Found wrong about what exactly? Are you saying those 5 people were intentionally killed by Trump protestors now?
As I said in the OP, aside from the cop who was violently beating people trump protestors didnt murder a single person. Who has shown that not to be the case, i havent seen it.
@pthenq1 "violently breaking a window"... violence against innamate objects doesnt count as justification to murder someone.
Im not a police officer, and the federal building isnt a private home. but that aside...
Are you telling me if someone was unarmed and nonviolent but broke the window to your home youd get out your gun and shoot them dead?
Me personally I wouldnt just kill someone for breaking my window when it is clear they dont have a gun and/or are not brandishing it.
@pganssle Not really.. one was an accidental death, so irrelevant as you point out.. the other (the police officer) was actively beating people with his stick, so striking him would count as self defence, not deliberate murder. Not that I justify the violence on either side.. but if your beating people bloody with your baton and the group retaliates by hitting you in the head, your hardly innocent.
@pthenq1 yes they warned an unarmed non-violent woman that she would be shot dead before she was shot dead... what about it?
@pganssle I dont recall me saying anything about blaming police for those deaths, nor did I place blame on anyone.
The point here is that the 5 deaths are continually mentioned without context and causes people to imply that the crowd was violent and going around killing people, which simply wasnt the case.
@pthenq1 You keep arguing against things I never said.. As I pointed out a very small handful of people there had the intention of physically stopping the elections, and those people (as you pointed out) had delusions of grandeur of a coup.
The vast majority where there to peacefully protest, and the vast majority did exactly that. Aside from a small handful there was little to no intention of anyone starting a coup. But for that small handful of people, yes, they had that delusion.
@pthenq1 Aside from a small handful of people no one had any intention of a coup.. most were walking around taking selfies.
Regardless its not the point being discussed. but of the people who did have real intent to start a coup, by all means arrest them and try them, hell you can arrest the people taking selfies too they knew they werent allowed there... none of that is the point.. you dont shoot people dead when they arent not being physically violent against another person and have no weapons... proportional response, always proportional response.
@pthenq1 Sure, how is that in any way remotely relevant.. you do not shoot dead an armed non-violent accomplice.
If you want to argue that they should be arrested and tried for a crime, sure, you wont get any disagreement from me on that, so your point is moot.
Whatever you want to call the unarmed non-violent individuals who were murdered are fine with me. I dont condone what they did, but what they did isnt even close to as bad as murdering an unarmed person who is not being violent towards another person in cold blood. They should have (and would have been in the right for using) non-violent means if they wanted. Pepperspray, teargas, rubber bullets all could have been justified against an unarmed person breaking into a capitol building. but once you murder a non-violent unarmed person you loose any right to having the high ground regardless of what they were doing.
uspol, doubting one's sanity, empiricism, wasting resources!
@timorl ill look through it again when i have a chance
For now i will say the one you picked is actually the one I'd expect to be most likely to come across as "hang mike pence" only because it is the one where the "we" which is the most distinguishing characteristic is most muffled and "mike pence" and "want pence" have similar meter.
@rlamacraft Also notice in the video you posted 3 policeman hold off the crowd and are not assaulted even once, despite their clear intention to get inside not one single person strikes an officer in that crowd or do you see them attempting to injur or hurt anyone in that video at any point.
However you **do** see a police officer behind the door shooting and killing the unarmed and non-violent protests for breaking the window and trying to enter.
They are destroying property, and what they are doing is wrong, and ive said this before, but that doesnt change the fact that an unarmed person who did not commit violence against any persons was shot dead.
@rlamacraft Never said how they behaved was acceptable, or that they were non-confrontational.. I did say that they they were unarmed and non-violent. More specifically:
1) The vast majority did not strike, injure or otherwise cause violence against a person. The only exceptions I know of this was in response to first being beaten physically by the person who was attacked, and even then I only know of one such case
2) Multiple protestors, all unarmed, none of whom phyiscally assaulted anyone were killed
Moreover, it wasnt until AFTER the first unarmed protesters was murdered that more wide spread aggression started taking place (though still only isolated cases of physical violence).
Surprise surprise, 4 out of 5 of the people who died at the capitol hill riots were unarmed and non-violent pro-trump supporters, the one none Trump supporter killed was a cop who was struck in the head while he was actively beating people with his baton, effectively the one initiating violence and the crowd defended itself by the sound of it, in the interaction he got struck and died a day later from the head injury. Its sad that he got hit and I dont justify the violence overall, but if your the one sitting there beating people with a stick people fighting back is kind of the expectation, its not an acceptable tactic against unarmed civilians IMO.
https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/11/us/who-died-in-capitol-building-attack.html
uspol, doubting one's sanity, empiricism, wasting resources!
@timorl yes i would cut it up the way you cut it up, but would not have picked the snipped you picked to cut up (it is the least clear of all of them IMO)
uspol, doubting one's sanity, empiricism, wasting resources!
@timorl Then you are trying to test soemthing very different then what you said you were trying to test, and thats fine.. what you are trying to test is, what was most likely actually said. Thats fine and a great thing to test, but also wouldnt tell you, then, anything about which of us is politically biased.
uspol, doubting one's sanity, empiricism, wasting resources!
@timorl In my view if i were walking down the street and you happened to be standing in my way and I said "move" and you didnt, and i walked through you, causing you to stumble to the side unharmed, then no that isnt violence, violence implies you have been harmed in some way. If you were to respond to taht by taking a baton and bashing me over the head then I would say you were the one initiating violence.
> . And applied to the latter, especially in the case of crowds, it would make any kind of crowd control impossible.
non violent crowd control is not just possible, its far more effective., you have pepper sprays, physical barriers, sound weapons, and a host of non-violent tools that are far far more effective than physical beatings.
