Show newer

@freemo @Science
My hobbies include, watching time go by. Said no ever.

@khird

I'm not sure we can say its carelessness if they dont understand the math to begin with. Most people who misunderstand it likely arent even doing or considering it in vector math terms. I am more interested in the purely conceptual understanding that a lot of people are curious enough that they do consider it, but often get it wrong.

Understanding it really doesn't require anything nearly as complex as vector math, and even if you do vector math you don't even need to touch or incorporate time dilation directly (you can use energy equations and ignore time dilation and it works out correct). Sure if you want to calculate exact numbers in a complex scenario with multiple objects moving at different speeds and directions then vector math is going to be your go to (with or without time dilation).

Simply understanding intuitively as I have already done in some of the comments or even doing the math without consideration fo vectors by limiting our talks 2D is possible with just a basic intuition and very little rigour (the numbers I cited in some of my comments i just did simple math in my head, there wasnt a vector in site or anything to do with time dialation to cite those numbers).

@Science

@PauITown

My first dilation was in the 4th grade, haven't looked back since :)

The math is actually surprisingly simple once you understand how it works. Just some basic geometry and algebra.

@swiley @Zest

@a1batross I wouldn't be surprised if this was due to a craving for iron.. I would imagine foxes dont eat too well in winter and could have an iron deficiency.

@swiley

I kinda disagree. Personally I have always found special relativity highly intuitive even from a young age (in 4th grade i had re-discovered the equation for time dilation after hearing my teacher mention how it worked as a side comment once and it sounded like an easy concept).

I think intuition goes very well with it but you must learn to have a new intuition of sorts and think about what it is like in space where you have no points of reference around you to consider what is or is not stationary in an absolute sense.

IMO it doesnt start getting to be intuitive until you tack on general relativity, then things are a lot harder to reason through. Length constriction fo special relativity can be a bit unintuitive too, but even that I think you can build up an intuition rather fast once you understand a few things without the need for math or axioms.

@Zest @Science

@Zest

One added point, in the last part where we introduce a new ship. Time dilation has little to do with it, and its a perfect example of why.

The degree of time dilation is always proportional to the relative speed between two objects. Since you and the new ship are traveling at almost the same speed and direction and only differ slightly, therefore you appear to be traveling away from each other but at a very slow speed, time dilation between you and the other ship would be negligible.

Imagine the speed difference is so small you and the new ship appear to only be moving away from each other at about the speed of a car on the highway, 60 mph/kph. then the time dilation between you and that ship would be no different than the time dilation between your family you left at home and you in a car driving down the highway. In other words it would be imperceptibly small.

@Science

we need a technological advance in the field of whiteboard markers

@anonymoose

For sure, and I am willing to give the benefit of the doubt here that is what happened.

@DudeNamedBen @icedquinn

@khird

Indeed, that is the intended meaning of course.. but often grossly misunderstood by people.

@Science

@icedquinn

I agree entirely. The bill is inexcusable and wrong.. But it still isnt a plot by congress and is limited to one state.

@DudeNamedBen

@Zest

> because intuitively if one thing is moving away from you and another thing is moving in the same direction, if you accelerate fast so that your relative speed is equal to the speed of light, is it possible to travel away from both of them at the same speed?

So this is your first mistake, the phrase "speed is equal to the speed of light" makes no sense. You can never have anything moving relative to you at the speed or light or faster (other than light of course or another massless particle).. You would have to rephrase this to say "near the speed of light" to make any sense.

If you and the object are moving at the same speed and direction and are moving at near the speed of light relative to the earth the earth would appear to be receding away from you at near the speed of light, lets say 98% of C.

Now if you left the object that is moving with you behind and now accelerated to 98% the speed of light relative to that object what you would see is that even though you increased your speed by 98% C relative to the object that was moving with you, relative to earth you only appear to have accelerated by 1.98% the speed of light. In other words after accelerating the object that was moving with you would now be receding away at 98% the speed of light and the earth would now be receding away at 99.98% the speed of light.

> is this a time dilation thing?

Well, no it isnt a time dilation thing exactly, though time dilation is occurring it isnt really relevant to the people in the ship (who would be unaware of any time dilation presumably. but not completely unrelated either (if they had a telescope and looked at earth thigns would appear to be moving slower in terms of the people and clocks the faster they go). With special relativity you cant really ignore any one aspect wholly.

> and would that only be from your perspective

Well not only from your perspective exactly, but only from certain perspectives. Obviously if a second ship were traveling along side you at the same speed and direction as you and accelerated along side you then they would see all the things you see from their perspective.

