You entire response is pretty much an exercise in **Hume's razor** / **Hume's guillotine** and I reject it on those terms alone.
You are arguing that what **ought** to be doesnt matter and all that matters is what **is**, which is contrary to the very premise of the discussion, which is a discussion about what me and tim feel **ought** to be the interpretation. Not to mention even a bit Nihilistic as it can be applied to any discussion where one argues an improvement of society by proposing a particularly moral outlook which is not currently the predominating one, creating perpetual stagnation as a principle.
> Morality is a very loose concept in that it is very subjective and local to subculture you adhere to.
While the consensus on morality does differ greatly by person and location, and culture, that does not necessarily mean it is subjective, and I would argue it is not.
A great many people believe all sorts of things that is dictated by the culture they are in, for example some people believe the earth is just a few thousand years old, some even believe it is flat. The opinions you get on these ideas are highly dependent on the person you ask and the culture you are in. None of that, however, implies that the "the earth is round" is not an objective truth. Objective facts do not require consensus to be objective.
With that said when people do agree on an objective fact, some saying the earth is round, the others saying it is flat, then what you have is peoples opinions as to which of these two facts are true.
Morality is no different, I would argue there is an objective, factual, sense of what is or is not moral, it just so happens peoples opinions about what that fact happens to be differs, and there is no consensus as to which of the many proposed objective moralities is the truth, and factual one.
In my opinion of the fact, however, it is quite easily objectively defined, good and bad is measures by the overall quantity of happiness an action elicits as a result of that action over time.
> Since these acts do not touch most of the stuff “universally considered bad”, we do not deal here with universal moral principles, but strictly with normative ones.
that seems like an unjustified leap to me. Because an act does not touch on something considered bad, universal or otherwise that does not mean we have to go an extra step to somehow figure out some reasoning why its really bad afterall. That's just confirmation bias eagerly trying to find a reason to call it bad "well if this doesn't determine its bad, lets try another technique that will determine it is bad"
In fact I'd argue much the opposite, if our usual sense of morality, on analysis of a situation, shows us there is nothing about it that would typically be considered bad, then we can stop there and conclude that is in fact, **not** bad.
> So while each of us might call those people “good” or “bad”, that does not matter.
Of course it matters, particularly in this context. The point of the discussion is to decide if we feel Biden has an effect which is more "bad" or Trump. Answering that question requires us to debate if we feel they are good or bad. Falling back to laws does **not** answer that question for us.
That would be like saying "Slavery was good because people disagree whether slavery is bad or not (re: nazis) and therefore we must fall back to laws. The law said slavery was legal, ergo slavery was good"... the logic is flawed the moment this argument invoked law as an arbiter of good and bad.
> The society, through a contract between its members (which we conveniently call constitutions) decided that those acts are bad.
No we didn't, we agreed those acts should be punished, we agreed those acts should result in consequences like being put in jail. At no point did anyone assert that anyone was "bad" or "good", the law only dictates the consequences, nothing more.
> And you have all right to think that. Yet, what matters in this case is what the society as a whole “thinks”.
"Matters" here is an awfully loaded term, and again not true. Even if we can determine that a majority happen to agree, thats rather irrelevant as we are arguing what **ought** to be, not what **is**. Again if we were discussing if slavery was right it would be silly for anyone to argue it was morally justified because the majority believed it to be so.
@koherecoWatchdog I would agree that is a concerning decision and I would support a better definition to ensure an ID wouldnt be required.
@koherecoWatchdog Your preaching to the choir, all this I already know and more or less agree with.
@koherecoWatchdog Not disagreeing with you that it is a problem. Only trying to clarify the details.
I personally feel strongly that a person should have a right to levels of anonymity they are not currently granted in many things, and requiring and ID is part of that. It is why I am against all of the following:
* Stop and ID laws
* requiring you use your true name on facebook
* Requiring licensing or registration of guns (in its current form, I'd be ok with anonymized licensing)
etc
@koherecoWatchdog Are you claiming that these place will not accept a nondrivers photo ID, or did you perhaps mean to say a photo ID and not specifically a license?
