Show newer

@ejg

We cant have different definitions of wealth, the term is very well defined for us already. Perhaps you are using an incorrect definition of wealth you coined yourself, I dont know, but I am just using the established definition.

For starters, net worth is not wealth, though they have a relationship.. someone with 100$ in 1910 doesnt have the same wealth as 100$ in 2020, nor does a person with 100$ in NYC in worth have the same wealth as 100$ of someone in alabama. So lets be clear about that since you seem uncertain about how we are using our terms...

Second yes, some people on that list have a lot of money, some have something far greater than a lot of money... so? No matter how much money some people might have doesnt turn into a bad thing, again, how much they have, even when its a lot, doesnt imply you have less as a consequence of it. There is no "problem" there to solve just because someone has a lot of something.

@FailForward

@ejg

> Employing people doesn't necessarily generate wealth for them. The $15/hr they get lets them rent an apartment, own a car and pay for food.

Actually it does, relatively speaking. If those people had no work at all they would be generating negative wealth (destroying wealth). So while keeping them emloyed may generate very little wealth individually, perhaps even 0, it is still significantly more than if they had no job or income.

> That little old lady needs a better financial advisor, and to not put her entire retirement in one company.

Never claimed she had all her money in one company. Even if her portfolio is 1% amazon overall when you consider that money across **all** little old ladies with retirement funds its a huge amount. Also, presumably if the whole fallacy of "someone having a lot of money is bad" were true we would be talking about far more than amazon and bezos.

> Amazon being gone would allow others to grow to fill the void left behind, generating wealth for them.

Certainly true, and then you have brand new multi-billion dollar companies so it solved nothing. But more importantly this statement misses the point.. the point is simple, he isnt just generating wealth for him and his select cohort of friends.. he is generating wealth that old ladies, and minimum wage workers share in as well.

@FailForward

@realcaseyrollins they were beating the crowd with their batons even though they were behind the barriers. At one point you can see a cop pull a person over from the other side of the barrier, drag them into an open space and then beat him, even after he was cuffed.. yoiu hear the crowd chanting in disgust things like "We should do that to you!".. this was all just a few minutes before they surged and broke through the barriers.

@ejg

The wealth he is creating is for all americans, some just less directly than others. If overnight you took everything he owned and destroyed it (not took it from him, but destroyed the thing he created) a lot of people will be out of work and starving, little old ladies wiith reiterment funds will go bankrupt, a lot of people would be effected.

@FailForward

@realcaseyrollins It seemed obvious to me that the capitol police treatment of the people is what led to the riots. Especially if you watch the video of the police's treatment of the crowd prior to them storming them.

@FailForward That is somewhat moot becauSE eventually shared get sold, the longer you held them before selling and the more value the accumulated the more tax you spend when you liquidate. So all profit will eventually be taxed, not to do so means you never have the money to buy anything anyway. Even if you try to pull out dividends on your shares youd get taxed.

@FailForward @jlo

> Warren Buffet and Bill Gates are on the record that they actually SHALL and WANT to pay more taxes

They can donate more taxes then they owe if they want, nothing stopping them. No reason they have any right to speak for all rich people.

Moreover it is telling that the 2 people who are rich and ok with more taxes are the ones who are very old and on the verge of dying, and care a lot about their legacy and how they will be seen on their way out. But it will be the younger generation of rich who will bear this burden, not them.

> even if they wanted to, they cannot just send an invented gift bill to the state.

Of course they can, they can donate whatever they want to the state.. why not?

> Seriously, if somebody owns most of their wealth only on paper, how shall we tax them?

The same way we always have, by taxing a percentage of that wealth when it "moves"... rich eople are already taxed for the money they gained when it was income.

> Personally I think it’s the fault of the mid-level wealthy people (your usual backyard millionaires, which is maybe you, or your neighbour) who are blocking the right laws to be passed because they are afraid that their small nest egg will diminish.

