the failure here is in your 2nd point:
> 2) to do 1 and on top of that also increase the amount of oil coming into the country.
You are under the mistaken impression that a pipeline, under any scenario, will increase the overall amount of oil being moved. This is false and not bore out by the data.
1) If there is a truck transport going on, then a pipeline reduces the number of trucks. 2) If there is no truck transport going on and the pipeline is being built to support a new operation, then if the pipline is blocked then they buy trucks and transport in the oil that way.
No one sits on a pile of black gold and goes "Oh well if we cant transport it via a pipeline we will just ignore all the other ways we can transport it and not sell this extremely expensive product we have millions of tons of it"
The fact is, the oil, whether a new construction or old, once identified and owned is getting sold one way or another, blocking a pipeline, doesnt change that fact if the setup is established or not, it just means instead of the pipeline replacing already existing trucks the pipeline would be preventing new trucks from being bought... either way its the same deal and there is no reason to think a preexisting condition changes that equation.
> If the former, then the CO2 emissions will not be realised and the situation stays as it was 2 weeks ago.
Again since the axiom is still incorrect everything that follows it is likewise incorrect.
> If I am right, then technically speaking, stopping the pipeline project _is not_ going to put more trucks on roads, because nothing needs to be replaced. The volumes of oil which now will not be transported were not transported anyway. So there your argument fails a bit.
This statement makes no sense to me. Why would that matter. They have an oil field somewhere, right now the oil is being transported by trucks, building the pipeline means no trucks would be needed, reducing the CO2 footprint. Why does the fact that the pipeline doesnt already exist matter or effect the equation?
Even if we were talking about an oil field that isnt operational, it still would be a failed counter argument. If someone owns a huge oil field and gets denied the pipeline they need to transport it why would you think they wont spend that money on trucks to get it operational? The oil is a source of money and they wont pass that up and is not related to if its in operation or not.
> So (theoretically speaking) the effect of this decision can have twofold effect:
Since your axioms are invalid all the other points made hereafter are likewise invalid.
Yes but those measures ultimately need to be productive to the purpose. Varied measures just for the sake of varying them, even if some of those measures are counter to the goal, wont result in improvements.
So if this were to be taken as analogy to drug addicts then banning pipelines would be like telling one of the biggest drug dealers in their city that they must lace all their coke with heroin before selling it, with the logic that heroin costs more so it would discourage consumption and naively ignoring the fact that it causes more harm than the original.
@bonifartius yea, as a general rule you wont find price has a very strong influence on consumption.
@biomedmax As far as I know the MS strictly forbids nudity and lolicon. So if thats the case lolicon from them should be rare but if you see it you can probably report it and expect the account to be removed.
That could be true, but the data shows little if no effect.
Presuming that is true my guess would be that they just replace their normal commute to work with a similar number of miles taking the family on vacation. The net miles in the end being somewhat the same. Just speculation though, all I know is gas prices have a surprisingly small and insignificant effect on consumption.
Well said, and exactly...
Plus as i stated earlier in this post: https://qoto.org/@freemo/105612036766523680
There is almost 0 impact on the consumption rate of oil anyway.
So what you'd see is at best a amrginal decrease in oil consumption (1% if your lucky, or if at all) and a HUGE spike in CO2 production.
Its equivalent to forcing all power to be generated with coal rather than nuclear because although coal produces way more pollution it costs more so people will buy less.
Its a self defeating ideology when done naively.
Since I worked on this in a data science role I know the numbers intimately. To give you an idea of just how insignificant the price-demand curve is for consumers:
In 2008 we have the most telling data, the average national gasoline price shot down from $4 dollars a gallon to $1.75 a gallon (nominal price) before rising back up again to $4 dollars a gallon in the year or two that followed.
Despite the price having decreased by more than half there was no noticable difference in number of miles driven by vehicals in on the road (total across all vehicles). In fact it **decreased*** slightly from 3.275 trillion miles traveled per year to 3.2 trillion miles traveled per year.
Likewise as the prices rose again there was no significant difference seen either.
Definitively showing that an increase in gas price (or decrease as the case may be) has a negligible effect on consumption, even when the difference in price is extremely significant.
Since I worked on this in a data science role I know the numbers intimately. To give you an idea of just how insignificant the price-demand curve is for consumers:
In 2008 we have the most telling data, the average national gasoline price shot down from $4 dollars a gallon to $1.75 a gallon (nominal price) before rising back up again to $4 dollars a gallon in the year or two that followed.