Keep in mind I did say someone being pushed aside, such as a cop in this case is inappropriate, and wrong.. but it isnt violence.
Ultimately its about escalation, it is absolutely unacceptable to respond to one act with another significantly more violent act.. you do not repond to someone pushing through you by beating them over the head with a stick as they did, you do not shoot them to death when unarmed and havent struck anyone, as they did, etc.
We even uphold this principle in our own laws (though sadly as of late cops are above the law), it is the law of proportionality, you are allowed to defend yourself but only with similar force as that which you are threatened. so for example shooting an unarmed non violent protest dead for bashing in a window, however wrong that may be, is not proportional and makes YOU the bad guy, not them.
uspol, doubting one's sanity, empiricism, wasting resources!
@timorl yes but those biases dont work against what youa re testing they work for it. I remind you what your testing for from your OP:
> 1. I am so influenced by propaganda my basic senses are broken.
2. The above, but for the other participant.
3. This specific video is an auditory case of blue/black vs white/gold dress.
So you are trying to determine if people hear if we were hearing what we were hearing because its what the chant **sounded like** (not what it actually was) or if we were hearing what we were hearing due to our **personal political biases**
If you eliminate people who already know the context of the chant then you eliminated any chance of what someone hears is due to political bias, as they have no context for that. Therefore what you get when people hear the whole phrase will be what the average person, not viewing it within any politicial framework, is likely to hear "hang mike pence" or "we want pence".
If, as you say people who hear any chant are more likely to lean towards "we want pence" simply because that is a more common wording for a chant, then youa re arguing that me hearing "we want pence" is more likely **not** to be due to political bias than you hearing "hang mike pence" would be (since the latter is not what a non-political context bias would lean towards).
So in fact while the biases you describe are valid, they are also entierly in line with what you were testing for and not biases you would even want to eliminate.
uspol, doubting one's sanity, empiricism, wasting resources!
@timorl depends on how they do it.. breaking a window isnt violence against a person, someone standing in your way and you simply walking past them anyway (pushing through them) also isnt violence...
Now if someone stands in your way and you beat them with a stick till they move, then that IS violence.
Ironically the only one (for the most part) being anyone with sticks were the cops.
I would say that they "physically overpowered" the cops, I would also say that a small number of people (the ones breaking glass) were "destructive of property"... but violence towards an individual is not something that is guaranteed as a matter of course simply by walking into a building you arent allowed or walking through a line of people standing in your way, particularly when no one actually struck a cop to do it
uspol, doubting one's sanity, empiricism, wasting resources!
@timorl Only way i could see it increasing bias is if it causes someone to identify the scene it came from and remember it. But we should already be rulling that out by asking explicitly if that is the case. Presuming, however, that they are unable to identify the setting in which the chant occured and never heard about it or saw the video then I cant see why it would increase bias.
But our brains need context to understand what is being said even in the best of circumstances. The "chinese telephone" example that is often done in schools is a great example of that, single words become distorted very quickly as they are passed on but phrases tend to remain intact and are understood and rarely become changed into something refelecting ones biases (though im sure it does happen).
uspol, doubting one's sanity, empiricism, wasting resources!
This is the first time you refered to it as threatening/aggressive behavior rather than violence. That is a big difference in my eyes. There is a huge chasm between being physically violent towards a human being vs breaking a window, one I will call violence, the other I would agree is aggressive and even threatening, but isnt violence.
There is also the matter of considering who strikes a human first in an encounter of mutual violence to determine who is in the right in my mind.
So take the example of the police officer being beaten by the flagpole.. had he at any point earlier int he day beaten people in the crowd with his baton? Every single incident i saw where a police officer was even threatened (such as the one running through the halls as people chassed him while he periodically stopped to beat them a little with his baton)... in every case it can be seen the police officer initiating the violence by beating them with their baton or similar, and only after that (and usually repeated examples of that) did the crowd respond with any level of violence.
Even then those examples are very rare, in one case we have the officer who died who was reported and admitted to be actively beating the crowd with his baton before finally being struck, and in the other case with the flagpole, which we dont have video evidence to know, but seems possible he was doing the exact same thing.
Only other physical violence of any kind I know of from the events were explicitly non-lethal but also in like kind. For example they were being actively tear/pepper gassed by police and one protestor responded by pepper spraying the police in return.
REgardless overall it appears far more violence was done on them then they did in return, as is evidence by the death toll being almost exclusively trump supporters.
Jeffrey Phillips Freeman
Innovator & Entrepreneur in Machine Learning, Evolutionary Computing & Big Data. Avid SCUBA diver, Open-source developer, HAM radio operator, astrophotographer, and anything nerdy.
Born and raised in Philadelphia, PA, USA, currently living in Utrecht, Netherlands, USA, and Thailand. Was also living in Israel, but left.
Pronouns: Sir / Mister
(Above pronouns are not intended to mock, i will respect any persons pronouns and only wish pronouns to show respect be used with me as well. These are called neopronouns, see an example of the word "frog" used as a neopronoun here: http://tinyurl.com/44hhej89 )
A proud member of the Penobscot Native American tribe, as well as a Mayflower passenger descendant. I sometimes post about my genealogical history.
My stance on various issues:
Education: Free to PhD, tax paid
Abortion: Protected, tax paid, limited time-frame
Welfare: Yes, no one should starve
UBI: No, use welfare
Racism: is real
Guns: Shall not be infringed
LGBT+/minorities: Support
Pronouns: Will respect
Trump: Moron, evil
Biden: Senile, racist
Police: ACAB
Drugs: Fully legal, no prescriptions needed
GPG/PGP Fingerprint: 8B23 64CD 2403 6DCB 7531 01D0 052D DA8E 0506 CBCE