Show newer

@auramun@anarchism.space No i havent contradicted myself once, you just didnt bother to take the time to actually read what you just quoted, againt he qord **all** was critical in my statement and means something very different than **most**

@auramun@anarchism.space wait are you now claiming that **all** mass shooters are white, not just **most**... I impled that the narrative that **all** mass shooters were white was a lit... It is, in fact a lie.

Notice how your language jsut switched from the word "all" to "most" later in this same post?

Please read things more carefully.

Do you disagree with the fact that "all mass shooters are white" is a falsehood?

@auramun@anarchism.space It doesnt, that was never the point of the post. Thats just what you ASSSUMED was the point and ive just spent the last few hours repeating over and over was not the point and you werent listening.

Race is irrelevant in determing a shooter, that **WAS** the point of the post. The fact that most white people ahve been shooters in the past is the result of them being the majority int he population, not due to them being white. Just as the majority of shooters were all taller than 4 feet, for the exact same reason.

Again we have been agreeing all along, i have been trying to tell you we have been agreeing all along, but youve been too emotional to listen to me once in this long debate and realize that.

@auramun@anarchism.space It doesnt deny most shooters are white, in fact it proves that they are... please again try and listen to people.

@auramun@anarchism.space I didnt get to the part of meaning yet.. we can discuss that next. First you have to agree that my statement is true (or make an educated case why it isnt).. after that we can go onto the next part where we break down if it is relevant or not.

But you seem to be struggling witht he topic (statistics) a lot making it hard to get past the first question.

Perhaps lets try again, now that i explained it do you agree with the following?

If you randomly select a white person and one minority fromt he us population these people both have the same chance of being mass shooters?

@auramun@anarchism.space The whole point i was making with the post was that race has no influence on if someone is a mass shooter or not, which is exactly what you just agreed to.. Again as i said i imagine if you bothered to understand what I was saying youd likely agree with me.

@auramun@anarchism.space I'm saying a lot but based on your answer I see the problem now, you dont understand some fundemental ideas in statistics (its ok a lot of people dont Im not attacking you for it). I explained in my other reply why your answer is not correct.

@auramun@anarchism.space Incorrect, why would the characteristics of a specific individual influence a process of random selection between all individuals. Only way those factors would influence your answer here is if i had fore-knowledge of those factors when making my selection and used them to determine who i selected. But then it would be a randomly selected individual anymore.

@auramun@anarchism.space No again your not listening...

you keep on talking and having put any effort at all into understand what i was saying. I told you there was nuance and technical reasons why you are incorrect. I waited to see if you weregoing to ask what those were or if you'd just keep talking... guess which one you did.

I have given **YOU** the good faith effort of reading everything you posted and remarking on it. however you have not given me the same.

@auramun@anarchism.space its also a fair answer to say you dont understand statistics well enough to know what the answer is... if you feel that is the case. Otherwise again i ask, do they stand equal chance when randomly selected or not

@auramun@anarchism.space You didnt answer my question you just went off on a tangent of your own..

yes or not, are they of about equal chance or not?

@auramun@anarchism.space The irony of all of this is if you actually took the time to understand what I've beensaying i suspect you'd find it largely agrees with your own opinion. its just your hung up on some non-technical definition.

@auramun@anarchism.space

1) I think I've reiterated about 6 times now that I do **not** think that behaviour is significantly influenced by race. You have made this point several times, i have told you it is **not** a point i agree with, yet you continue to claim it is a point I am makin... **again** it is not. Please please please try to listen more to what i am saying and not put words in my mouth (even if it is an innocent mistake)

2) race/populations is very much applied in science all the time, just not in the sense of race that you seem to be defining it as (or as the opinion articles you posted describe it as).. which is where a lot of the confusion comes in (also why we use the word populations instead of race, to avoid that very confusion)

@auramun@anarchism.space I have read the article. Again being non scientific and opinion based it left out a **lot** of technical detail and nuance that would be critical. In fact it is not disagreeing with me but we would have to discuss that nuance and detail for you to understand why.

You said however you didnt want to discuss race further. Which is it?

It sounds like every time i make a point that proves you wrong you want to slam the door shut ont he conversation then when you hear a point that backs up your claim you want to revive it again. How about if you want to revive the race talks we back up to where we left off then...

Or drop it and go back to the original point, up to you.

I appreciate that you are trying to be more respectful. I see your tone. I think your still being driven emotionally to some extent rather than being objective about the topic. Which isnt horrible, but it is making it hard to have productive discourse to some extent.

Not trying to say your emotions are bad, these are important issues and i understand why one might get emotional about it. It just isnt productive to the conversation.

@auramun@anarchism.space Sure lets go back to that if youd like.

let me start with my assertion just so i can see if we are clear. Is the following statement correct or wrong:

If i select one white person at random out of the USA population (based on how they are identified, regardless of if race is real)... and I also select one minority at random from the US population. Do you agree or disagree that the two people you selected have about the same chance of being a mass murderer (with the minority having a marginally higher chance)?

@auramun@anarchism.space I said from our very first message that race has little to no impact on social behavior. Never once did I claim otherwise. You kept insisting i said that and I kept insisting I didnt.

@auramun@anarchism.space Here ya go, took a little digging to find one not behind a paywall so you can view it. This is a peer reviewed paper (linked at the bottom). So you dont have to go digging here is the quote where they specifically express that "populations" are now used in place of the word "race" because race is considered a "loaded term" (basically what i said a euphemism):

Many terms requiring definition for use describe demographic population groups better than the term 'race' because they invite examination of the criteria for classification.

nature.com/articles/ng1455

@auramun@anarchism.space "black" and "white" arent populations/races .. neither is "hispanic" or "muslim" ... none of those are what scientist mean when they say population/race

@auramun@anarchism.space No true, one sec I can easily find you a peer-reviewed source that points out that "populations" are used in place of "race" we as a community have covered it in depth.. one sec ill find a source

@auramun@anarchism.space ancestry means something subtly different. It refers to the colleections of people that donated their genetic material to you. The populations from which those people come from is still relevant however genetically.

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.