Despite the price having decreased by more than half there was no noticable difference in number of miles driven by vehicals in on the road (total across all vehicles). In fact it **decreased*** slightly from 3.275 trillion miles traveled per year to 3.2 trillion miles traveled per year.
Likewise as the prices rose again there was no significant difference seen either.
Definitively showing that an increase in gas price (or decrease as the case may be) has a negligible effect on consumption, even when the difference in price is extremely significant.
@koherecoWatchdog As a data scientist ive worked on this problem before, and yes it factored in cost cutting demand, and it isnt hard to do actually. We look closely how gasoline prices effect consumption and it isnt very significant, and certainly does not outweigh the cost-benefits your describing.
@koherecoWatchdog yea the car drivers are of course a big part of the issue, but in fact they arent the bulk of the pollution or the majority of gas consumers. So they really arent where the focus should be. Airplanes and freighters (large boats) are the bigger problem
@biomedmax you can easily just block whole servers if it has content you dont want to see. There are only a small number of servers that allow lolicon and by blocking those servers on your account you're good.
@tursiops Well thats the problem isnt it... people will pay the extra 10 cents to get their gas when a pipeline is cut and it doesn't matter that it costs 10 cents extra or that it equates to an extra few million tons of CO2 in the air than it would have if a pipeline was used.
Which is the very reason stopping pipelines is one of the most idiotic things any president who cares about the environment could possibly do. It tells you they care more about their image (because public will see it as a good thing even when it isnt, just like you did) then they care about the environment.
@koherecoWatchdog not when those scenarios have a net result of more pollution and not less. Blind ignorance towards a goal without analylizing the results of an action is how we cause more harm than good...
Dice it however you want the simple fact, and what the numbers show, is that if you block pipelines the net result is more pollution, not less. Pipelines contribute negliible pollution, Trains for transporting oil alone (and thats more ecofriendly than trucks) contributes 10 million tons of just CO2 for the transport of oil inside the USA. Trucks produce significantly more than that.
@koherecoWatchdog Exactly... which is why its good to try to push for an increase fuel tax (particularly if that fuel tax is going towards ecological investments). But should you fail to get such a law passed (and as you say its likely you may not) then its better to do nothing then to block a pipeline out of desperation and cause far far more damage than doing nothing.
@tursiops Except the reality isnt that simple.
You block a pipeline it doesnt reduce the quantity of oil being consumed in any noticeable quantity. all you've done is move the transport from the most evo-friendly mode of transport (pipelines) to the least eco friendly modes of transport (like trucks)... So the end result is 10,000+ new trucks on the road in an endless line of moving oil from point A to point be and a few million more tons of CO2 in the air than before.
yes but if you have a marginal impact on the cost and a HUGE impact on the CO2 output you arent having any positive impact, your just punching yourself in the face repeatidly.
@koherecoWatchdog If you cant implement solutions that reduce oil consumption, real solutions, then better to do nothing.
Blocking pipelines is a huge step backwards and is effectively dumping millions of tons of CO2 into the air with no real benefit other than costing people a few pennies on their gas price which we already know people will easily pay anyway.
Jeffrey Phillips Freeman
Innovator & Entrepreneur in Machine Learning, Evolutionary Computing & Big Data. Avid SCUBA diver, Open-source developer, HAM radio operator, astrophotographer, and anything nerdy.
Born and raised in Philadelphia, PA, USA, currently living in Utrecht, Netherlands, USA, and Thailand. Was also living in Israel, but left.
Pronouns: Sir / Mister
(Above pronouns are not intended to mock, i will respect any persons pronouns and only wish pronouns to show respect be used with me as well. These are called neopronouns, see an example of the word "frog" used as a neopronoun here: http://tinyurl.com/44hhej89 )
A proud member of the Penobscot Native American tribe, as well as a Mayflower passenger descendant. I sometimes post about my genealogical history.
My stance on various issues:
Education: Free to PhD, tax paid
Abortion: Protected, tax paid, limited time-frame
Welfare: Yes, no one should starve
UBI: No, use welfare
Racism: is real
Guns: Shall not be infringed
LGBT+/minorities: Support
Pronouns: Will respect
Trump: Moron, evil
Biden: Senile, racist
Police: ACAB
Drugs: Fully legal, no prescriptions needed
GPG/PGP Fingerprint: 8B23 64CD 2403 6DCB 7531 01D0 052D DA8E 0506 CBCE