Show newer

@carver@fimidi.com

Kind of you are right that it is lighter because things are getting pulled into the air..

Logs dont have much moisture though, although a lot of steam **is** produced it is water that didnt exist prior to the burning.

the vast majority of the mass of wood is carbon, when it burns the carbon is is released and the result of the chemical reaction is water that didnt previous exist is created and carbon dioxide. The newly created water escapes as steam and the CO2 produces is effectivelly oxygen from the air carrying away carbon from the wood.

The vast majority of the weight lost when a wood log burns is the carbon it is loosing and being carried away by the oxygen.

So in short steel wool is an oxidative reaction where iron oxidizes with oxygen cause iron oxide, this is a solid and stick around so the weight increases.

In wood its an oxidative reaction where carbon is being oxidized creating CO2, this in turn is a gas and is thus escaping into the air.

@stux @artilectzed

This video started a good discussion over on my friends feed. So far no one has answered it and I dont want to give away the answer to anyone else (please CW your answers) but the question is this:

Why is it when you burn a piece of steel wool it gets heavier, but if you burn a log it gets lighter.

stux⚡️  
When you burn steel wool, it gets heavier.

@stux

I really want you to get what happens in a log as compared to the steel wool because a lot of people kinda know the answer and kinda dont and it will be an eye opener for you I think, and others.

Here is the thing, like i said both are the same sort of reaction, combustion of a fuel in an oxidative reaction.. and there is a key difference between them that causes steel-wool to get heavier and a log to get lighter... But before i answer it (and i will do that if it doesnt click cause I really want you guys to understand this cause its cool)... Think about it in reverse

As a tree grows from a seedling it starts as barely anything just a seed and turns into this massive very heavy tree... where did it get all its weight from? All the atoms that make it up, where did they all come from?

@artilectzed
@carver@fimidi.com

Spoiler - Answer to the question 

@carver@fimidi.com the first half is correct of course, molecules are being captured in the steel wool.. but they arent being destroyed in a log any more so than they are in steel wool .

And to be clear even if you destroy a molecule you dont have any less matter, the matter just takes a different form.

@stux

I see why you are saying what you said now.. but no this has nothing to do with the log.

I dont want to confuse the issue but this is a totally different tangent and the video is even a bit misleading. I can explain the video a bit better but its unrelated tot he question about the log I posited.

There is a hint of truth in the video you posted of course. A burning log gives off light and looses some energy, that energy would cause an infentesimal amount of mass to be lost. But it is so little as to be impossible to measure.

@artilectzed

@stux

Well there are certainly differences, but they are both fuels burning in an oxidative reaction.

Its actually something you will go "duh I knew that" once I say it :)

@artilectzed

@stux

Wouldyou like the answer as to what makes a burning log different from a burning iron-wool? They are both oxidative reactions and very similar in principle.

@artilectzed

@stux

Well no not really chemical reactions get their energy from stored bond energy not mass. In any chemical reaction the mass is exactly the same, down to the electron. It simply releases energy from bond energy.. There is never any change from mass to energy or back again.. it si a fundemental garuntee in chemistry.

@artilectzed

@stux

Last time I checked logs arent nuclear reactions, lol I wish, but no... mass is preserved and energy is preserved both seperately in any sort of reaction you are likely to see, including burning of logs.

@artilectzed

@artilectzed

yup, so next question (let me know if you want the answer) why does a log get lighter when you burn it?

@stux

@carver@fimidi.com Think of the answer to this: what is the basic formula for any combustion to take place? then you will get your answer.

@carver@fimidi.com while id understand why you might guess that, no, thats not it.

I will give you a hint, the only reason a log gets lighter when you burn it is because of the smoke that comes off of it cares away most of the material. Notice when iron-wool burns there is no smoke.

Thats half way to the answer for you.

@solidsanek

Well then im glad i took the time to insert myself into your thread.

Last person i told this too insisted that no one knew where the developers of doom got the name from... I'm just like... it was literally already a word, yes we do!

@vanillabean

Part of me thinks if we didnt just get through with being stuck inside all alone for 3 months loosing our sanity America probably wouldnt be so quick to riot right now.

Dont get me wrong, people being pissed is absolutely justified. I'm just saying, it may have made tensions unusually high :)

@solidsanek

Indeed, I see the word often as I read books from the 1700s a lot on the topic of the occult.

You see at the time the word "demon" had no evil connotation in its own right. It just meant a spirit and could be good or bad, caco as a prefix implied it was bad/evil

@vanillabean

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.