Show newer

@Pat

> I remember reading that first study you cited (Jayaweera, et al., 2020 Jun 13), and I've used it in helping to form my understanding. It said, "In general, infected people spread viral particles whenever they talk, breathe, cough, or sneeze."

> Breathe.

Read the data not the commentary. Normal breathing was shown in their study to produce virtually no aerosol. Any commentary about it is moot against the data.

> I don't like to use the words "aerosol" and "droplet" because, as that study said, those terms mean different things to different people. When an infected person breathes they shed virus within sub-micron particles. Period.

False the study clearly shows in its data that normal breathing produces virtually no aeresol (<5um) or droplet (>5um), period!

> That second study (Morawska L, Cao J. 2020 Apr) which studied COVID transmisability and made a claim about viability in particles with little or no H2O, that was studying pre-delta variants.

There is no reason to think that all of a sudden post-delta variants can magically exist outside of a droplet. The only difference of consequence is the density of the virus is much much higher.

> As I said, the newer variants are better at surviving in the air, that's why the R0 is so high, why people who wear cloth masks still get sick and transmit. It's airborne.

The new variants only produce many more viron per droplet, they dont do anything to be more airborne other than through this mechanism. It does of course mean it takes far less exposure to catch the virus, but it doesnt mean the viruses are suddenly existing outside of droplets..

@torresjrjr @NEETzsche @mkljczk @ducheng

@spazzpp2 indeed but it is important to understand how to interprit studies and to identify direct evidence and confounding so you can get a sense of if causality is demonstrated.

The problem with lay people reading studies is they cant really do the work, they can just read the conclusions and have no idea as to how strongly those conclusions represent causality

@spazzpp2 Yes it is, and due to the lack of good or definitive studies all we have to go on is opinion. Thats my point.

@spazzpp2 yea we know COVID kills

The existance of studies doesnt imply the studies support the conclusions your drawing. As I covered wgle studies do exist none of them are valid or complete for the aforementioned reasons.

@atheprogrammer

Churchs in general arent usually all that tec friendly, even newer ones.

@thalweg

@Pat

> Actually sub-micron particles are created in infectious levels with every breath.

Incorrect, studies have shown normal breathing creates virtually no aerosol.

ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/.

> Even when all the H2O has evaporated from a particle, there can remain lipids and the protein shell of the virus itself can help keep it viable.

No viruses dont persist outside of droplets. That would be true airborne status and there is simply no evidence to suggest that is the case as shown by the following study:

"If SARS-CoV-2 could travel in the air, outside liquid droplets, it might be carried longer distances on air currents. There is currently no robust scientific evidence to support airborne transmission of SARS-CoV-2."

Morawska L, Cao J. Airborne transmission of SARS-CoV-2: The world should face the reality. Environment International. 2020 Apr;139:105730. DOI: 10.1016/j.envint.2020.105730.

@torresjrjr @NEETzsche @mkljczk @ducheng

@Pat

sub micron particles are considered aeresol. They arent really produced in any detectable quantity with normal breathing, though they arent non existant. However unless its humid out they are going to evaporate super fast as well.

The point here is that airborne isnt airborne in the same sense as smoke.

@torresjrjr @NEETzsche @mkljczk @ducheng

@Pross988

If you cared about other people you'd duct tape a plastic bag over your head and then put a mask over it

@icedquinn @NEETzsche @mkljczk @ducheng @Pat @torresjrjr

@Pat

To put it in perspective, according to studies normal breathing produces virtually no aerosol and no risk (unlike smoke). Which that alone should give you a good idea why airborne doesnt really mean airborne in the usual sense you think of.

@torresjrjr @NEETzsche @mkljczk @ducheng

@Pat

The maller the droplet size the shorter it can persist since it will dry out faster. larger droplets fall out of the air quicker and also dont persist. Smoke will persist much longer in terms of smell as they are smaller, dont dry out, and most importantly are ionized.

@torresjrjr @NEETzsche @mkljczk @ducheng

@underlap You cant follow anyone from any server? You are using the web interface?

@icedquinn

Agreed. Like i said i wasnt trying to negate your point. Just pointing out some relevant nuance.

@NEETzsche @mkljczk @ducheng @Pat @torresjrjr

@icedquinn

One point of clarity, the co2 levels are acceptable for short term exposure but considered harmful only for long term exposure.

@NEETzsche @mkljczk @ducheng @Pat @torresjrjr

@Pat

Fair.

Though to be clear airborne diseases arent o literally airborne. That is the virus only persists in droplets. So smoke is going to carry way more than the virus would.

@torresjrjr @NEETzsche @mkljczk @ducheng

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.