Show newer

@vnarek There are plenty of liberals who want to ban guns completely. Mostly only want to highly increase regulations, either way it is contrary to individual rights.

Abortion is also a bad example, liberals want to support the individual right and liberty of the mother, and conservatives want to support the individual rights and liberty of the baby. Both are trying to secure individual rights, they only differ on whose rights matter.

When it comes to transgendered I would agree that conservatives have a rose track record on individual rights than the neoliberals do, but tahts the only exception I can think of.

@vnarek Irrelevant, the numbers I cited were **percentages** of GDP, meaning it was already normalized for population.

If you look in terms of raw money the USA pays **many** orders of magnitude more than switzerland for social programs. We dont use that measure specifically because, as you say, we need to normalize for population.

As I pointed out once you factor in the difference in population the spending on welfare programs are nearly identical.

@vnarek neo-liberalism would be effectively what you see as modern day liberals in most countries but especially the US.

Lets take the definition of liberal you gave (which i described as classically liberal):

* free economy without government intervention

* individual rights as a priority

If we look at most self described liberrals today they embody the opposite of both these qualities where they are central to modern day conservatives (thus the use of the term neo to distinguish them).

For example conservatives tend to be strongly pro-free market, they are against regulations on the free market in many forms, conservatives tend to be against enviromental regulations for example, and minimum wage, and similar examples of the government regulating the flow of money. Meanwhile increasing minimum wage, or forcing companies to hire minorities tend to be strong central points for liberals.

The other point of individual rights also apply. conservatives tend to support individual rights tot he extream for example extream forms of freedom of speech, and even the right to own weaponry, generally opposed by neoliberals to various extends.

@vnarek Another point, while the USA is lower than most of europe in terms of percentage of GDP spent on welfare, it is very very close, as to be almost marginal.

For example the USA spends 19.3% of its GDP on welfare and social programs, switzerland however spends only 19.7%.

So this argument is fairly weak considering how marginally different the two are.

@vnarek Yes the wikipedia uses the classical definition of liberal. This is not what most people in the USA today mean when they say liberal, they usually mean neo-liberal, which is effectively the opposit of that.

Free economy (free markets) with minimal government intervention would be more in line with modern day conservatisim in america, or classical liberals

They are very confusing terms for that very reason.

The spending is a relevant point, of course, to some degree. Except I wouldnt argue welfare as being the same as redistribution of wealth.. a flat (or flatter) tax system that feeds those who starve isnt really redistributing wealth to any significant degree. That just keeps the poor from starving and does little to nothing to eliminating the rich from the population.

@kravietz Yes it always amazes me how no matter where you are in the world the groups which lean strongly towards one agenda or another (label themselves as left or right adamatly) tend to be completely clueless as to the reality of the situation.

Politics around the world is more about propaganda than facts, sadly.

but yea, I pay a much lower tax rate overall in europe than I would in America. Like I said I know a great many people who have fled america to livein Europe and paying less taxes and being at the top of the tax bracket is something I hear quite often.

But in other ways too, europe is far more conservative (aka, small government, less intervention and regulations) when it comes to foreign affairs too, as is seen by the fact that they have fewer military bases around the world and invest less money in trying to regulate or intervene in other countries as well.

@kravietz yes im aware of that, and that is exactly my point. When all things considered the tax in europe is less progressive than in the USA. See my last post for examples.

@kravietz Sure, we can do that...

So basically the "left" is the side who tends to focus on redistribution of wealth via progressive taxation. In other words, having an extremely high tacx burden on the rich in an attempt to redistribute wealth from the rich to the poor.

Therefore if we measure this phenominon by comparing the tax burden of the highest tax class compared to that of the lowest tax class, you find there is a greater difference between the two in the USA than in Europe.

I am in the highest tax bracket both in the USA and in the Netherlands where I now live, I've also worked in a few other countries.

The total taxes I have to pay in the USA if you consider **all** taxes (local, state, income, property, all of it) I pay significantly higher taxes at the highest tax bracket than I do in europe. Furthermore there is more of a difference between the taxes paid by the lowest tax bracket and the highest than there is in most of europe.

In effect when you factor in all taxes the USA tax system is in fact more progressive than the european system, typically.

@kravietz I am using the more modern day USA usage of the terms than the traditional one you are likely thinking of.

Generally when people use liberal or conservative today they really mean neoliberal or neo-conservative. in fact neo-liberal would be classical conservative and a neo-conservative would be classically liberal. So they are admittedly confusing terms.

Might be easier if you just consider what i said in terms of left=liberal and right = conservative

@vnarek
Well its important to understand what liberal and conservative mean. I think they tend to be inaccutate terms since liberal generally is used to refer to neoliberals specifically. In other words liberal is generally used as a synonym for democratic socialism. The primary principles of liberalism and socialism is a large degree of government regulation and oversight as well as using taxation to redistribute wealth from the rich. Conservatism generally has at its central point the opposite, minimal government regulation and intervention and relying on free markets.

Taxation is relevant as the usa has a more progressive tax scheme, that ia, a scheme intending to put a higher tax ratio between poor and rich in an attempt to redistribute wealth.

We find the same pattern in other areas. Europe is generally much more noninterventionist when it comes to foreign affairs, which again is along the lines of small governance associated with the right.

@hansw@mastodon.social Health insurance is horrific in the USA, but having used health insurance in the EU I can say its pretty horrific there just in different ways.

For example your chance of survive cancer in the USA is much higher than in the EU, wait times in the EU are also significantly longer than in the USA and often results in preventable injury or death (as was the case for me)

I find it ironic that most people see europe as more liberal than the USA yet most people I know who move there are staunch conservatives who move there because the policies they care about and the people themselves are overall **less** liberal than the USA.

It seems very few people even realize that by many measures europe is more conservative rather than liberal. A prime example of this would be the taxation scheme which in much of europe has a lower ratio between the poor and the rich classes (closer to flat tax).

Experiment to demonstrate how germs spread using fluorescent light.

@comphys yea its usually inevitable anyway. Unless your working really close to the noise floor seperation of grounds tend to be pointless and sometimes even counter productive

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.