Glad to hear you are out there trying to make a difference, we need as much of that as we can get. Sad that you need to clean up other people's mess at all though.
@adidal I dunno what the fuck you are talking about. I am a god damn fucking paragon of tranquility mother fucker!
(joking of course) :)
ham radio operator's credo:
1. Be a jerk to everyone you meet
2. Make assumptions about how things work based on the first explanation someone gives you and never change your mind or learn anything more about it for the rest of your career in HAM radio.
3. if someone gives you advice contrary to #2 call them names and insult them until they go away
4. Never do math, numbers are a lie. As long as you can hear someone talking in your radio then your assumptions are validated.
5. Under no circumstances should you actually learn how things work. Simply quote people with credentials and insist your misunderstanding of the quoted text is the only correct one. If someone disagrees with you remember your credentials are automatically the same as the authors, so you are right.
6. Make it a point to never understand the purpose or intent of FT8 and anytime you see anyone mention it make fun of them for not being a real HAM
7. CW is the only acceptable mode of operation, everything else is contrary to the spirit of HAM radio.
8. Only people over the age of 90 are allowed to be HAM radio operators, everyone else is ruining the hobby.
9. Making a joke of any kind should be treated exactly the same as a personal insult. You now have the right to respond to the person as rude as you'd like
My guess
@frank87 Would you like the answer early (ill respond via DM if youd like)
@cee I demand 'roo cuddles!
It doesnt take much vaccination for a variant to take hold. Consider the data. India began vaccinating in january of this year. Likewise delta variant began to be detected in very small prevelance in january as well. As the vacination rate of india grew so did the delta variant. By the time vaccination rate reached 20% then the delta variant finally became the dominant variant crossing the 50% threshold. As of today about 50% of india is vaccinated and delta variant is now pretty much the only strain in the wild with high 90's percentage range of prevelance.
So yea vaccination in india directly correlated and strongly correlated with the delta variant spreading.
> It depends on how far those mutations go. The delta variant is still affected by the current vaccine as in that the vaccine is still (largely, partially) effective enough to reduce the chance for the most terrible results.
There is no good data that supports this assertion. Older indirect data that made a weak argument (but the only data we had at the time) would suggest this was true. Newer data that actually has sampled people and examined their viral load, so much more direct data, suggests the vaccine does **not** actually help fight the delta varient at all.
The data is too new to make any solid assertions either way, but as we discussed the earlier suggestion that the vaccine helps with delta is now showing to more likely be completely false.
> Herd immunity is already out of the window, we're not going for that at all. We're using the vaccine to prevent ending up in the hospital in the first place, the very hospital that's now already overflowing. So trying to avoid ending up in the hospital in itself is already a very big thing.
Thats the problem, recent data suggest the vaccine isnt keeping us out of the hospital at all. Delta in and of itself just has less people int he hospital if your vaccinated or not. The people who wind up in the hospital lean towards being unvaccinated most likely due to other factors (for example unvaccinated people are less likely to socially distance as they are more likely to dismiss the virus).
This is why direct evidence is so much more important than indirect evidence. Its easy to assume looking at who winds up in the hospital that the vaccine might be effective, but being indirect evidence there are a host of other explanations for it as well (such as the one I just gave).. but the direct evidence, that suggests the vaccine has no effect at all on Delta.. so that is the stronger evidence.
To give you some perspective the first vaccine caused the virus to shift from its original form to the delta variant. This is approximately 3x to 4x more contagious than the original virus.
The more contagious a virus is the more people need to be vaccinated to reach herd immunity.
Which means if we keep using the same vaccination approach as a "temporary" measure, with continually creating new variants of vaccine to combat each new virus, then you will get ever increasing R0 numbers (how contagious it is).
By the time we have a solution that might work the thing will be so damn contagious that the herd immunity threshold will be too high to reasonably reach and despite the vaccine being effective we will no longer be able to fight the virus anyway.
Its like the antibiotic problem but instead of evolving over the course of decades it evolves over the course of months. I'm not sure you realize just how devestating going the vaccine route will be as long as it only remains a temporary option.