What is or is not illegal isnt really the issue be debated here. Pretty sure both me and tim would agree that from a legal standpoint the group acted illegally.. Terrorism is so loosely defined I would also agree that from a legal standpoint they very well could probably make a terrorism charge stick, but then again people have been charged with terrorism for some pretty absurd reasons, so that isnt much of a measuring stick IMO.
You are using the law as if it is a defacto measure of good and bad. I reject that as an accurate measure of morality. The only place law has any relevance is if we are discussing what the consequences for these people are likely to be, but that is wholly seperate from if these people are good people are not. Or how bad their actions are.
It also depends on if a police officer can or will even find many of them and simply how much is invested in doing so, which ultimately biases any results.
In my eyes burning a building down with people in it, as the liberals did in my city during their riots is clearly and substantially far more immoral than breaking the window of a capitol building, walking inside, and taking a selfie. Yet the people who through the molotov cocktail into the buildings, despite some even being caught on tap, are likely not be persecuted because no time or money was spent on doing so. Yet those who broke the windows of the capitol building will, in all liklihood, have every resource of the FBI thrust upon them, likely being arrested and tried. Yet to me it is quite clear they are not even approaching the level of immorality as burning a building with people in it...
Apology accepted, no worries, as I said we are generally respectful in both directions and its appreciated.
As i said in my last comment at the very end (see the PS).. aside from the transcript i did watch it again before typing that comment and it still sounds like "we want pence" to me. Though there are parts where its a bit garbled, but even when I try to hear or pick out "hang mike pence" from that my brain can not hear anything remotely close to that.
@timorl thanks youa re correct, deleting and recreating, thanks.
1) I told you I was done with the conversation, please respect that.
> We want Pence”? Did you watch the video on your phone, or something with terrible sound quality? I re-watched it twice and it’s not even that unclear, especially as the person recording enters the doorway – they are very clearly chanting “Hang Mike Pence”. I suggest you rewatch it in better sound quality or something?
Even the official CNN transcript has it written as "We want pence", and CNN is liberal leaning and in general misrepresented a lot of clips out of context, so thats pretty damning that they recorded it as such.
From the transcript:
CROWD: We want Pence. We want Pence. We want Pence. We want Pence. We want Pence. We want Pence. We want Pence.
http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/2101/11/ebo.01.html
> Well done though, you made me doubt reality, I re-watched it a third time just to be sure. Still very clearly “Hang Mike Pence”.
>
> (Once again this made me wonder if you are trolling, because if you are, you are being amazingly successful.)
Apparently me, CNN, and tons of other people who all watched the clip are all trolling you then. More conspiracy thoery talk.
After this lead in I'm not even going to read the rest of your post.
**I asked you politely to drop it, please do.** I do not find the conversation productive or your current mentality remotely objective enough to be a useful conversation.
PS: I just watched the video again just to make sure, cant imagine how you hear "Hang mike pence" on that video, seems clearly "We want pence", just as CNN transcribed it.
@academicalnerd Good, alwayss great to see quality content. Thats what it is there for. Aside from being highlighted in our menu it is also a great way for users from other servers to follow serious STEM content from QOTO.
Also you may wish to consider posting to the QOTO science group: @Science Oor if you wish feel free to start your own group on a more specific subject (or just your own style). then it will get listed in our group directory.
It provides a similar purpose as hashtags with the exception being that QOTO groups are moderated.
@academicalnerd Its a hash tag for anything of serious effort WRT STEM.. think of it like an open STEM newsletter or magazine where you can post to it openly... Pretty much if its stem related and you any effort into it then feel free to use it.
@snow What a disgusting piece of shit... not Leonie, their cool, you.
Everyone you dislike for any reason you call on the world to harass... everyone but yourself whom clearly you dislike more than most people.
Get help.
I'm sorry but at this point I have to exit the conversation, it is feeling far too much like **arguing with a conspiracy theorist** than someone with any sort of practical outlook. Now **I do respect that you will debate respectfully**, so do **feel free to disagree or interject in the future**, but hopefully next time around it wont be on this level of **absurdity**, **denial of facts**, **lies**, and **exaggerations**.
Just to be clear on why im calling this conversation quits I want to highlight the main points in your discussion that have led me to that conclusion.
