Show newer

@agoradefense

You dont seem to know what "legitimate" means. the holocaust would be legitimate according to Nazi rule, and illegitimate according to international law. Saying a thing is legitimate must always imply by what rule system or system of law it is legitimized..

But yes, from the Nazi legal system the holocaust was as legitimate as anything else, and by international law illigitimate.

Copyright and IP law however is legitimate in nearly ever system of law we have on the planet.

@herag @Albright @null0x0

@JackMeinoff No BTC is a bad coin too, its only advantage is that it is the oldest, so it will hang on longer.

You are literally investing in a coin that has absolutely nothing to bring to the table, has never shown any sliver of success, and since its public opening went nowhere but down...

What possible argument could you even make in support of the coin? Ethereum itself has an argument to be made, as do many other coins like ADA, or even ripple... Shib literally has nothing one could argue for in its favor.

@herag

No it doesnt exist in my mind. It has been codified on paper, executed through actions.. etc.

As for it not being legitimate, you clearly dont know what the meaning of that word is. Legitimate is defined as "conforming to the law or rules"... It is quite literally legitimate by definition.

You cant in one breath say that they exist and are real, and then in the same breath try to claim they are a fiction... you are making not a lick of sense. What you probably mean is you dont agree with it, or that the ideas it espouses are human creations.. but none of that makes it a fantasy. Your throwing words around and using them in a way that is in no way related to what those words mean.

@Albright @null0x0

@realcaseyrollins

Normally I'd be ok with that but a few things

1) I wont pay to become a criminal and have the same status as a non-paying person

2) I wont demonstrate my support for the existence of #1

If there is a DRM free version I will happily pay. If there is no DRM free version i will pirate on principle. If at a later point a non-DRM version is sold I will buy it even if I pirated it.

@null0x0

@herag

> So it is 'real' why?

Because it exists and is utilized by society. I cant believe I need explain the meaning of "real".

If i imagine a picture of a unicorn in my head then that thought is real, the unicorn is not, but i actually had the thought and therefore it is real.

I really shouldnt need to explain what the meaning of real is. No it has nothing to with who set up the system or how many people support it. So long as it exists, tangibly or not, then it is real, buy definition.

@Albright @null0x0

@agoradefense

Ummmm what, yes thats **exactly** what legitimate means. The definition of legitimate is:

"conforming to the law or to rules."

@Albright @herag @null0x0

@agoradefense

Thats exactly how law works.. everyone agrees, it enters law, now you have to follow it at gun point... yes its completely legitimate and pretty much the basis for every society on the planet.

@Albright @herag @null0x0

@anonymoose

> No, that's not actually how IP or computers work. The "work" that is copyrighted is not 1s and 0s. I couldn't transcode an audio file into a different format, resulting in a completely different arrangement of 1s and 0s and therby successfully avoid the copyright. Both file formats fall under the copyrighted work, yet changing 1 bit in either which renders the file inaudible, would be perfectly acceptable under IP.

Wrong. The work copyrighted absolutely can be 1's and 0's though usually it is not, and instead copyrighted as text, or an image more abstractly.. however any set of 1's and 0's that represent the copyrighted work is therefore derived from it, and copyrighted as well (and thus yes, the 1's and 0's are copyrighted by extension). Moreover any derivatives such as modifying a single 1 or 0 would be likewise copyrighted.

> And anyway, "derivative work" only exists as a legal concept that is a subset of IP law. Therefore the argument is begging the question as it depends on IP being true for 'derivative works' to be cogent.

IP is "true" its the law. So derivative work as a concept of IP is also "true"

> And no, my arguments aren't nested, the first is an appeal to common sense, the second is the rigorous proof. I would accept a refutation of the rigorous proof as sufficient to dismiss the common sense appeal, but not the other way around.

Sure I can do that.

> We can prove this by simply looking at the economic goods matrix. Thoughts (or specifics orderings of 1s and 0s) are neither excludable nor rivalrous. Therefore as a class they cannot exist as private property.

In your "proof" even your leadin here fails... For starts "thoughts" arent copyrighted. If you happen to somehow know something i am thinking and go implement it you would not be violating any copyright as I can not copyright a thought in my head. I can copyright **expressions**, which may be some image or text that i derive from a thought. But the underlying thought, even then, is not necessarily copyrighted.

Software, for example, can do the same thing as some copyrighted piece of software. so long as it was designed from scratch and not derived directly from the other software its legal, even though it represents the same idea.

> This isn’t some esoteric point of anarco-capitalists philosophy; it is literally econ 101 level analysis.

No it isnt, as we just covered your statement isnt just not part of econ 101, but it is fundamentally incorrect.

Ergo, now that we are into your "proof" it too fails on its axiom statement.

@herag @null0x0 @Albright

@herag

It is not a "fictious construct of the elite classes"... it is very much real, it just isnt physical... non-physical does not make a thing fictitious.

> IP requires the illegitimate use of force to extract wealth for the benefit of someone who has no control over their creative work.

Also not true, not only is the use of force legitimate (as it has entered into law democratically) it also is not used over someone who "has no control over their creative work"... you have all the control over your creative work you want, as long as you arent stealing from others when you do it.

And yes it limits derivative works, as well it should. You are, however, welcome to design and build your idea from scratch. You arent limited in any meaningful way, you just can't steal other peoples hard work to avoid doing your own hard work.

@Albright @null0x0

@anonymoose

> There is no consistent theory of law or property by which a particular arrangement of 1s and 0s on my hard drive is perfect fine, but somehow is ‘theft’ if I flip 1 bit out of hundreds of thousands.

Actually IP law doesnt work like that.. if a particular arrangement of 1's and 0's is illegal, then flipping just one of those is also illegal. The two are significantly similar to be considered derivative work.

Basically if the combinations and 1's and 0's you have can not be reasonably expected to be derived from a copyrighted material, and therefore you came up with it on your own independently (or from free/open sources) then it is legal... simple as that.

> We can prove this by simply looking at the economic goods matrix. Thoughts (or specifics orderings of 1s and 0s) are neither excludable nor rivalrous. Therefore as a class they cannot exist as private property.

Since your axiom above is wrong this and the rest of your statement is by extension wrong as it builds the argument upon your axiom.

@herag @null0x0 @Albright

@lupyuen QBasic is the only embedded language for me ::blows dust off his old parallax chip:: :)

@lucifargundam @zpartacoos @uncapybarable @tek

Ok so the verdict is in. Standard mac and cheese sauce (mild soft cheddar + milk + butter) is amazing on spaghetti. Only thing is due to the increased surface area of the spaghetti you need to up the ratio of milk somewhat to get a bit more liquid sauce. Otherwise it was fantastic.

@cwebber I'm glad to hear that, I do too.

From my perspective it was unexpected, and i suppose that can be mometarily jarring when i saw the first post. But beyond that it didnt really change my perspective of you, other than respecting your honesty. So to me it seems a good thing, nothing **to** hate.

@cwebber Best of luck to you, I hope it hasnt gotten you any hate. Either way I respect the bravery and honesty in what you are trying to do. Rock on.

@herag

Nah I completely support IP law enforced by the threat of gun and legal consequences. I just have no problem with people breaking the law when the conditions under which IP is sold is not reasonable. In this case I support IP but not the use of DRM.

@Albright @null0x0

@Albright

everyone has the right to break the law if they are willing to suffer the consequences.

@null0x0

What properties should the bonding curve of a cryptocurrency or fiat demonstrate?

@lucifargundam

Being softer noodles I doubt I'd like that. mac and cheese needs nice firm noodles.

@zpartacoos

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.