Show newer

@isolategab
How do you figure? Since their content is not shared by anyone on our server how is their reache extended?

@isolategab
If i may, i dont think anyone in this thread claimed blocking gab is an infringement of rights, do as you wish for your instance. I think all that is being said is that the user in this cases wishes to decide that for themselves and puts instances that honor that wish as a high priority in how they select instances.

@SuperDicq @arteteco @design_RG

@isolategab
That seems largely incorrect. Fedilab is and has been one of the most popular clients in the app store and has since reversed their block on gab.
@design_RG @arteteco @realcaseyrollins

@isolategab
If the purpose is not to amplify hatefuk speech from gab then we already already serve that purpose as our users do not promote hateful speech from gab in the first place. In fact i have never witnessed one of our users ever sharing a post from a gab account of any kind, and i doubt our users would.

@SuperDicq
While thats a bit of a tangent to the concern i voiced i do agree you will do more good to talk to them and let them know their opinions are harmful and why.

Silence wont being about change uf anything it will give them a false sense of security as they will only hear people constantly agreeing with them.

@arteteco @isolategab @design_RG

@isolategab
But to what end? It woukd still impede our LGBT community from their purpose (to watch for risks to their community). They woukd be unable to see responses in threads or watch the overall gab timeline for threats against their community if we silenced it.

On the other hand, what good would it do that woukd be worth that cost? None of our members are allowed to share hateful content so its not like a generalist instance where there is a fear gabs voice might be amplified.

@design_RG @arteteco @realcaseyrollins

@rimugu Unfortunately there is no cure for ignorance. Feel free to continue with yours and misinterpret what I say however you please.

@rimugu Nope wrong again.

I never said it had to be the same as me, only that it had to be appropriate.

I do not hate many people and things other people hate, yet I recognize their hate as appropriate.

You should try reading what people say, rather than reading what you want to hear. It really helps on the comprehension side of things.

@rimugu

I have no problem with hate. Hate should be encouraged against the right things.. we should hate rapists, and nazis, and a great many other things.

So how much hate you see or dont see isnt so much the issue. How you ideantify appropriate vs inappropriate hate is far more important. I dont know you well enough to know if you are capable of such distinction.

If you really cant find inappropriate hate on GAB then all you have to do is look to their most popular member milo, you can go through his follower list to get some hints as to who is likely to be of a similar nature.

@design_RG

@rimugu

the only difference is hating a group for giving a voice to nazis and taking away a voice from those who criticize that decision is a very different nature than spewing the hate of genocide in my view.

Feel free to show me a high quality account that doesnt have much hate on it and posts quality content and I'll be happy to change my mind.

@design_RG

@rimugu

I never claimed they dont have the right to do it. I only claimed it reduces my respect for them for their choices in that regard, as is my right.

@design_RG

@rimugu

mastodon isnt a single server.. some servers on mastodon absolutely are communist hell holes, others are not.

Gab is a single server and I've seen the number of explicit racists there to be the majority of the people I've seen. That said it may simply be because they generally responded to me. I didnt go around looking for them.

I will say this, considering they let nazi accounts roam free, yet mass block other accounts that speak out negatively against GAB (my own GAB account included) tells me all I need to know about their practices as a server personally.

@design_RG

@rimugu

Are you really telling me you havent seen the huge swath of explicitly pro-nazi accounts on GAB? Many of whom posts swastikas publicly to show their support.

If not consider yourself lucky. I have seen more than I care to count.

@design_RG

@chrism

A Sterling endorsement, thank you, Chris.

This place is pretty unique -- I have been in internet communities of different kinds for 30 years now. Fr many years it was Forums, and I was active and became Mod, and sometimes Staff, assistant admin in some of them.

No place in my experience had an upper level Admin class that would take a Mod's suggestions and give it thorough evaluation, then decided by consensus or voted -- with the Mods getting equal voting power.

One person, one vote, this is thanks to our fearless leader's vision, and unique indeed. We disagree sometimes, in fact I do get ticked off and he knows what causes that. But there's mutual respect, and no offense is taken, we are professionals.

Tribute to Jeff's vision and openness. Very, very rare.

I was in different places over time, and of course left; there comes a time when it's the best for all involved, or I wouldn't be here now. Some of the places I worked at are still alive and important in their niches.

I do know I am a sailor, a traveller, and a day will come when I set sail, saddle my bike and take to the road -- just like I love doing in real life.

Until then, it's a pleasure working here; people couldn't pay the cost of the work volunteered by dedicated staff all over the Fediverse. Got to hope the experiment goes well, as the corporate internet is pretty disgusting sometimes.

@freemo

Just a reminder to all the QOTO crowd, our June nomination for an additional moderator is currently taking place on our discourse!

discourse.qoto.org/t/nominatio

@freemo @design_RG I agree too. I had the pleasure of blocking gab early on in my fediverse experience. I'm quite capable of removing things I don't like. I don't need an admin/moderator to do this as this is censorship.

I'm all for free speech but with that comes a responsibility to behave, be respectful, and treat people how one would want to be treated.

Unfortunately give some people access to the Internet and they think that hrough their anonymity they can be obnoxious. There is always a minority like this. Unfortunately!

So, thank you for treating us like adults, giving us the freedom to choose. This is just one of many reasons I like qoto.org!

:ablobcool:

@design_RG I already posted the nomination on discourse and announced it 3 days ago :)

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.