@HappyWizard Yes I have read the Sepher Yetzirah and many religious texts from countless religions. Studying, or at least reading up on the technical details, of various religions is an interest of mine.
I mostly focus on the more obscure and older religious texts. The abrahamic religions arent my main focus. but I do feel i needed a foundation in the three major religions if i wanted to seriously study the more obscure religions and have a useful context with which to draw on.
@hansw@mastodon.social I guess it depends in how it is used to describe nature or to thank people. I do agree there is a **lot** of religious ways of speaking that are ultimately distasteful and really dont do any good. but I also think there is a way to discuss religion, even in the ways you describe, that can be useful and instightful, sadly a minority of people are capable of it is all.
@vnarek yea, vox isnt really "political" but has a clear left lean.. seems they hit many topics but they do have many political videos.
The stuff they do that is non political isnt too horrible, some of its pretty decent. Just saying their political stuff (and there is a decent amount of that) is about as bad as PU but on the left.
@hansw@mastodon.social
I dont really think a persons education is complete without the understanding of religion. If you do not discuss and understand religion then your education has huge gaps in terms of history and philosophy that will seriously hinder a persons potential.
I am not suggesting you need to **believe** in religion mind you. Nor do I think its healthy for one person to try to prostelatize their religion onto anyone else. but understanding the history, nature, reasoning, practice, and technical aspects of religion is absolutely vital for any scholarly or educated person in my view.
To not discuss religion, at least in an object and critical way, would do everyone a disservice.
What you describe sounds like a bunch of religious judgemental fools. I do not, however, feel it encompasses the end result of all discussions regarding religious topics.
@vnarek Yes. i'd say the mirror image of PragerU would be Vox, and pretty much all of their content is equally biased and inaccurate in much the same way the PU video was (that is, they throw in a few accurate facts but have such a strong agenda they have to fill in the gaping holes with bullshit).
As a practical example take this Vox video trying to claim race doesnt exist: https://youtu.be/VnfKgffCZ7U
Like the PU video it makes some valid points, for example how historically race was used as a weapon against minorities and to distinguish one race as superior, totally valid part of the argument. But the rest of the claim is completely unfounded in science.
Race is, generally, scientifically accepted. We have objective ways genetically to identify race. Second, the examples they use are loaded and overall inaccurate. For exampel they talk about "white" being redefined over history as a way to suggest race doesnt exist. except "white" is, simply speaking, not a race. A race has to do with geographic origin so you could say "european" is a race, which might be vaguely similar to saying "white", but subtly different and important. We can show through genetic means objectively that someone is of european origin, but white has no meaning, a russian, would generally be described as "white" on inspection but unless your a far-western russian you arent likely to be "european".
In the end I'd say the video I linked from left-leaning vox is on pretty much the same level of inaccuracy as the PU video you linked.
@vnarek yea if we are just talking about "should a country seperate church froms tate" they really didnt make a single valid point to argue that in either direction.. They only point they made that was valid and somewhat accurate was a description of the history of it in the USA.
@dyvulgativa We a should at least tag the other moderators here since they play a large role in this discussion. Though they will prefer to comment in discourse as would I since that is where we keep a more official record of it all
@vnarek Ok got through it, that video was ups and down for me...
I agree with the one criticism you made earlier, that the ending was weak and not really well rooted in fact.. To claim marriage, crime, and all the ills of society is due to the removing of religion from our government is... well.. a weak argument as presented. We also have doubled our life expectancy, is that too due to seperated of church and state? There arent too many pirates around these days either? Yea the connection at the end was baseless, weak, and totally ruined the reputable nature of the rest of the argument.
With that said, the video had slant and an agenda, when you have such an agenda you get shitty arguments like that to fill in the gaps. Its the same pattern i see in most strongly left-leaning videos. When your that desperate to make an all encompassing point your going to have some pretty big gaps to fill with bullshit.
But there also are a lot of very good abnd valid points in the video, so a video with bias agenda and bullshit, sure, but about as decent as you can get when you have lean (no worse than left leaning stuff like i said)..
