Show newer

@billstclair Yes that is true for a lot of what I do as well, I tend to work in higher dimensional spaces often that do not have a physical analog. but in the end, they must still do something useful in reality

@saxnot

I dont agree with that conclusion at all. We know of **tons** of evolutionary features that look damn near identical but evolved along entirely different pathways and thus have entirely different internal structure despite having the exact same end function.

Just because an animal lacks the specific structure a human might use to perceive pain is in no way suggestive they dont perceive pain, particularly considering that they do show a pain response. It just means that the mechanisms they evolved to perceive pain happen to be different than the mechanisms we might use.

@Nikita

@saxnot

You have yet to convince me they are an automation. You linked a study which i have yet to review. I have not checked if that study is cherry picked, or if it even concludes what you suggest it does. I will let you know once I've read it. But as I said right now I cant see how such a claim could be even remotely falsifiable.

@Nikita

@billstclair Yea I'm a research scientist who deals with advanced math day-to-day... I care about what is real, and verifiable.

@saxnot

You'd have to make a solid argument how such a claim could even be falsified before I'd accept those conclusions. I'll check out the link.

@Nikita

@billstclair I love reality, and not getting lost in our own idealized version of it. Sometimes that looks similar.

Sure see ya.

@billstclair AS for me refusing to agree on precise definition. Sorry but neither I nor you get to dictate how language works. As much as both ofus might **like** and want definitions that is simply not reality.

@billstclair Only sort of, I'm a research scientist myself.

Words do **not** always have percise meaning in science, or math (most of what I do is math based and was part of my education).

What we as scienstis do is a two part process. 1) if we are going to use a word we immediately assume our audience will not consider non0technical definitions 2) of the technical definitions currently in use we **explicitly** define which of those definitions we use in the paper we right.

Luckily the more specific the category we discuss the fewer definitions we have. If we are specific enough in our topic there may only be one definition, in which case we dont always need to reiterate which definition we are using.

However to claim in math words have a singular definition with no overlap is pure fiction. Even in math and technical subjects there are often more than one accepted definition in use.

@saxnot

There are a lot of efforts to investigate animals perception, some might even go so far as to make claims as to what an animals internal perception might be. IMO its all unrestable and bunk. We can at best show how animals respond, nothing more.

@Nikita

@saxnot

Insecs show pain response, so any assertion that they cant feel the pain of being crushed is very weak evidence.

Just because they have very different anatomy and the mechanisms for pain may even have some fundemental differences, its still a huge HUGE leap to say they dont feel pain when that is an untestable assertion and when they show pain avoidance response.

@Nikita

@saxnot

Life being shit is part of life. For those of us that strive to be moral people, then doing our best to eliminate said shit should be our constant goal :)

@Nikita

@saxnot

I am not making any claim as to what is measurable or verifiable. Neither science nor myself can even verify if **you** have emotions anything like my own, let alone some other animal.

But at least for me since animals show all the same emotions as humans and with the the same, and sometimes even more, dramatic expression, it seems reasonable to me to assume they are more alike than different.

All the anecdotal evidence points to it being more the same than different, so without a way to test it I'm going to assume you can feel feelings because you act like you do, I will assume the same for most other animals.

@Nikita

@saxnot

The torture doesnt occur in the killing. The torture is from a life of being in confined spaces and having their babies taken from them and similar.

So how they kill them is largely unrelated to the accusation of torture.

@Nikita

@saxnot

While I have little doubt that animals have the same diversity of feelings and rich internal emotional landscape that we do, for the most part, other than that, I agree.

@Nikita

@saxnot

Aww thanks, I've always enjoyed our discussions and debates as well.

@Nikita

@saxnot

The way in which vegans promote veganism leaves a lot to be desired for sure.

But if you kill an animal for food when you had alternatives then I'd argue this is always less moral.

With that said I do agree there is a tipping point. Cows can be raised on land no suitable for plants. Which means maximizing food production ethically is marginally at odds with complete conversion to veganism.

@Nikita

@saxnot

Yea at least if they are raised ethically (and yes that means less of it) then we can eliminate the vast majority of the immorality. The death itself isnt as big a deal to me as a life of suffering.

@Nikita

@saxnot

Well thats the problem, how attached you are to something has little to do with how ethical it may be to kill that something, let alone torture it for its life first.

A murderer may have no attachment or negative feelings about the people they kill. That isnt making the killing anymore ethical however.

@Nikita

@saxnot

In the end the point is there is a huge gap between what we do now and what the most ethical version of food production we might be able to achieve. Ethical means ensuring the animals you eat are relatively enriched and happy during their life time, presuming you are going to eat animals at all. It is obviously more ethical not to eat animals.

@Nikita

@saxnot

I think you miss the issue. It has nothing to do with the fact that pros do the work for you, or even that they can produce more meat.

The issue is that with factory farming the conditions for the animals are often unacceptable by the moral standards of the people who protest it. Specifically confinment in small spaces or lack of mental enrichment.

@Nikita

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.