Show newer

@zleap

I think eugen is ok with implemented features regardless of twitter, i just think he is highly inspired by twitter more than trying to replicate it feature for feature.

@design_RG

@design_RG

Yea its absolutely doable in theory. Eugen was explicitly against it. So he did this on purpose, though I disagree.

@zleap

@zleap

Ideally we should be able to edit posts without "deleting and redrafting"

@design_RG

@zleap

I generally tend to agree, but I think it is important we at least listen to the cynics. We just shouldnt jump to make changes over every criticism either.

@design_RG

@zleap

I like the simple design of your blog. I have a similar design on my own. I'm a fan

@design_RG

@design_RG @freemo
Well this is on my personal blog, to add context, I am posting about various topics e.g freecodecamp or code club and saying I am happy to be contacted here on Mastodon.

This is due out Tuesday, hence scheduled

personaljournal.ca/paulsutton/

@zleap

So if i understand you correctly people think the service isnt used by enough people to be useful.

If that is your main concern wouldnt eliminating registered accounts have the opposite effect? It would reduce the number of apparent users making the service look more obscure not less, no?

@design_RG

@design_RG

I understand that. But we are trying to solve problems here, not just dictate solutions in isolation of the problem.

I am trying to understand **why** you want to see that so I can help come up with the best solution to resolve the problem, rather than just blindly jump to the solution.

As I said it seems your concerns is there is no statistic for people to know dormant but once active numbers (as that was your explanation of the problem and what the solution you proposed solves).

As such the link I provided gives a solution to the problem you mentioned without the downsides that your solution would cause.

@zleap

@zleap

In what way would it be an attack vector? Do you feel adding the third statistic type I mentioned would mediate that attack?

@design_RG

@design_RG

Seems this solution would be the best way to satisfy your concerns without having the downsides then, since you mostly just want better reporting of dormant but once-active accounts:

qoto.org/@freemo/1043029429453

@zleap

@design_RG

Even providing a list as text output is going to take writing of a script. The actual act of suspending the account once identified would probably just be one additional line of code.

@zleap

@design_RG

So if I understand you your whole argument is you want a statistic that shows people who are not active, but were at one point active, and thus serve a purpose that neither the active user account nor the current registered user account serves?

If that is the case I'd say the best solution is just to add a 3rd statistic to be reported, it can report "dormant accounts" and provide the number of all users that have posted at least once, but include users even if they have not been active in more than 2 months.

That solution would provide the number you suggest to people but not have any of the negative side effects I listed.

@zleap

@Phaedrus

true but the problem is because im usually on my phone it is very tedious to edit the mistakes in that format (its hard to align the cursor to the correct position and edit). Its really really annoying.

On other platforms I post from my phone and then when i am by my computer I go through and fix spelling errors later.

@zleap @design_RG

@Phaedrus

Sadly because I often type from my phone my posts are riddled with spelling errors I hate. I never have the time or energy to go back and fix it let alone willing to orphan the thread in the process (as I tend to not be by my computer until later where its easier to fix).

@zleap @design_RG

@inverness01 alibaba and countless other services in fact.

Problem is people care and want companies that are socially ethical and this usually means making socially ethical statements according to their morals (which are contrary to yours).

So while there are plenty of companies that lack such moral opinions of the same nature as Amazon, none of them are as large or offer as many products, or have as significant a rpesence in the USA, and wont, because of that very reason.

@design_RG

As a general rule i try to only D&R when no one has commented or boosted yet. But sometimes it still causes issues as seen :)

@zleap

@zleap

Sorry i deleted and redrafted right before you replied, your reply is now orphaned (might want to recrreate it).

I do hate delete and redraft.. i think that needs to be fixed!

@design_RG

@design_RG

The counter points to this:

1) We already seperate out stats between active users and registered. So by removing old accounts it would make the registered number useless as we would effectively be reducing it to the active count. Aside from perhaps being dishonest to our users it prevents us from actually being able to know the ratio of active users to registered users, as the registered user count doesnt represent anything meaningful.

2) Users who register with no activity represent 0 value, but also represent 0 negative sides. They do nothing to decrease the quality of the instance

3) users may wish to have an account for read-only purposes. There is no harm in that

4) we can not truely delete accounts, it looks more like a suspension. This means users can not re-register later without them emailing an admin. This adds extra work load on admins, hassle for potential users, and with no gain.

5) there is no easy way to suspend accounts on the criteria you suggests. Someone (me?) would have to invest time and energy to write a script to do it.

6) many users want a server with expiernce and a history. The registered user count reflects this. For that reason many users pick their instance specifically because they have a large registered user count. so we would be doing ourselves harm

It seems to me there are quite a few down sides to doing this and not a single positive effect I can think of... What, exactly, is to be gained by doing this?

@zleap

@zleap

We already have a reflection of the true number of active user accounts though.. its the "active user" count.. why would you want to strive to make the registered user count identical to the active user count reported and thus loose one piece of data entierly... what is the benefit of that? If users want to know the active user count its posted right there on the front page next to registered count.

@design_RG

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.