@Pat
There is no doubt resperators will decrease cases if used properly (they often arent but thats another matter). So it would mean less invesment in ventilators and ICU and more managable rates.
That said I dont think respirators are where we should focus anymore. Not because they fail to work but because it isnt reasonable to expect the world to wear respirators for the rest of our lives (or on and off for the res tof our lives).
If it were up to me we would ditch resperators, ditch vaccines, ditch social distancing, just go back to acting like the virus doesnt exist. Divert all of that money into expanding ICU wars and increasing our stock of ventilators. Wear a mask or respirator in nursing homes or around elderly but otherwise just let the virus run its course.
Thats fair. But that mostly just boils down tot he fact that your government cant stop quibbling... Lets not pretend the solution is impossible. Politics just refuses to do what it needs to.
I blame a lot of it on the medical community which is trying so hard to get everyone to conform they sell everything as absolute fact when the truth is we are kinda just making educated guesses of minimal info. The end result is that when new data questions the earlier assumptions they refuse to back peddle.
We are so committed to vaccines being the solution right now that it would be career suicide for a medical worker to actually suggest we let the virus run its course and focus on supportive care. The narrative has been repeated too many times to backpeddle now for fear of loosing public trust.
What im hearing is not that #2 isnt an option there, its that politicians are idiots and didnt execute on #2... big difference.
And yea improving ICU capacity is a huge cost. Expecting other countries to be able to support their own increased capacity AND yours isnt going to work. The netherlands needs to execute on #2 rather than bickering about what to do :)
Mutation rate is a function of a few things, the number of times the virus replicates, the viral load produced when it replicates, and the accuracy of the transcription. The vaccine does **not** cause the mutation rate to increase. What vaccines cause is mutations to be **selected for**, thats where people get confused. When mutations arent selected for then they happen all the time and almost all of them will just die off as quickly as they come into existance. When they are selected for, however, then even if far fewer mutations occur the ones that do occur stand a much higher chance of proliferating once they come into existance. Thats the problem.
@trinsec In my nearly 4 decades of life I have yet to see a single problem solved that didnt involve a nipple.
@trinsec In my nearly 4 decades of life I have yet to see a single problem solved that didnt involve a nipple.
Doing nothing isnt an option, but the choices arent vaccination or nothing.
If it were up to me my focus would be on supportive medicine. Forget about masks, or vaccines, or any of that. Instead invest all that money on 1) researching cures such as transcription inhibitors that may provide a solution where vaccines wont 2) dump tons of money into building new respirators and space in hospitals so we can handle the increased load on the medical system until we find a solution.
@trinsec I'm in shape too, my shape is about the same shape as Columbus thought the shape of the earth was. To quote columbus:
"I found it (the world) was not round . . . but pear shaped, round where it has a nipple, for there it is taller, or as if one had a round ball and, on one side, it should be like a woman's breast, and this nipple part is the highest and closest to Heaven."
Jeffrey Phillips Freeman
Innovator & Entrepreneur in Machine Learning, Evolutionary Computing & Big Data. Avid SCUBA diver, Open-source developer, HAM radio operator, astrophotographer, and anything nerdy.
Born and raised in Philadelphia, PA, USA, currently living in Utrecht, Netherlands, USA, and Thailand. Was also living in Israel, but left.
Pronouns: Sir / Mister
(Above pronouns are not intended to mock, i will respect any persons pronouns and only wish pronouns to show respect be used with me as well. These are called neopronouns, see an example of the word "frog" used as a neopronoun here: http://tinyurl.com/44hhej89 )
A proud member of the Penobscot Native American tribe, as well as a Mayflower passenger descendant. I sometimes post about my genealogical history.
My stance on various issues:
Education: Free to PhD, tax paid
Abortion: Protected, tax paid, limited time-frame
Welfare: Yes, no one should starve
UBI: No, use welfare
Racism: is real
Guns: Shall not be infringed
LGBT+/minorities: Support
Pronouns: Will respect
Trump: Moron, evil
Biden: Senile, racist
Police: ACAB
Drugs: Fully legal, no prescriptions needed
GPG/PGP Fingerprint: 8B23 64CD 2403 6DCB 7531 01D0 052D DA8E 0506 CBCE