Show newer

As a side note i want to say im really happy to see how these topics get a lot of good respectful conversation going both here and on the discourse.

The QOTO community seems much more active lately in discussing their own policies and future with dozens of people stepping forward to add to the conversation, including people from outside the server.

Its an exciting and welcome change to see so many people engaged in respectful discourse on these issues.

@Sphinx
@Ox @arteteco @design_RG @realcaseyrollins @miguel31416

@design_RG
Im not denying the fact that most of the world has different views on guns. But there is a huge difference between someone thinking gun rights are a bad idea (most of the world) and actively being offended and appalled by the very image of a gun or a discussion about it that differs from their own opinions. People who react in this way dont represent most of the world, they represent a small minority of radicalized individuals who can not tolerate opposing views.
@Ox @Sphinx @arteteco @realcaseyrollins

@design_RG
The big deal with the poster is essentially they get less interaction on their post. Moreover it implies political lean if we CW things right leaning activists fight for (like guns). Moreover it is a fundemental shift in our policy as a free speech instance which which tries to only moderate content in the more extream scenarios.

Worse yet, the only people who are likely to raise a stink over stock gun images (violent images are another matter) would be extremely radicalized groups, the sort of people we really dont want to cave to or apologize to.

Europeaners are certainly generally against open gun rights but very few europeaners are going to be offended by the mere image of a gun on a post, if they were thry would never be able to go to the movies without being offended.

@Ox thanks for, as always, have a very reasonable and respectable viewpoint

@Sphinx @arteteco @realcaseyrollins

@realcaseyrollins

The bulk of servers do. Its simple the radicalized ones tend to be the loudest so its easy to presume they are the majority.

@design_RG @Sphinx @arteteco

@realcaseyrollins

Yes, most of the radical left servers (Which is a lot) probably fall under this description. Thankfully any radicalized servers (eft or right leaning) have likely long since silenced us.

@design_RG @Sphinx @arteteco

@stux Thats an interesting description for a choke hold, but ok :)

@design_RG @Sphinx @arteteco

I think we need to be careful about enforcing CW as a policy and choosing your own personal limits on when to post CW.

As eugene puts it, CW is mostly a contract between the user and their followers.

People being sensaitive or offended by something shouldnt really be the measure. Our current CW rules around spoilers and nudity is a functional one, it would cause harm to people in a work place setting.

If we start catering to what a person sensative to or offended by something might not like we start down a rather nasty slippery slope in my opinion.. do we CW knives, off color jokes, how about posts criticizing men-s rights movement or feminism (for example snow was greatly offended to see such posts).

On any topic there will always be people who are offended by it, and to the people who have similar views it will hurt our reputation among that group. If we begin trying to accommodate anyone who might be offended by anything we will quickly find we either need to take sides or CW everything.

@cwebber Why is that? Its generally right-leaning in my experience which may explain why?

The sin which is unpardonable is knowingly and willingly to reject truth, to fear knowledge lest that knowledge pander not to thy prejudices.

~ Aleister Crowley

This quote becomes more important every day.

@nyetoots

They are not specific to any language. The focus is on algorithms mostly.

@MutoShack

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.