Show newer

I feel like im overdue for a watching of the Dead Poets Society... I might need to give it a watch in the next few days...

@justin Oh yes, of course.. and I do hope that is how it plays out.

But as I said before the fact that it got through a top circuit court already and was upheld is pretty fucking scary in its own right.

@emilis I mean, saturn is obviously a tea.. it is ingredients suspended in a liquid.

@SuperDicq We just need it processed first, usually through a cow and converted into meat.

@justin ok so your saying now that they may rule either way?

By the way just to be clear #1 means the lower courts rulling is **only** precedent in 1/5th of the USA and it doesnt become precedences throughout the entire court system unless and until the supreme court hears it (which by the way is why they often take cases where they are likely to uphold the lower courts ruling ).

So apparently this is a picture of a "chef's salad" from a local restaurant in Philly. I cant stop laughing at the fact that they call this a salad and its basically just a pile of meat and cheese, you can barely find the little tidbit of green poking out from underneath.

@justin Again, no, they take cases all the time (just as often as the contrary) when they agree with the case...

Why do you think the supreme court takes so many other cases that they wind up rulling in favor of the lower court's decision? If your reasoning made any sense such cases would be rare and they arent.

@justin Huh, they do it all the time (take a case and rule the case valid). It is just as common for them to rule in either direction.

@justin Can't imagine why you would assume that, how do you know they arent taking the case to uphold the lower courts rulling?

@swiley strictly speaking, yes, in practice, no.. interpritation goes a long way. the "Community doctrine" isnt a law that was passed that is being tested, it is existing precedence on the interpretation of the 4th amendment. The very idea is entierly fabricated within the court system and for all intents and purposes has all the effect and efficacy of a law.

The distinction between law and precedence only becomes relevant when you consider the cycle that can exist if the law making body (congress in this case) disagrees with the courts. The courts can add all sorts of "interpritations" like this that have all the same effects any law would so long as the law doesnt directly or explicitly contradict it (well even then they could but arent supposed to). What congress could do, however, is rewrite the 4th ammendment or create new laws that directly clarify the courts interpritation and effectively eliminates the "community doctrine" principle.

So effectively what that means is when laws and the constitution isnt extremely explicit there is usually enough room for the courts to create interpretations that have all the effect of an unjust law. Since amendments to the constitution are a lot harder to achieve than courts making a ruling on the constitution this effectively gives the court system a lot of room to "mold" laws into meaning almost whatever they want them to.

@swiley The fact that its already gotten through as many appeals court as it has (and as of right now is the "law" and upheld by the courts in a large portion of america unless and until SCOTUS overturns it) is scary enough

SCOTUS is just the last desperate attempt to fix this injustice, remember there are many levels of appeals each one have a larger and larger jurisdiction up to that point. So its already law in a huge swatch of the USA as a result.

@blucrunch well no, they lied in order to get into the house, then search it, then take the guns, all of which where no crime has happened or was suspected.. cant imagine that would hold up in court.

@blucrunch The olice can not lie to you to force you to hand over your legally owned handguns though, so I wouldnt say that applies here, not that I'm a lawyer either.

@TonyStark We have the first segregationist as president in living history. A man who started hist whole political career to fight to support segregation... its a disgrace, yea, we have a LONG way to go yet thats for sure.

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.