More like we care about fairness and justice. Being taxed the extraordinary rate anyone in the upperclass already is, isnt fair and it isnt solving anything.. what problem is it your even trying to solvE? Most of the answer to this question make it clear that the problems being imagined are in some cases non existent and in others arent a problem where the solution is "we need to make rich people less rich"

In the end people are trying to solve a problem that doesnt exist and in doing so would make things worse IMO

@ejg

@realcaseyrollins I see, interesting... I wouldnt really know other than to say womens shoes run smaller

@FailForward Huh? Those schemes are already taxed at extraordinary amounts. Owning something and taking all the risks of loss that entails and then needing to pay half of all your incom as tax is simply unacceptable IMO and relies on the fallacy of money being a 0-sum game. The false idea that some people having more money must means others have less as a result.. its not how money works

@ejg

Sure, and that should be addressed, you dont address it by taxing assets and make such a dream impossible though, thats for damn sure.

@FailForward

@ejg

Sit on? That money isnt sitting in a big vault of gold he goes swimming in every day like duck tales.

He literally has that money in businesses employing countless people and **creating** new wealth both for him and the country.

Again money isnt a zero sum game, him having more doesnt mean you have less, in fact, it means you have more as he is ultimately using it to generate ew wealth.

@FailForward

@ejg

I would disagree.. I think the fact that you can never truly "own" your home, that even if you buy it you have to pay for it perpetually is very much disastrous.

A person should have the right to work hard, buy themselves a home, and then be free of that financial obligation, thats the point.

Taxing on assets, like a home, is just a way of saying you can never truly own anything, a government ill forever tax your assets and eventually should you ever fall on hard times financially loose everything you own and get nothing for it as it will all go to just cover the taxes you were unable to pay (and should have never hard to).

Yes taxing ownership of property is particularly heinous IMO.

@FailForward

@ejg

The very mentality that asset ownership need be taxed is diseasterous to say the least. It relies on the zero sum fallacy of economics for one.

@FailForward

@jlo

That's a scary precedence to say the least. The very fact that people think someone owning a lot is somehow a problem that needs to be corrected is already worrisome in its own right. Wealth is not a pie, someone having more doesnt mean you have less. Its not a zero sum game.

@FailForward @ejg

@BigSkyRider I would think it would be obvious.. you said "if it provides no additional protection, do we still have to call it a vaccine"... then you provided an image with no relevance to anything showing that COVID, like all vaccines, work by giving the same protections as catching the disease... Ignoring the fact that yes, it still protects you, if you never got the disease it is a way to be protected without getting the disease (duh!).

Hope that clarifies it for you.

@BigSkyRider What this post makes no sense... How is this any different than any other vaccine? They protect people who havent gotten the disease, they arent for people who have it, no vaccines are.

@freemo @ejg I agree with what @freemo points out. People get outraged about how rich somebody is. And that is true. Except huge part of that wealth is only on paper in the fluctuating value of financial (and other assets). But nobody pays taxes over their net worth increases, we pay taxes from realised income.

Anyhow, these concepts have issues. For instance where I live, it can happen that you own say 50 shares of a startup (let it be 50%) which is worth 1000 bucks starting capital, then the next day investor comes along, buys another half for 1Mio bucks and the third day you have the tax office on your neck to pay taxes from a wealth increase (income) of 999k bucks, while all along your cash position did not change at all.

What I am trying to point out is this: Whenever people complain about rich people not paying tax on their wealth increases, the real question to them should be:
1. So how exactly will you legislate it so as not to harm everybody along the way?
2. And suppose if we all pay taxes even over wealth increases which are only on paper (because the stock you own or control went up due to market fluctuations, or geopolitics), what will we do when next year a person's net worth actually decreases? Will the tax office reimburse us, or what?

These are just headlines to cause outrage, nothing else. What actually helps is to tighten up the laws about income taxation and also classification what constitutes income and what does not. If e.g., Bezos has a salary of 1000 bucks and that's all he lives off, he shall pay taxes as a 1k income guy. But if he besides that lives in a house owned by Amazon Inc, drives a car owned by Amazon Inc. and flies Amazon-owned aircraft in his private capacity, then those effects should be counted as his income too. There are countries where this is sorted (at least on smaller scale) better.

@kotovalexarian@liberdon.com

Then it also isnt stealing or evil if a big company takes your personal proprietary code and steals it either.. as long as your consistent.

@Vectorfield

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.