But yes that perspective is not shared by other observers necessarily. From your perspective (since you're not accelerating) it feels and looks like you are stationary and it is the object and the earth that are moving instead. So to you on the ship the object is moving 98% the speed of light and the earth is moving 99.98% the speed of light. From the perspective of the object the object is stationary and you are moving away from it in one direction at 98% the speed of light and the earth is moving away from it in the other direction at 98% the speed of light. Likewise from earth the object appear to be moving at 98% and you appear to be moving at 99.98%

> the relative speed by an observer who was traveling even faster than the other object you could be moving slower relative to all three things from their perspective because time would be going differently to them?

Direction matters here, but yes. If there was another object in the mix that was another ship and basically flew along side you and accelerated when you did, but lets say they stopped accelerating just a few moments before you stopped, so they are almost at the same speed and direction as you but not quite. From their perspective the object and earth would be moving marginally slower than from your perspective. However this new ship would appear to be moving very slowly away from you and in the direction you came from (towards the earth) while to the new ship you would appear to be moving very slowly away from them and in the direction away from earth.

@Science

@Zest

> because intuitively if one thing is moving away from you and another thing is moving in the same direction, if you accelerate fast so that your relative speed is equal to the speed of light, is it possible to travel away from both of them at the same speed?

So this is your first mistake, the phrase "speed is equal to the speed of light" makes no sense. You can never have anything moving relative to you at the speed or light or faster (other than light of course or another massless particle).. You would have to rephrase this to say "near the speed of light" to make any sense.

If you and the object are moving at the same speed and direction and are moving at near the speed of light relative to the earth the earth would appear to be receding away from you at near the speed of light, lets say 98% of C.

Now if you left the object that is moving with you behind and now accelerated to 98% the speed of light relative to that object what you would see is that even though you increased your speed by 98% C relative to the object that was moving with you, relative to earth you only appear to have accelerated by 1.98% the speed of light. In other words after accelerating the object that was moving with you would now be receding away at 98% the speed of light and the earth would now be receding away at 99.98% the speed of light.

> is this a time dilation thing?

Well, no it isnt a time dilation thing exactly, though time dilation is occurring it isnt really relevant to the people in the ship (who would be unaware of any time dilation presumably. but not completely unrelated either (if they had a telescope and looked at earth thigns would appear to be moving slower in terms of the people and clocks the faster they go). With special relativity you cant really ignore any one aspect wholly.

> and would that only be from your perspective

Well not only from your perspective exactly, but only from certain perspectives. Obviously if a second ship were traveling along side you at the same speed and direction as you and accelerated along side you then they would see all the things you see from their perspective.

But yes that perspective is not shared by other observers necessarily. From your perspective (since you're not accelerating) it feels and looks like you are stationary and it is the object and the earth that are moving instead. So to you on the ship the object is moving 98% the speed of light and the earth is moving 99.98% the speed of light. From the perspective of the object the object is stationary and you are moving away from it in one direction at 98% the speed of light and the earth is moving away from it in the other direction at 98% the speed of light. Likewise from earth the object appear to be moving at 98% and you appear to be moving at 99.98%

> the relative speed by an observer who was traveling even faster than the other object you could be moving slower relative to all three things from their perspective because time would be going differently to them?

Direction matters here, but yes. If there was another object in the mix that was another ship and basically flew along side you and accelerated when you did, but lets say they stopped accelerating just a few moments before you stopped, so they are almost at the same speed and direction as you but not quite. From their perspective the object and earth would be moving marginally slower than from your perspective. However this new ship would appear to be moving very slowly away from you and in the direction you came from (towards the earth) while to the new ship you would appear to be moving very slowly away from them and in the direction away from earth.

@Science

@icedquinn

In what sense? Provide misinformation and lie about what it means? Yea its pretty common. Though until I hear a response I will give this person the benefit of the doubt that they just made a mistake and hopefully they post a correction.

@DudeNamedBen

@DudeNamedBen

> Congress set to pass bill ...

No that is a lie and the link you shared explicitly states as much.

Notice where it says "Washington **state**" at the top.. This is a state bill, it applies only to washington state and has absolutely nothing to do with congress which can neither vote on it or pass.

It is a troubling bill in general of course, but it is limited to a single state.

@M0YNG I think this was meant to be a reply on the original thread, can you make it there so my answer can be seen by others who are interested please?

@Science
Interesting fact of the day:

Despite popular belief it is not really correct to say the speed of light is a universal speed limit in the universe. It would be more correct to say one object can never go faster, relative to another object by the speed of light.

In other words, no matter what speed I am going relative to the earth (or anything else) doesn't matter; if there is some object going the same speed and direction as me I can still accelerate up to the speed of light faster than it.

All that matters is that nothing can go faster than the speed of light relative to me the observer.

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.