Show newer

@pthenq1 my friend with the condition hid it for many years before being diagnosed, so thats BS

@pthenq1 Even if 95% of murders are carried out by them, 99.99% of them will never murder anyone.. nothing reasonable about it.. you create a situation where 99.9% of people who would never kill anyone now can no longer seek help without loosing fundemental rights so go untreated and have to hide their condition.. all in the hopes of stopping the 0.01% of them.

So you have now made the entire group dangerous and untreated in a naive and unethical attempt to stop 0.01% of them from crimes.

I bet if you run the statistics youll find 98% of mass shootings are done by men (I cant think of a single woman who did it).. so by that logic only women should be allowed guns... This type of thinking is dangerous, reckless, and stupid. Not to mention causes WAY more harm than it fixes.

@pthenq1

Are you literally arging that the dictionary definition is wrong and you are right?

@icedquinn

@pthenq1 i think its fine to discourage a psycotic not to buy weapons, but the second you make it illegal if they seek treatment you create a situation where psychotics are forced to hide their condition and not seek treatment... worst idea ever

@pthenq1

Definition of neurotic: "A person afflicted by neurosis"

Definition of neurosis: "Neurosis is a class of functional mental disorders involving chronic distress, but neither delusions nor hallucinations."

@icedquinn

@pthenq1

No you are using the terms absolutely wrong, a neurotic person is one with a mental disorder, but where the mental disorder does not include delusion or hallucination... Normal people who have no mental disorders are not neurotic.

@icedquinn

@pthenq1

Lets make this clear.. .if someone is schizofrenic or a psychopath, and goes to a psychiatrist asking for help with their condition, and the psychiatrist evaluates them and identifies them as a psychopath and agrees to help treat them... should this cause the psychopath to loose their right to guns or not?

If not, how do you even propose psychopaths be identified by this "background check" of yours?

@icedquinn

@pthenq1

I know what they are but you havent addressed the problem.. You are suggesting a system where my friend who was schizofrenic should have continued to hide his condition and avoid a psychiatrist to retain his rights, something he did successfully for years, making him far more of a risk than a medicated person with their rights in tacts and condition treated.

@icedquinn

@icedquinn

Psychopaths are also neurotic.. he is using the terminology wrong. Psychopaths do not expiernce delusion or hallucination and therefore would be a neurotic.

@pthenq1

@pthenq1

My friend has schizofrenia, therefore is not neurotic. He goes tot he therapist for treatment... so your statement makes no sense that only neurotics go to therapists.

My friend with schizophrenia would literally have been forced not to go to a psychiatrist when he suspect he was developing the disease for fear he would loose his right to self protection. He would have been forced to try to hide his disorder at all costs rather than seek treatment as he did.

Moreover, they can and often are treated. Medication can eliminate their hallucinations, so your argument they cant be treated is also false.

@icedquinn

@pthenq1

So you are back to the idea that you penalize people who think they have a mental condition and seek psychiatric help by perminantly taking away their right to guns for life.. and you think this is a good idea.

All your doing is creating a situation where people with mental disorders need to hide it at all costs and never seek help or a psychiatrist for it because they dont want to loose their right to self protection...

It is a horrific idea and im not sure why you dont get that.

@smithy @icedquinn

@pthenq1

So a psychotic o psychopath who wants to get help.. only they will be forced not to get help?

And schizophrenics who hallucinate people that arent there, them your cool having guns?

@icedquinn

@pthenq1

You still havent addressed the fundamental concern.. you are proposing a situation where if a person goes to a therapist to get treatment they automatically forfeit part of their rights, for life.. so you are effectively discouraging people from going to psychiatrists. Sounds like a pretty shitty solution that will cause way more harm than good.

@icedquinn

@pthenq1

you just ignored all the concerns raised and reiterated your point... so your basically telling people that if they are found to have a condition they loose rights and thus are punished for seeking medical treatment if they feel they have a mental disorder... worst suggestion ive ever heard.

@icedquinn

@pthenq1

There are two things you can mean by that.. banning it for people who were commited against their will by commiting a crime, those people are already banned from having guns..

Or your suggesting the right to bare arms should be revoked for anyone who voluntarily chooses to go to a psychiatrist and has been treated?

The second one is the only one where they can currently get tguns.. but it makes no sense. There is no public registry where people who seek psychiatric treatment on their own get registered and publicly can be "pinged" in a check... so your suggesting something quite obscene, that if I decide to call a psychiatrist and seek help then I will get on a public registry where gun shops can look me up, and my rights become revoked...

For one having a public registry where people are punished for seeking mental health is beyond a horrible idea, doubly so if the consequence is to loose your fundemental rights.

Do you really think anyone who is struggling with a mental disorder who feels they need to see a psychiatrist is going to do it if the law states that should they go to get treated they forfit a basic right for the rest of their life?

God what a horrible idea.

@icedquinn

@pthenq1

not sure how you can do "more" background checks.. they already do background checks on all the shit a background check can cover (criminal past, parking tickets, outstanding debt)... what are they proposing to check my background twice? lol

@icedquinn

@icedquinn

If they actually played by the rules they would just make a new amendment, legal, no problem.. oh wait.. they cant get the votes! So instead they try to erode it in other ways.

@pthenq1

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.