## Completely changing fundamental facts
This one is the most obvious and the exchange we **just** had in the last message shows that
You said:
> So an angry mob walking towards people they just chanted about killing
and then your presented evidence in the very next post here:
> My bad, you are right, in this video https://youtu.be/ba0UR7gITrU they probably just finished their laundry and a politely asking for their pants to be hanged.
So now in the most absurd fashion possible you went from a video of people chanting "We want Pence" to that being equivalent to "chanting about killing"
On top of that your claim was they chanted about killing the cops (people) they were walking towards to get int he building. Pence wasnt seen by the crowd at any point and the video not just had nothing to do about chanting death threats, but it wasnt even remotely aimed at the cops they were walking past
## You didnt even watch your own video evidence
At least twice now, at least that you have proven, you have made exaggerated and absurdist claims and repeatedly claimed videos to back it up. In ever case the video didnt have the slightest relationship to the claims you made and in one case you outright admitted to not even watching the video you had claimed to be the biggest piece of evidence you had.
See the following quotes from you:
> And you are trying very hard not to talk about the Texas tweet. It’s very hard to create a charitable explanation of that one.
> Biden ever endorsing political violence, like the Texas tweet did.
> So forcing a car off a road is not violence? It’s a safe thing you do only symbolically?
> I only watched the video with the cars surrounded and heard the claims about someone being forced off the road.
You literally strung out that example as some defacto impossible deny example across four different messages and literally never even watched it, and just assumed what you "heard" was true, putting no effort in of your own to verify truth. Which leads me to the next point...
## You are just parroting liberals
This point is evident from the last, and your general pattern. You have sworn up and down atrocities, which almost certainly is little more than a parroting of what you heard on mainstream media or from liberal friends, from sound bites and 5 second clips.
Then when actually pressed with evidence it is clear you never even watched the videos you held as evidence. Clearly im just arguing with dogma here and a parroting of what you heard, and despite having the weakest evidence those arguments are also the hardest to argue against and change anyone's mind.
## Exaggeration to the point of dishonesty
We covered this already:
* "We want pence" turned into "chanting for murdering the people (cops) they are approaching"
* An anti-trump protestor trying to ram a trump protestor off the road turned into a trump protesters being violent
* Claims of violence from a group where every video you showed to prove it shows no violence from the group towards people of any kind and multiple acts of violence against the group including being beaten with sticks and in one case an unarmed protesters/rioter being shot and killed.
* Implying it was organized, when there was no organized effort for any of it. You had a handful of wackados online who made a few absurd and inappropriate threats but pretty much 0 coordinated effort outside of that.
* Calling a bunch of people taking selfies in the capitol who are unarmed and nonviolent with only about half a dozen actually being destructive or threatening, and even they were completely non-violent against individuals, a "coup".
Honestly I just cant engage in a conversation that has this sort of level of intellectual dishonesty. It isnt a good use of my time.
I'm sorry but at this point I have to exit the conversation, it is feeling far too much like **arguing with a conspiracy theorist** than someone with any sort of practical outlook. Now **I do respect that you will debate respectfully**, so do **feel free to disagree or interject in the future**, but hopefully next time around it wont be on this level of **absurdity**, **denial of facts**, **lies**, and **exaggerations**.
Just to be clear on why im calling this conversation quits I want to highlight the main points in your discussion that have led me to that conclusion.
## Completely changing fundamental facts
This one is the most obvious and the exchange we **just** had in the last message shows that
You said:
> So an angry mob walking towards people they just chanted about killing
and then your presented evidence in the very next post here:
> My bad, you are right, in this video https://youtu.be/ba0UR7gITrU they probably just finished their laundry and a politely asking for their pants to be hanged.
So now in the most absurd fashion possible you went from a video of people chanting "We want Pence" to that being equivalent to "chanting about killing"
On top of that your claim was they chanted about killing the cops (people) they were walking towards to get int he building. Pence wasnt seen by the crowd at any point and the video not just had nothing to do about chanting death threats, but it wasnt even remotely aimed at the cops they were walking past
## You didnt even watch your own video evidence
At least twice now, at least that you have proven, you have made exaggerated and absurdist claims and repeatedly claimed videos to back it up. In ever case the video didnt have the slightest relationship to the claims you made and in one case you outright admitted to not even watching the video you had claimed to be the biggest piece of evidence you had.
