few things here to clarify, not that its wrong, but it misses some important detail..
The 37% figure isnt entierly accurate. first off is that they arent just paying fecderal tax (where the 27% figure comes from) but both State and loca tax. In practice that jumps the figure up much much higher. Somewhere in the 50%+ range (I dont have the tables in front of me).
Second, that figure only applies to income earned due to a paycheck or salary. It is not the figure payed by billionaires who earn a huge portion of their income through other means (stocks, dividends, etc), so overall is not very accurate in terms of what they are paying out on their total personal revenue stream.
As to the figure of 1% of the population paying a whoping quarter of the total taxes collected by the government.. thats **huge** and far too high IMO.
to your last point about inequality, I view that very different. Money isnt a pie, some people having more doesnt mean others have to have less. So framing it as inequality isnt really accurate to me. A better measure would be wage mobility, how easy is it for the middle class or poor to become rich, and vice versa. Thats the true measure of fairness. While I'd say there is certainly some work to be done in that area, and I absolutely support better welfare programs to improve that aspect, the truth is of everyone ont he fotune 500 list over half are self-made billionairs that started life as middle or lower class individuals. so I'd say the system is alot closer to fair than people might recognize.
I am insulted tat you would even suggest that! Dont lump me in with that species!
@J@gameliberty.club @igeljaeger @jasonl8446
Speak for yourself, what makes you think I have a life!
@J@gameliberty.club @igeljaeger @jasonl8446
Sometimes the literal interpretation of the words doesn't always reflect the definition. But I can see why it might seem that way.
@igeljaeger @J@gameliberty.club @jasonl8446
Interesting fact of the day:
In the USA current estimates have the total Tax Avoidance of the top 1% wealthy at 500 million per year collectively or 5 trillion per decade.
By comparison the total tax avoidance of all the middle class and poor who work under the table totals about 2 trillion per year, four times more.
Remind me again how the rich avoiding taxes are the main problem?
Sources:
https://www.cnbc.com/2019/11/19/tax-avoidance-by-the-rich-could-top-5-trillion-in-next-decade.html
Apparently the Democrat voters have gotten so brain dead they actually think Trump said the Coronavirus is a hoax. Literally about 15 seconds on snopes would have debunked that one for you, yet somehow they are so used to buying the manipulative lies flying around they dont even question it and you hear them repeating this nonsense.
Americans really are unbearable in large doses.
It was a pleasure on this end as well. Thanks for the good exchange.
@J@gameliberty.club @igeljaeger @stevenroose
Well the malicious intent part isnt untrue, but its more of a consequence of the mechanics of it than inherent to what slander is. In order for there to be civil legal action (the domain slander operates in) then there needs to be someone who was financially damaged by it. It isnt that there needs to be malicious intent, only that the result must be damaging in order to be actionable as a civil suit (otherwise who are you even going to sue?).
I think this becomes evident if we look at the definition of slander from a law dictionary specifically in which case we can see a similar but more appropriate definition in line with what I said:
Oral defamation, in which someone tells one or more persons an untruth about another, which untruth will harm the reputation of the person defamed.
@J@gameliberty.club @igeljaeger @stevenroose
Whether hatespeech is opinion really depends on how we are defining hate speech.
If you simply have a racist opinion, while we may agree that is unacceptable speech morally speaking, it isnt strictly speaking hate speech in my opinion.
To cross over into being hate speech there has to be some nature of "attacking" the person int he speech for it to be hateful. Despite the name I dont think "I hate you" is hate speech. but if you said "I hope you die" might be.
I think ther eis a fine but blurry line between a respectful opinion and explicit hate speech, even though there may be immoralities on either side of that line.
If it is your opinion that peope should start a riot, that is not a call to action, so no.. You would have to say 'Everyone here, lets riot!" then you are expressing a call to actiont hat goes beyond a simple opinion. So yes these are strongly different.
As for not all lies being slander, that part I agree with. To qualify as slander the person saying the lie needs to know it is a lie at the time they say it, or there needs to be reasonable evidence to suggest the person most likely knew it was a lie. Now to actually be legally actionable you have to actually hurt someone with that lie, or else there is nothing to actually sue for. But either way it is not protected speech.
@J@gameliberty.club @igeljaeger @stevenroose
Jeffrey Phillips Freeman
Innovator & Entrepreneur in Machine Learning, Evolutionary Computing & Big Data. Avid SCUBA diver, Open-source developer, HAM radio operator, astrophotographer, and anything nerdy.
Born and raised in Philadelphia, PA, USA, currently living in Utrecht, Netherlands, USA, and Thailand. Was also living in Israel, but left.
Pronouns: Sir / Mister
(Above pronouns are not intended to mock, i will respect any persons pronouns and only wish pronouns to show respect be used with me as well. These are called neopronouns, see an example of the word "frog" used as a neopronoun here: http://tinyurl.com/44hhej89 )
A proud member of the Penobscot Native American tribe, as well as a Mayflower passenger descendant. I sometimes post about my genealogical history.
My stance on various issues:
Education: Free to PhD, tax paid
Abortion: Protected, tax paid, limited time-frame
Welfare: Yes, no one should starve
UBI: No, use welfare
Racism: is real
Guns: Shall not be infringed
LGBT+/minorities: Support
Pronouns: Will respect
Trump: Moron, evil
Biden: Senile, racist
Police: ACAB
Drugs: Fully legal, no prescriptions needed
GPG/PGP Fingerprint: 8B23 64CD 2403 6DCB 7531 01D0 052D DA8E 0506 CBCE