For example they **were** correct that the modern notion of church and state is largely a fabrication and the constitution itself had no intention of such a separation. The only original intent is that a law would be unable to restrict religion or give any single religion precedence. But nothing about the constitution or its wording would, for example, prevent prayer in schools, or prevent a bible verse from being printed on a government building. So they made some valid points in that regard as well.
I think its a good quality video in the sense that if your looking for lean right or left, thats probably about as good as it could get. If you want something truely accurate without any gaping holes you'd have to ditch the lean in the first place.
@vnarek I'm 2 seconds in and he said that separation of church and state isnt in the constitution... I really hope he mentioned the first amendment soon... Or how the bill of rights was defined by the founding fathers and not just tacked on as a later evolution... I hope this gets better, but not a good start...
@vnarek watching
Its been over a decade and this shit never gets old.
Every time one of my russian friends comes over I sing this to announce hsi arrival
@vnarek do you have a video of that PU video on church and state that you thought was poorly done. I'd like to see it. Might give me an idea on if i agree with you that PU went down hill or if i feel it might be due to your own bias (regardless of where I stand on an issue even if i disagree with an argument I can sometimes still give a source credit that the argument was attempted expertly).. might help for you to get a second opinion from someone who isnt left wing?
thank you but im not worried about his account at all. I just wanted him to be aware of the situation since it would effect him and so he can voice his opinion on it if he wishes.
His account is welcome here.
@vnarek I suppose that ultimately depends on just how easily your views can be challenged in the first place.
I cant speak for you but I usually find most left-wing people are quite dismissive of anything right win even when good arguments are made. Though I also find most right-wing individuals are equally dismissive of left-wing ideas.
I dont know you personally but it may have more to do with your own intolerance of right-wing ideas than the specific way PU presents it (though i havent checked on PU in a while, perhaps their quality went down hill).
I also am probably a bit unusual in the sense that I usually find both left and right wing politics make good arguments, and bad arguments and that most well thought out solutions do not resemble either left or right wing agendas.
At the moment we are still tolerant of all languages, so that shouldnt be an issue. But it is a topic that is being discussed and I cant garuntee it will remain that way. Regardless we will not delete established accounts in another language if/when the rule passes.
Also, if we do decide to restrict accounts to english only we will likely make an exception for any established active accounts at the time the language restriction is put in place.
@dyvulgativa Please add your comment to the discourse thread, so it can be considered.
For now we are holding off enforcing any language restrictions.. Its been considered but we decided not to enforce it unless and until it creates an actual problem... We welcome your input in the thread:
https://discourse.qoto.org/t/final-proposal-restricting-posts-on-qoto-to-english-only/226?u=freemo
Jeffrey Phillips Freeman
Innovator & Entrepreneur in Machine Learning, Evolutionary Computing & Big Data. Avid SCUBA diver, Open-source developer, HAM radio operator, astrophotographer, and anything nerdy.
Born and raised in Philadelphia, PA, USA, currently living in Utrecht, Netherlands, USA, and Thailand. Was also living in Israel, but left.
Pronouns: Sir / Mister
(Above pronouns are not intended to mock, i will respect any persons pronouns and only wish pronouns to show respect be used with me as well. These are called neopronouns, see an example of the word "frog" used as a neopronoun here: http://tinyurl.com/44hhej89 )
A proud member of the Penobscot Native American tribe, as well as a Mayflower passenger descendant. I sometimes post about my genealogical history.
My stance on various issues:
Education: Free to PhD, tax paid
Abortion: Protected, tax paid, limited time-frame
Welfare: Yes, no one should starve
UBI: No, use welfare
Racism: is real
Guns: Shall not be infringed
LGBT+/minorities: Support
Pronouns: Will respect
Trump: Moron, evil
Biden: Senile, racist
Police: ACAB
Drugs: Fully legal, no prescriptions needed
GPG/PGP Fingerprint: 8B23 64CD 2403 6DCB 7531 01D0 052D DA8E 0506 CBCE