See the following quotes from you:
> And you are trying very hard not to talk about the Texas tweet. It’s very hard to create a charitable explanation of that one.
> Biden ever endorsing political violence, like the Texas tweet did.
> So forcing a car off a road is not violence? It’s a safe thing you do only symbolically?
> I only watched the video with the cars surrounded and heard the claims about someone being forced off the road.
You literally strung out that example as some defacto impossible deny example across four different messages and literally never even watched it, and just assumed what you "heard" was true, putting no effort in of your own to verify truth. Which leads me to the next point...
## You are just parroting liberals
This point is evident from the last, and your general pattern. You have sworn up and down atrocities, which almost certainly is little more than a parroting of what you heard on mainstream media or from liberal friends, from sound bites and 5 second clips.
Then when actually pressed with evidence it is clear you never even watched the videos you held as evidence. Clearly im just arguing with dogma here and a parroting of what you heard, and despite having the weakest evidence those arguments are also the hardest to argue against and change anyone's mind.
## Exaggeration to the point of dishonesty
We covered this already:
* "We want pence" turned into "chanting for murdering the people (cops) they are approaching"
* An anti-trump protestor trying to ram a trump protestor off the road turned into a trump protesters being violent
* Claims of violence from a group where every video you showed to prove it shows no violence from the group towards people of any kind and multiple acts of violence against the group including being beaten with sticks and in one case an unarmed protesters/rioter being shot and killed.
* Implying it was organized, when there was no organized effort for any of it. You had a handful of wackados online who made a few absurd and inappropriate threats but pretty much 0 coordinated effort outside of that.
* Calling a bunch of people taking selfies in the capitol who are unarmed and nonviolent with only about half a dozen actually being destructive or threatening, and even they were completely non-violent against individuals, a "coup".
Honestly I just cant engage in a conversation that has this sort of level of intellectual dishonesty. It isnt a good use of my time.
If I really needed to make a court case out of it I would. But at this point the evidence is more than enough for me to draw the conclusion I did, especially given their past pattern of behavior.
@MutoShack I <3 org mode
1) they never admited they didnt do it, sure
2) More importantly they pretty much **did** admit they did it. They claimed they were going to create random accounts ands specifically post the pictures listed in this post:
https://likeable.space/notice/A21ux0IbhoDJIkNxzc
Surprise surprise shortly after that post we have random accounts showing up on QOTO posting **exactly** those images.
But yea Casey is the crazy one for suspecting you, LOL... Snows whole response is "whats your proof".. i half picture some cheezy 80's movie with snow wearing a mustache going "you'll never catch me coppers".
Jeffrey Phillips Freeman
Innovator & Entrepreneur in Machine Learning, Evolutionary Computing & Big Data. Avid SCUBA diver, Open-source developer, HAM radio operator, astrophotographer, and anything nerdy.
Born and raised in Philadelphia, PA, USA, currently living in Utrecht, Netherlands, USA, and Thailand. Was also living in Israel, but left.
Pronouns: Sir / Mister
(Above pronouns are not intended to mock, i will respect any persons pronouns and only wish pronouns to show respect be used with me as well. These are called neopronouns, see an example of the word "frog" used as a neopronoun here: http://tinyurl.com/44hhej89 )
A proud member of the Penobscot Native American tribe, as well as a Mayflower passenger descendant. I sometimes post about my genealogical history.
My stance on various issues:
Education: Free to PhD, tax paid
Abortion: Protected, tax paid, limited time-frame
Welfare: Yes, no one should starve
UBI: No, use welfare
Racism: is real
Guns: Shall not be infringed
LGBT+/minorities: Support
Pronouns: Will respect
Trump: Moron, evil
Biden: Senile, racist
Police: ACAB
Drugs: Fully legal, no prescriptions needed
GPG/PGP Fingerprint: 8B23 64CD 2403 6DCB 7531 01D0 052D DA8E 0506 CBCE