@pschwede Thats why we dont rely on any one thing.. yea the basics all show us rather clearly that CO2 acts the way. we think. But your right by itself it isnt enough. thats why we. have thousands of different experiments all testing the same theory from a different angle, all confirming it.
Its a bit like the flat earther debate. There are simple experiments anyone can do "basic" list stick a rod int he ground measure some shadows and with some basic math conclude the earth is round. But then you get into weird edge cases with atmospheric refraction and everything else. Yea we **can** make the topic more complex, and we even do. When we do all the conclusions still add up though and we show the basic case is still valid. Even once we account for refraction and everything else, the earth is still round.
Same here. we have basic experiments that are very simple and very clearly show the truth of climate change. Sure we can and will make more complex experiments too, just to test all the weird edge cases on the off chance maybe there is more to it. But all those edge cases also proved the basic case true. So, naturally, we accept that.
@pschwede Well people who study climate study the base fields they need to understand it. You dont need quantum mechanics just some basic chemisty to understand absorbing IR, plus a little geology too and other things.
@pschwede Well yea outside of their field they will, and should trust other scientists. If you want to see if anyone fully understands it you just ask the people who studied it. The opinion of someone who knows quantum mechanics says very little about how well we understand climate.
The fact is we do know, very well, how it all works, your just asking people who never bothered to learn it, so no wonder you hear they dont know.
@pschwede Volcanoes arent exceptions, they are just non human sources of CO2 that raised the temperature just like human sources would, thats all. volcanoes going off raised the temperature too. We just can compare the amount they give off to the volumn humans give off and easily determine that humans give off more. In fact there are whole papers on that.
@pschwede I've spoken to a LOT of people who devoted their life to studying climate change. Every single one of them can completely understand it. Can you actually list some of these scientists? Are they even published in the field of climate change or are you talking about scientists in totally different fields?
@pschwede BTW just to be transparent there ARE actually some points in that chart where you are right, temperature causes the change of CO2 rather than CO2 causes the change in temp. The analysis has shown that. Thing is we know why in that case.
It happened something like this.. At first CO2 rose due to volcanic activity and this caused the temp to rise. But once the temperature reached a specific critical point it caused a release of CO2 from the oceans (after a very long delay as it took time for the oceans to warm up at deep depths). This rise in temperature caused a chemical reaction to occur which caused the oceans to release massive CO2 itself and thus perpetuate the temperature rise even more.
We can prove this due to fossile record, and CO2 levels in the ocean along with measuring the chemicals that reacted to generated the CO2 in the substrate.
So in this one example, which resulted in an extinction level event, you can say that there was temperature causing CO2 rise rather thant he other way around. But as i said this is the exception rather than the rule.
@pschwede well CO2 isnt really showing a delay there just looks that way because they have different zero values. Instead of trying to see if one line is to the left or right of the other pick out actually peaks and look how they line up. The peaks themselves mostly overlap on each other well.
In practice we dont just eye ball it in science. Im suggesting you do it here since i dont want to actually take the time it would take (months/weeks) to teach you statistics. In practice what we do is actually test for the stuff your saying with very specific formula. Those are covered int he full paper I linked.
@pschwede No you dont that makes no sense, thats not how Data science works in any field.
It seems your really grasping at straws to justify a prejudice that has no basis here in reality. Again people rarely agree on this stuff, especially when its political like climate change. The fact that every single person who has invested serious time studying this agrees should tell you something if your not going to do the research yourself.
I mean ive shown you a series of very simple and straight forward experiments that demonstrate quite clearly the reality of climate change. Saying We havent correlated everything in the universe therefore its bad science, is frankly, rather absurd.
Afterall even if we did show something else correlated that wouldnt debunk anything. It would just prove there is more than one thing that is effected by CO2 and temperature.
Afterall the human population will also correlate to CO2, even if it correlates less closely than temperature.The fact that this is true doesnt debunk the assertion that CO2 effects temperature, it jsut means that the human population also effects CO2.
So really no matter how you look at that argument its a very weak one.I really think you should take some time to reflect on how your letting your biases drive your ability to objectively evaluate data, rather than trying to draw conclusions from data.
I dont mean this as an attack, I dont think you are absurd, only that your argument seems to be, which is more a sign of cognitive bias than anything about your abilities. I'm sure if you take the time to study this from a more objective perspective you'd be capable of understanding it.
@pschwede Not nearly as closely no, also historically not at all.
@pschwede While this experiment is NOT the same as i was describing before it does do a good job at showing how we can prove that CO2 is opaque to green house gas but not to air: https://youtu.be/Rt6gLt6G5Kc
@pschwede I mean yea, there are many natural sources of CO2, for sure.
@pschwede let me see if i can find the name. I've seen it but i dont know the name.
@pschwede I mean yea we certainly do exhale a gas that has a small portion of CO2 and the level of that CO2 is relative to how much energy we burn. Sure. But im not sure the point your making here. I mean teh science to confirm all this is really simple, its not particularly complex. Its just a few basical logical steps and a little bit of data and its easy to see. Its the reason we have such a huge amount of consensus on this issue, way more than most issues. PRetty much anyone educated ont he subject who takes a look can quickly see that climate change is legit.
