Show newer

@koherecoWatchdog

No, my claim is that any policy where you demand a shipping company violate customer privacy in order to comply with your demands is one that encourages violation of privacy, perpetuates it, and makes it much more difficult for those fighting for user privacy to achieve their goals.

@thenewoil @realcaseyrollins

@koherecoWatchdog

For some vvery strange reason you seem to think im arguing you should or shouldnt use fedex, I am not. I am arguing that your conditions upon which you use to pick what shipping companies you go with lead to unethical pressures and thus should not be employed. Beyond that I am not advocating for any particular shipping company.

@realcaseyrollins @thenewoil

@koherecoWatchdog

I've already explained why I dont need to, nor is it relevant, if FedEx is less intrustive or not. I will not repeat myself again.

@realcaseyrollins @thenewoil

@koherecoWatchdog

Which of the choices you go with after you weigh all the options isnt much of a concern for me, thats for you to decide.

My issues is, as I said, that having a personal policy to boycott companies that refuse to violate customer privacy and therefore will not be beholden to the contents they choose to ship, is an unethical policy to have and to apply when evaluating which company to go with.

@thenewoil @realcaseyrollins

@koherecoWatchdog

Just to illustrate how absurd that statement was imagine this was in the past a bit before Fedex had decided to ban shark fins. Since none of the major companies banned shark fins and they all shipped it by your logic any boycotting is "a moot point".

The truth is just because all the companies act unethically to the same degree in no way makes it a moot point, in fact all the more reason you shouldn't be encouraging that unethical behavior and the violation of customer's privacy.

@thenewoil @realcaseyrollins

@koherecoWatchdog

No its not all the same, you should be boycotting companies that violate customer privacy, your personal boycott is mutually exclusive to this however and in fact **encourages** and rewards this already unethical behavior.

@thenewoil @realcaseyrollins

@koherecoWatchdog

No couriers routinely open boxes and x-ray them to investigate content, all courriers do. Which as I said is a violation of privacy and should be seen as unacceptable. By boycotting in such a way that not only deems those methods acceptable but encourages their use is unethical choice on your part IMO. As I've said you shouldnt be encouraging boycotts which effectively demand companies utilize their already unacceptable violation of customer privacy.

@realcaseyrollins @thenewoil

@koherecoWatchdog

Yes, and i never once responded to "slace dolphins" in the thread, its a tangent I dont want to add onto the list.

@thenewoil @realcaseyrollins

@koherecoWatchdog

Huh? We werent talking about dolphins. We were talking about shark fins. Which Are in an opaque box with ice the vast majority of the time and thus unable to be identified without looking inside. Dolphins are an entierly different issue.

@realcaseyrollins @thenewoil

@koherecoWatchdog

Exactly you think they should have a right to be able to invade the privacy of their customers, I do not. Thats really the only place we disagree, everything comes from that.

@thenewoil @realcaseyrollins

@koherecoWatchdog

That makes no sense. I am evaluating the unethical nature of your boycott not the unethical natures of the company.

The truth is if your going to ban shipping shark fins then that implies a company has a right to knowledge as to the contents of what your shipping in the first place. You can do all the mental gymnastics you want but you arent going to get away form that.

@realcaseyrollins @thenewoil

@koherecoWatchdog

I never once claimed that any of those companies were better towards customer privacy than any others. so not relevant.

@thenewoil @realcaseyrollins

@koherecoWatchdog

No I claimed that a boycott on shipping companies in general that ship shark fins is effectively putting pressure on companies to violate customer privacy, therefore it is an unethical stance.

I never once claimed your boycott on FedEx has in anyway been successful or actually had the intended result.

@realcaseyrollins @thenewoil

@koherecoWatchdog

I never even mentioned USPS why would I have to... my criticism as I said is of your policy to boycott companies that transport shark fin. I made no endorsement or debasement of a specific company.

To repeat my stance is:

It is unethical as it leads to pressure to violate customer privacy, to expect a shipping company to make ethical decisions on the content of the packages being shipped and use that to determine if they will or will not ship a package. Any boycott which adds pressure on companies to violate customer privacy is an unethical position to take.

@thenewoil @realcaseyrollins

@koherecoWatchdog

I'd say they loose unethical customers.. the customers they loose are making unethical demands not ethical ones.

@realcaseyrollins @thenewoil

@koherecoWatchdog

Good, as i said its not their place to do diligence on the contents of your package. That is why we have laws and police officers.

@thenewoil @realcaseyrollins

@koherecoWatchdog

It isnt about UPS policies, its about your choice to boycott companies that ship shark fin.

Are you saying your stance is such that if UPS is shipping just as much shark fin as FedEx but just require the company not be named "shark fin soup inc" then you would not boycott them? Obviously that doesnt appear to be your stance. It appears you care that shark fins are being shipped, if they are shipped you boycott them, which implies you expect them to take invasive action to ensure they dont get shipped (as anything else would be ineffective short of changing laws)

@realcaseyrollins @thenewoil

@mur2501 maybe leave some food out for him and water?

@tombies@social.tchncs.de

@koherecoWatchdog

I am not advocating people use UPS either, nor am I advocating for or against FedEx.

What I am saying is as a cosumer boycotting a company and demanding they take a position that requires them as a matter of course to violate their customers privacy, and then use that violation to determine if they will black list them or not even when they engage in perfectly legal activities is NOT something that is helping the world. The last thing you should be doing is demanding these companies act in a way that prevents them from honoring their customers privacy.

@thenewoil @realcaseyrollins

@koherecoWatchdog

Thats not even remotely related to my claim here is.

It would be more akin to a shop owner demanding they strip search every customer that comes in the door and then decide if he likes you or not, and thus will sell to you, based on the contents of your pockets.

While a store owner would have a right to do this, I'd find it unethical as well..

The issue here with the shipping and with the analogy is one of a right for the customers privacy, nothing else.

@thenewoil @realcaseyrollins

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.