Show newer

@terryenglish

You also might want to take a minute and reflect on who is the condescending prick here...

YOU were the one who told me the notion of wealth generation is "absurd" and were quite condescending in your response to it.

Now your throwing a childish temper tantrum because I used a simple illustration to demonstrate why your wrong and even basic understand disagrees with you.

While I wouldnt call you a waste of space having the maturity of a child coupled with the fact that you were a condescending ass and then have a fit the second you get called out on it and proven wrong.. well I'd say of the two of us you're the one wasting **my** time.

Yes I can happily continue along without you a part of this conversation, thankfully.

Don't let the door hit you on the way out.

@realcaseyrollins @design_RG

@terryenglish Of course its mroe complicated than Econ 101, how is that statement relevant..

You claimed the idea that wealth gets generated as absurd, I showed a very simple example to disprove that. Obviously in the real world the dynamics are much more complex but that doesnt change the fact that you were wrong, wealth is, in fact, generated as a normal part of any economy.

@terryenglish

Well whether it is true or not is of course going to be hard to prove. But the fact is the rich give a larger*percentage* of their income to charity than middle class does, even if you normalize for just the percentage of income they have beyond their need to live.

So what little statistics I have to test the assumption suggests the rich are more generous to those in need than the poor or middle class is.

With that said, I dont think we can really objectively measure it and I find that to be a shallow measurement. So if i rely just on my gut mixed in with the evidence I'd suggest both groups are probably equally as generous.

As for the second point, you seemed to completely misunderstand what I said. I am not suggesting that there isnt a quantifiable amount of wealth in the world, there is. Obviously you if you have a certain amount of money in the bank you can only afford to spend as much as you have. So quite obviously you would need to cut spending to afford certain things. That has **nothing** to do with what I just said.

Wealth can and is generated, but it isnt generated out of thin air. We arent talking about just printing up some money and wham you have more wealth.

This is economics 101 so not only is it not absurd it is the accepted reality from anyone who has every studied wealth to any degree. I will explain it with an oversimplified example so you can understand how it works.

Imagine a world with only two people in it. I have 100$ in cows and 100$ in cash as well. Someone else has 200$ in cow feed. At the start this world has 400$ in it total, that is the fixed amount of wealth at that moment in time. If the person with the cows pays 100$ to buy the feed from the other person I now have no cash but I have 100$ in cows and 100$ in feed, the other person has 100$ and 100$ in feed. The total amount of wealth in the world is still 400$, everyone has the amount they had before, no one had to take any wealth from anyone else. But now I can feed my cows, I couldnt before. In 10 years thanks to the food I have I now have ten times the number of cows I owned before as they bred and were well fed. So in 10 years my 100$ in cows is now 1000$ in cows and I lost my 100$ in feed. Presuming the other person still has his 200$ the world now has 1200$ of wealth in it instead of 400$ of wealth it had 10 years earlier.

More importantly though 10 years ago me and the other guy both had the same amount of money. but now 10 years later I have 5x mroe wealth than the other guy.. yet I didnt take a penny from anyone, I **generated** that wealth in those 10 years and i am 5x richer than the other guy not because I took from him, but because I generated the wealth to make it so.

Its a simple concept, the fact that you think it "absurd" I think shows just how indoctrinated you are to a narrative even though it is so easily disproven with what we know of economies and wealth.

@realcaseyrollins @design_RG

@stux

If a user doesnt setup their own password then yes, you'd always be relying on the external service. which also means that external service has some degree of power over your users.

Again this is why I said I wouldn't necceseraly suggest that configuration.

@se7en

@terryenglish

sure but there are still some pretty gaping holes in that logic.

For starters the evil poor and middle class people dont have any less greed or desire to hoard away money. They are just not as effective at carrying out their intention. So the distinction is mostly virtual.

Second, just because you have a lot of wealth does not mean you hoarded it or took it from anyone else. Wealth is not a pie where someone having more means someone else needs less. Wealth is generated and destroyed constantly in large quantity. It is entirely possible, and even common, to be rich and having generated the wealth you have, in fact its entirely possible for a rich person to have generated more wealth than they own (meaning they have given more than they have taken from others).

