Show newer

@vnarek Yea I really dont care so much about Trump being labled as "lying" or any consequences trump personally faced regarding his own toots. They could delete his account and I wouldnt loose any sleep personally.

But I do like the fact that the laws are changing to hold social media legally accountable to their censorship, im more than happy with the courts cracking down on that.

@feld

Can you give an exemple in the USA where one company owns an entire band?

Generally the band is broken down into sub-bands, certain ones used by the public with limited power regulations but shared by anyone and no auction needed, and other areas of the band allowed for private use, and others devoted to public works (like research or government usage)... Generally a company might own a small slice, but a monopoly on a whole band, I've never seen that happen within the USA and I have looked pretty closely at a large swatch of the bandplans.

@georgia@dickkickextremist.xyz

@feld

No, I am not confused, the two concepts are closely related, particularly in this context.

@georgia@dickkickextremist.xyz

@feld You've posted a few valid points I'm not saying everything you posted is noise, lets not devolve into that nonsense you trying to attack me and im not trying to attack you.

I am saying the chest thumping tangent of appeal to authority or "its a republican thing" is noise.. back when we were discussing the actual merrits of the discussion itself, including your own contributions, were not noise and your opinions at that time were valuable. So I'm just encouraging you to stick to the main debate and not get into a metaargument.

@georgia@dickkickextremist.xyz

Authority doesnt matter here, the merrit of your argument does :)

@feld

@feld

Making it illegal to profit off a users data, particularly when that user is given the option if they wish to join the server or not (and thus is volunteering their data) is not going to be something we see legally executable. "

In fact the only way I could see you getting away with regulating the exploitation of User Data is through making it a public utility, much int he same way it would allow us to regulate how censorship goes down.

@georgia@dickkickextremist.xyz

@georgia@dickkickextremist.xyz

I disagree the idea of PU is about making sure companies cant get entrenched and largely if we look at history it has had that effect.

The airwaves were deemed a public utility, as a result of that it ensures anyone can get a radio and transmit (for example on a walkie talking).. There are countless companies both on the airwave and selling radios, none of which are "entrenched" or have a monopoly. As an example.

Prior to the airwaves becomes a PU it was basically "whoever can transmit the most powerful signal wins".

@feld

@feld I'm not claiming it is the only way it needs to be.. What im saying is I dont care about the metaargument you are talking about right now, it is a tangent I dont care about so much as the actual argument and any points you have on that.

I really could care less about republican this or i worked at that. I care about the underlying argument, the rest is noise fr me.

@feld

I'm glad to hear we are both educated on the subject. Your understanding was never in question. Appeals to Authority, especially on the internet, are largely irrelevant to the discussion too.

Im sure you have some understanding of the topic, and I respect your right to an opinion. I too am educated on the topic and say your dead wrong.. I dont really care about any of that, if you have specific arguments to share, however, feel free, thats where any value will come in in this conversation.

@georgia@dickkickextremist.xyz

@feld Who is to blame is a tangent I have no interest in going down at the moment. Regardless of who is to blame for the way it is, that is still the way it is

@feld

Thats not how legal arguments work regarding public utilities... Alternative means of communication wouldnt be an acceptable argument to whether FB is a PU or not.

Just because I can setup a lan independent of the internet, and thus not need to use an ISP would not be a valid argument that an ISP isnt a PU for example

@georgia@dickkickextremist.xyz

@feld We dont do that in the USA, we have nationalized agencies that regulate privatized companies that run our public utilities instead.

FCC for example is the nationalized service that regulates the shared mediums used bt RF transmissions, which themselves are privatized (anyone can own a transmitter within certain guidlines)

@feld

Sadly true, I wish it wasn't, but if you want to stay in touch with friends and groups in many ways it is

@georgia@dickkickextremist.xyz

@georgia@dickkickextremist.xyz

ISPs are regulated as public utilities (though there are classes of such PU)

@feld

@feld Because the vast majority of people use it. They have become essential in some ways to promote your business, stay in touch with friends, or be informed and organize events because of the ubiquity of such things like facebook.

@feld Hard to say. It is illegal for a ISP to censor for example. the deciding factor is if courts would see FB or Twitter as a public utility. There would be a good legal argument they are.

@realcaseyrollins

Sure. I think thats more a sign that im not radicalized to either side than a sign that they are good presidents though.

Even a broken clock is right twice a day.

@mutualitywsdes

@realcaseyrollins In a sense I agree. I see facebook and twitter as public utilities partyly because they dont federate and have such a massive userbase.

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.