Show newer

@penny

Can you give an example of a third party winning the presidential election due to a no show of a primary party? In every case I know of that is not true. But it has been a while since i reviewed the cases.

@vnarek

@vnarek

Radical in what sense? In every historic example we have of a third-party winning it always came about through a radical shift in voting that takes place over very short periods of time.

@penny

@penny

Generally we see that when third parties win it is sudden and happens over the course of only one or two elections when the people shift bases.

My hope is people will come to their senses and it will happen in the next few years.

This election we already have Handsy Joe and Prejudice donald at the reigns.. Its like watching two racist people from a nursing home with dimentia having an argument.

My hope is much more of this we might see a flip to a third party as we have seen historically. But that will only happen if people stop buying the propaganda of a two-party system.

@vnarek

@penny

then why is it possible for third parties to have won past elections, multiple times, without a change in voting?

The truth is, it isnt impossible, it just requires people to not be stupid. Which perhaps is pretty impossible in its own right, granted, but it has happened before.

@vnarek

@penny

thats no more true than any other party. It just so happens that the two major parties keep having successful campaigns because people keep insisting on giving them their money.

Their campaigns need to be just as successful, well funded, and supported as any third party would need to be. Sadly people are just gullible enough to keep supporting it.

@vnarek

@vnarek

since the USa was founded. We have parties in congress other than just republican or democrat (labeled as independents or third party seats) and they get an equal vote in any bills along with the other parties.

@penny

@penny

being a spoiler vote for an otherwise evvil candidate, even if it is the lesser of two evils, should be the goal. Especially considering there are "spoilers" on both sides.

voting for the lesser of two evils is still voting for evil.

@vnarek

@vnarek

Yes people do think like that. Just because most people are idiots isnt an excuse you should act like an idiot too though :)

In fact the only real way to dispel the two party system myth is by voting outside the two-party system, making sure the statistics around the vote show a greater split and thus breakt eh cyclic logic int he first place by demonstrating the logic is failed.

@penny

@penny

Those are all excellent examples of things that rig the system and need to be fixed. but they are separate issues to some extent and not so much examples of things that guarantee a two party system.. well not too much anyway.

There is some truth in those examples though I'll give you that. But I think thats more general corruption than corruption guaranteeing a two party system.

@vnarek

@penny

No you can have 40% vote for party A, 30% vote for party B and 30% vote for party C, and you will have a congress that represents those parties just fine. There is no requirement that everyone needs to vote for the same party for that party to see some level of success.

@vnarek

@vnarek @vnarek I really have no problem with proportional representation either.

In fact in congress itself we already have proportional representation, and congress is the more important arm of the government more so thant he president. Yet despite employing proportional representation in congress it doesnt change the fact that the vast majority is a two-party system. Because again, the fallacy persists, not because of any functional aspect to the system, thats secondary.

@penny

@penny

The failing in the logic is that everything is 50%, a dichotomy. Politics isnt broken down into left and right, thats the fallacy. Its a huge multidimensional landscape with overwhelming nuance that often doesnt fall into left and right.

Its only americans who have strived to make it that way out of ignorance.

@vnarek

@penny

the world isnt made up of conservatives and progressives, most people are neither of these. Conservatives and progressives just happen to be the extreames of the spectrum, not the majority.

@vnarek

@penny

Except we dont all have to vote for the same person, we just need to make sure one person gets more votes than any other.

@vnarek

@penny

the flaw in your logic is that 50% of people are on one side and 50% on the other.

Most people I talk to vote democrat not because they thought it was the best vote but because they thought it was the lesser of two evils. Similarly most people who voted for trump didnt feel he was the best choice but simply felt it was the lesser of two evils and anything was better than the democrats.

Most people dont want to be polarized, they are forced into it. In all reality maybe 5% of people want fascism, 5% of people want anarchy, and 90% of people want a reasonable balance of each.. In all reality 5% of people want the idea of sex to disapear and for trans to be the accepted norm, 5% of people want trans people to die, and 90% of people want something in between.

It is only because they buy into the lie of there being only two votes and they must pick the lesser of two evils that the divide occurs alone 50/50 lines in the first place. Very few people actually agree wholly with the side they wind up supporting, and feel they made a huge compromise to fight against what they perceive as a greater evil from the other side.

If the fallacy of the two party system was something people stopped ascribing to I think you'd find there is a lot more room for compromise than people think. the issue, especially in america, extreamism and polarization is so high (as a result of these two parties) we dont see much compromise from either side.

@vnarek

@vnarek more or less thats the jist of it. People incorrectly think if two parties are dominant that voting for a third party is a less significant vote. Thus they feel erroneously compelled to vote for one of two parties. The cycle would be broken if people didnt beleive (or spread) this false logic in the first place.

I have no problem with using ranked choice voting. It has no downsides and will cause the original false assumption, if otherwise bought into, to become invalid. Thus could potentially move us away from a two party system. Since I see no harm in ranked chocie voting I have no object to switching to it in the hope it might create this effect.

The the truth is, when you try to fix people not thinking for themselves by correcting the system according to their false expectations, you likely wont get very far. If we adopted ranked-choice voting across the USA you are likely to see the exact same result. a two party system, because people will just come up with some new failure of logic to justify it to replace the old.. people will start saying nonsense like "If your first choice when you vote isnt one of the two parties its throwing away your vote".. yea its just as much nonsense as with the system of voting we have now, but that wont stop them from believing it and executing on it either.

There is no shortage of evidence to back this up either... 1) In countries where voting systems are in place that resembles america's current system in several ways we often see exceptions where we simply dont see a two-party system and thus debunks the fundemental logic... 2) in states in the USA where ranked choice voting has been implemented we continue to see a dominance of a two-party system suggesting what I said, that you basically cant fix stupid.

@penny

@penny

by the way I'm not against ranked choice voting, I do support it.

But my point is, its an attempt at invalidating the thinking behind the inherent myth of two-party system. since beleive beleive the logic, however flawed, by introducing ways of voting that invalidate that logic, the idea is it destroys the myth and as such would dissolve the two party system.

But the truth is we dont **need** other forms of voting to do it. If the populace just werent gullible enough to buy the myth in the first place it would be a non issue.

@vnarek

@penny

Incorrect for aforementioned reasons.

If a majority of people voted for a decent candidate, the decent candidate would win... There is no math diminishing their vote so long as people stop believing the lie that they are forced into two parties in the first place.

It is entirely circular logic that such mathematical pressures exist at all, and becomes self fulfilling by ones belief in it.

@vnarek

@vnarek the two are unrelated. the **only** reason a two party system emerges is specifically because people buy into the lie that that they need to vote for one of two parties.

If we could remove that lie from the minds of the populace than there would be nothing inherent in the system that would favor two parties and there would not be a two party system.

@penny

The math isnt rigged, feel free to show whatever equation you think disproves this however. There is no statistical rigging.

People can and should vote for whoever is best. The idea of anything being "rigged" is little more than propaganda people bought into and as such change their choices.

the only thing rigged is the stupidity of the common voter that causes them to believe it is rigged and thus must vote for two parties int he first place. If they didnt believe that lie and actually bothered to vote for the best candidate, then we wouldnt have two dominant parties to begin with.

@vnarek

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.