So the logic fails on both points really.

@realcaseyrollins @design_RG

@stux

depends entierly on how you configure it. Its not uncommon to rely on the external service to authenticate without needing a local password of any kind. Though that isnt necessarily the setup I'd recommend if you went with a SSO solution.

@se7en

@stux

Not far enough to have anything useful. Was going to use SSO from github, gitlab, google, and LDAP to unify the services here. But was too much of an undertaking for the time i had.

@se7en

@stux

yes i would use that feature if it were available. I myself wouldnt use it to login but I would want my users empowered to be able to decide for themselves if they wished to use it or not.

I've looking into implementing SSO before in fact.

@se7en

@stux

If you gave them a password that you use on other servers that absolutely could be an issue. But that has nothing to do with the mastodon feature itself (which doesnt expose any sensitive data).

With that said you absolutely should be using a unique per-site password so that would not be an issue with keybase or any other service in the future.

@se7en

@se7en

I didnt say there was no risks with zoom conferencing, there are plenty. We are talking about keybase here, not zoom conferencing software.

Keybase only works with your public key, they arent even given access at any point to non-public data.

@stux

@terryenglish

Hatred for a lot of things doesnt come from "nowhere" so im not sure I'd use that much as ana rgument.

I have considered the scale argument before but it breaks down really quickly when you consider it. Sure if you consider one evil poor person vs one evil rich person it may seem that way, but in reality thats not how it works.

For every one evil billionair there are hundreds of thousands of evil poor and middle class people to match them. In the end the scale of all evil poor and middle class people is absolutely comparable in scale and effect as compared to all evil rich people. In fact I wouldnt be surprised if the collective results of evil non-rich people were to far outweigh that of rich people.

I understand the line of reasoning, but I find it faulty and ultimately caused not by the reasons given, that's just how people justify it to themselves, but rather from the desire to place the blame on any person or class of people that isnt themselves.

Most people dont do accountability too well, always has to be someone else it seems.

@realcaseyrollins @design_RG

@stux I dont like zoom either. but again, what would you accomplish other than to take away a useful feature that poses no security risk of any kind...

Is the point just to let the world know you dont like zoom? I mean I guess thats fine, but I really dont see the point other than to take away cryptographic self-identity from users, a useful feature.

@stux if someone mistrusts keybase what advantage would there be to shut it off? I cant see what you would hope to accomplish.

@terryenglish

Some rich do, some rich dont, just as some poor and middle class use it to theri own advantage and some dont.

Humans are shitty, you will find shitty humans in every class and every denomination. But to say the rich are somehow uniquely responsible for such things is absurd given the overwhelming evidence of people from every class acting just as deplorable.

But of course the poor and middle class wont take that responsibility, they would rather just blame the rich. Same story as forever, the majority will always demonize the minority.

@realcaseyrollins @design_RG

@iankenway some people have a rebel phase, others a squid ink pasta phase I guess :)

The taste is subtle enough, I barely notice it. Really needs a proper squid ink sauce IMO.

@realcaseyrollins

I have to agree with you there. When I hear people blame the rich its usually just a desire to have some evil entity to blame rather than accepting the general public are accountable for their own decisions. Though the left-wing I feel uses it even more specifically as a way to rally against a non-existant enemy. a way for them to justify increasing taxes ever upwards towards absurdity rather than being accountable for their own financial waste which could easily be resolved if they were more responsible in their spending.

I'm not even talking about social programs. They could easily cut defense spending in half, give everyone including the rich a tax cut, and still have more than enough money to cover their social programs. But that would require them to actually admit that all rich people arent evil after all.

@design_RG

@rimugu Is till have mine. Sadly most of the math I do these days wouldnt be useful to use even a modern day calculator anymore. So I dont get to use it often. But I wish I had a use for it.

@chris Later models came in different form factors but largely the same. Here is a later version of the same model.

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.