@louiscouture Social housing is, by definition, housing where the property is both owned and managed by the state, not by the landlord. So that argument is moot as the OP does not propose social housing, it proposing something entirely different.
> wait regular people people can afford homes in capitalist systems?
No that's not what I said, but also, even if i had said that it doesn't line up with your second paragraph.
> Weird, I thought if we forced landlords to lower their prices...
In capitalist societies they **don't** force landlords to rent out homes at a loss. So you are not making a statement here that is logically consistent. The whole reason in a capitalist society that regular people can afford homes is precisely because owning a home doesn't force you to rent it out at a loss.
@louiscouture Luckily we dont live in a society where only the rich can buy homes. In both europe and the USA upper low class and above are capable of, and do, own homes. It is only those in poverty who are completely incapable of owning homes. Those people, however, may not be able to own homes but they do (usually) get to live in a place with a roof over the head thanks to welfare programs.
So yea, in practice CUBA isnt really ahead, both places have the vast majority of their population with homes, or to be more specific, both societies ensure everyone has a roof over their head if they go through the proper steps.
The big difference is that in Cuba everyone lives in poverty (like the picture attached which is what Cuban homes look like). Where in europe very few people have to suffer in that sort of poverty, and almost all of them have a way out if they do.
@louiscouture That logic only applies in non-capitalist societies. So sure in a communistic society that may very well be the outcome without the capitalistic consequence of pushing the home shortage farther than it already is.
But we arent talking about communistic societies here, we are talking about capitalistic ones. And in a capitalistic society where there is a free market on buying and selling homes, then no, that logic doesn't work because the end result is no one buys home, no one builds homes, and existing homes stop getting maintained until they are no longer livable.
So regardless of that, no, your logic does not work in practice in capitalistic societies and the end result is making the problem worse. So you'd first need to create a working communistic society, which so far no one has done successfully without creating extreme poverty, but hey if you can managed to do it, then we can talk :)
The fact of the matter is, if the intent of the person is to rent out their home, they will do what is most financially advantageous to them. So the only way they would let a house sit empty is if they felt that by doing so they stood to either make more money in the long run by renting it later, or would take less of a loss. No one is going to take a loss out of spite.
The only situation where I could see a house sitting empty and being financially disadvantageous would be if its a vacation home they use often. In which we are effectively trying to argue whether having a vacation home should be legal or not. Obviously I'd argue it should be and if they were made effectively illegal you wouldnt really solve any problems because it goes right back to the original point that if people are buying fewer homes (in this case no one buys vacation homes) then less homes are built or maintained in the first place.
@Demosthenes Fedilab here as well. But generally I prefer the webclient and dont access it too often on my phone.
The part your missing is that when you rent to someone you can not stop renting to them anytime you want. Depending on the country you become locked in for anywhere from one year to 5+ years.
So if you are forced to rent out your home during a downturn in the economy then you no longer have the ability to wait a few months to a year to rent it out when the economy improves, when it would be economical to do so.
@louiscouture I never said the government can't, I said they **don't**, at least not in response to a faulty market.
The point is they dont because if they did no one would buy stock, it wouldnt be a wise investment if everytime the market went south the government had a rule in place you'd be forced to sell all your stock at a loss, it would be a garunteed bad investment and the stock market would crash and the economy would suffer.. So they don't, regardless as to whether or not they could.
It is no different with housing, generally most governments don't do this, because if they did it would mean buying and building homes at all would be a loosing investment. In turn fewer houses would get built, and the problem regarding a shortage of houses would skyrocket.
I said it was a bad Idea, and it is, I never said the government couldnt do it, governments enforce bad ideas all the time. The governments that do it too often tend to either collapse entirely or have populations that live in an extreme poverty as a result of these sorts of choices.
@louiscouture Not just like the stock market though.
The stock market doesnt require me to sell my stock when the market is doing poorly and take a loss. As an investor if it isnt to my advantage to sell stock I can sit on it for as long as I like and make money.
In this case they are forcing landlords to rent out their home even when it isnt in their advantage to do so and to take huge losses, where waiting and not renting it out means they can save themselves (potentially) from that debt or loosing their home.
So? In order for that to be even remotely useful you'd have to first show what percentage of the general population has no comorbidities with COVID-19 in the first place.
Even then it tells you very little about how concerning the disease would be for a healthy person without comorbidities. Consider the following hypothetical to understand why.
Presume there was a disease that killed 10% of people who are healthy and 90% of people with comorbidities, and those comorbidities were common. The end result would be the percentage of people who died and had no comorbidities out of everyone who died from the disease would be very low despite the fact that the percentage of healthy people who die overall from it is still very high.
@louiscouture Seems like a bad idea...
Lets assume I want to be a landlord, I get a mortgage and it costs me 1500 per month. I want to rent it out at-cost so that I can ensure I can cover the insurance so my house doesnt get damaged and pay the rental agency to handle the day to day, plus the mortgage. but other than breaking even I dont wish to make any money as the equity I build in the home will be my long term payout.. so presume this comes to 1800$ per month for me to break even.
Now i put my house up for rent at 1800$, but no one bites because the economy is in the shitter.. So I am forced to either rent my house out at a loss or the government will do it for me. Meaning I'm garunteed not to be able to make my mortgage payments and as such effectively have to loose my home all together, and in the meantime since I cant cover insurance either and the tenant damages my home when my mortgage finally defaults the value of the home will now be less than when I bought it so the house I bought it so I also am now 50,000$ or more in debt.
Why should a landlord have to loose their property and go in debt simply because the economy is nnot doing well.
While I originally identified only 3 fediverse apps it appears this has affected almost all the apps in the store. As of yet I havent heard of any app developers who didnt get a notice (please correct me if you have any information that disagrees with that).
If enabling latex on discourse is important to you I'll take a closer look at it and see if i can get it up again. Probably isnt too hard.
I'm not a fan of rapists either by the way.. or baby killers.. oh and Hitler, Hitler was an asshole.
@lupyuen You don't drink? You must be really thirsty all the time then!
Ya know what I hate... people who kill puppies.
I oppose post-marital sex.
Earth’s nearest supergiant is cooling down at the end of its life
Scientists now believe the dimming of Betelgeuse was caused by a giant sunspot ...
Jeffrey Phillips Freeman
Innovator & Entrepreneur in Machine Learning, Evolutionary Computing & Big Data. Avid SCUBA diver, Open-source developer, HAM radio operator, astrophotographer, and anything nerdy.
Born and raised in Philadelphia, PA, USA, currently living in Utrecht, Netherlands, USA, and Thailand. Was also living in Israel, but left.
Pronouns: Sir / Mister
(Above pronouns are not intended to mock, i will respect any persons pronouns and only wish pronouns to show respect be used with me as well. These are called neopronouns, see an example of the word "frog" used as a neopronoun here: http://tinyurl.com/44hhej89 )
A proud member of the Penobscot Native American tribe, as well as a Mayflower passenger descendant. I sometimes post about my genealogical history.
My stance on various issues:
Education: Free to PhD, tax paid
Abortion: Protected, tax paid, limited time-frame
Welfare: Yes, no one should starve
UBI: No, use welfare
Racism: is real
Guns: Shall not be infringed
LGBT+/minorities: Support
Pronouns: Will respect
Trump: Moron, evil
Biden: Senile, racist
Police: ACAB
Drugs: Fully legal, no prescriptions needed
GPG/PGP Fingerprint: 8B23 64CD 2403 6DCB 7531 01D0 052D DA8E 0506 CBCE