Not saying you cant question it. By all means ask questions and do research. But you have to keep in mind its all been done, we know the answer already. The research should be more for you to answer your own outstanding questions than any real attempt to debunk climate change which at this point islike trying to claim teh earth is flat. We have just too much evidence.
@pschwede Oh the experiment is simple. You either put a hot objects ot an object you shine light on, inside a clear tank filled with a gas, then stick that ina . larger tank under vacuum.
You then observe to see how long it takes the hot object to reach room temperature (or some fixed point). You repeat this with a GH gas int eh chamber then do it again with a non-GH gas. It can be trivially observed that with a GH gas present the object retains its heat significantly longer.
@pschwede Wait how are we talking about breath? You mean because we exhale CO2? Well we dont exhale anywhere near pure CO2 in fact CO2 is only a small percentage of what we exhale.
@pschwede democracies are filling mostly with uneducated people these days. Yea people arent too bright and as such many people are not equipped to understand climate change, let alone how to understand how to feed themselves or anything else.
But jsut because people cant understand the truth due to their own ignorance isnt really an excuse for us to put the truth in question.
@pschwede What is proven in the school is simple, that when you surround a hot object with green house gases, that hot object has a much harder time cooling down due to insulation against radiative loss.
The experiment proves that rather clearly. No one has proposed any counter explanation to what is going on.
It seems like your grasping at straws to hold onto a cognitive bias more than someone who is trying to find the most likely truth. Some light at certain spectrums are reflected sure.. so what? we can still measure how much makes it to earth as well as how quickly the earth gives off heat. All of these measurements are pretty damn good at confirming the effects of GH gas really.
@pschwede yes they have done the due dilligance to calibrate the co2 int he ice with modern day findings. It is covered in the paper in some detail actually. These processes have passed peer review by experts on such things.
@pschwede I mean to the uneducated facts can certainly be ignored denied or forgotten, sure. But scientists actually prove their facts and demonstrate why it is. The truth is we can very easily and clearly test "invisible gases" for these effects. So no trust needed.
Like i said i did the experiments myself when i was younger. They arent particularly hard to do and requires no trust, you can do it yourself.
@pschwede Sure.
Basically the way the greenhouse effect works is that CO2 and other greenhouse gases are opaque to infrared light. they may or may not be opaque to visible light, for simplicity sake lets just talk about visible light and infrared light as they are really where most of the heat energy is from anyway.
so for infrared light (what we call radiative heat) the atmosphere is partially opaque and looks like a partially blackened cloud. As such when IR reaches the earth part of that IR is absorbed by the GH gas and heats up the atmosphere directly. To be specific approximately half of the IR light that reaches earth is absorbed by the earths surface specifically, heating it up. In turn some of that IR is also reflected by the surface, and on its way back out to space goes throught he black atmosphere a second time and even more is absorbed.
this means everything heats up. As we know normally things like planets in space, if they are hot, will slowly cool down. They do this by releasing heat energy as IR, radiative heat.
The surface is constantly giving off IR in an attempt to cool itself. If there were no greenhouse gases the atmosphere would be transparent and the IR would just escape into space, cooling everything. But since the atmopshere is opaque to heat the heat just gets reabsorbed by the atmosphere and cant escape.
Even the heat int eh atmosphere itself cant escape very well. When hot air near the surface of the earth gives off its IR in an attempt to cool itself off it cant because it just gets reabsorbed higher int he atmosphere again.
So while a planet with no GH gas could easily allow its heat to escape through a transparent atmosphere when GH is present the heat can no longer escape.
This effect is even worse on visible light. Since the atmosphere is transparent (mostly) to visible light nearly 100% makes it way through the atmosphere to the earth. It is then absorbed and converted to heat and thus when it escapes the same energy that had an easy time getting to earth as visible light is now IR and cant escape. So things heat up even more.
Jeffrey Phillips Freeman
Innovator & Entrepreneur in Machine Learning, Evolutionary Computing & Big Data. Avid SCUBA diver, Open-source developer, HAM radio operator, astrophotographer, and anything nerdy.
Born and raised in Philadelphia, PA, USA, currently living in Utrecht, Netherlands, USA, and Thailand. Was also living in Israel, but left.
Pronouns: Sir / Mister
(Above pronouns are not intended to mock, i will respect any persons pronouns and only wish pronouns to show respect be used with me as well. These are called neopronouns, see an example of the word "frog" used as a neopronoun here: http://tinyurl.com/44hhej89 )
A proud member of the Penobscot Native American tribe, as well as a Mayflower passenger descendant. I sometimes post about my genealogical history.
My stance on various issues:
Education: Free to PhD, tax paid
Abortion: Protected, tax paid, limited time-frame
Welfare: Yes, no one should starve
UBI: No, use welfare
Racism: is real
Guns: Shall not be infringed
LGBT+/minorities: Support
Pronouns: Will respect
Trump: Moron, evil
Biden: Senile, racist
Police: ACAB
Drugs: Fully legal, no prescriptions needed
GPG/PGP Fingerprint: 8B23 64CD 2403 6DCB 7531 01D0 052D DA8E 0506 CBCE