@iamo
Its up to you. Why would **I** feel its a good idea. Did i give you the impression we were unhappy with something you did?
@jcp Our peertube instance is limited to users who are active members of qoto and/or using our other resources (such as git or discourse) to host open-source projects. It is not intended as a general-use instance for everyone, though exceptions would likely be made if there is at least some sort of a STEM-oriented purpose to the request.
May I ask what sort of content youd like to host so I can make the decision?
No I am saying that your metaphore fails to hold up to its intended purpose, nothing more.
100 women and one man can produce 100 new humans every 9 months.
100 men and 1 woman can produce only 1 new human every 9 months.
Would seem when it comes to making new humans the women are more vital component than the men.
Well i thinkw e are mincing words here. When we talk about privilage in terms of sexism we are talking about "inherent advantages you have due to something you were born with".. we arent really talking about the more colloquial use of the term privilage which tends to mean "someone who has a lot of resources at his disposal".
Women, as we covered, tend to be oppressed in much of the world, they are not generally considered "priilaged". But of course a billionair woman born into riches we might, as a colloquial term say "she is privilaged" even if her sex itself may add to her oppression rather than privilage. So we have to be careful not to mix these terms.
Boris for example is clearly privilaged in the colloqual sense. He is a person who has power, and as such is privilaged. I'd also say that. Similarly we could say Teresa May was privilaged for the same reason, even if her sex may have contributed to some degree of oppression, overall she was privilaged in status and class.
So by extension to take what I said earlier, Boris I am sure has at least some aspects in which he is oppressed. I really dont know him well enough to speculate what those may be. In fact its likely he probably hides them from the public if he has any such qualities (perhaps he has a heart defect for example he doesnt tell people about).
So I'd say even Boris, while overall mostly privileged, likely has some aspects of his makeup, albeit perhaps minor, that also would cause him to have some aspect of oppression on him as well.
Agreed thats why when we started i wasnt particularly happy with the word sexism as i felt we were talking about oppression not sexism, but at this point i agree we are talking specifically about systematic oppression (when talking in the generalized state), which of course is very serious, but it is also somewhat different from just sexism.
But again, semantics so lets not beat a dead horse considering that we pretty much agree and really just use slightly different words to get there :)
I also want to point out one area that was from earlier where they may be some level of real disagreement, im not sure.
But the other thing that is important to note for me is that while, on average and overall being male will give you more privilage than female, even that in isolation is situational.
A male looking to get a raise in a small company owned by a female with sexist tendencies may very well hold the male back explicitly for his sex. In this scenario i think it would be fair to say the male is the victim of sexism and, at least in this scenario, not as privilaged for his sex.
With that said, just as in the other conversation while the individual circumstances might be that way, on average it si more likely to be privilaged in most scenarios more often than you would be oppressed when compared against a woman.
So for me me it all boils down to one important fact i was trying to get at when i started all of this and that is this:
Generalizations are fine, and even useful if we want to fix society. But we must be very cautious of assuming that generalizations hold true against individual people or even specific scenarios.
It is always contextual and if we loose sight of the context we tread very dangerous waters, that was all I was getting at.
Yes I'd say that is mostly it. I would just pick a slightly different wording (though we agree in what we are trying to say).
My wording would be "being male caries with it privilage over being female" which while being slightly different wording I think is in agreement with what you said, yes.
Well some people may be oppressed in ways that are so minor as to not be particularly significant, but even a white straight male may have otehr ways they are oppressed.. If they are significantly overweight for example, that will absolutely cause them to be part of an oppressed group, same for if they happen to be disabled, or autistic, or if they have a history of drug abuse.
There are countless qualities a person may have that falls ont he side of oppression rather than the side of privilege.
I would assert that virtually everyone has at least some qualities that they are oppressed for, even if they may not be as significant as other qualities.
One thing is clear to me, no one is univerally a member of the "privilaged" nor universally a member of "the oppressed", everyone is some mix of each in countless ways.
Fair, but to be clear im not sure if we really disagree on even that point. I think its just semantics (which apparently is important to both of us and we disagree there). But the underlying meaning of the words we are saying are mostly the same, we just disagree on how it should be said.
The point here though is just that, people **are** complex.. yes we can talk about race overall and the privilages it may denote. But when we talk about individuals we have to understand that virtually everyone has privilages and has oppression.
Everyone is oppressed for some aspect of who they are, and almost everyone is privilaged for some aspect of who they are.
Agreed, a black gay man would have privilages in the USA a white straight woman would not have, many of those privilages extending from his sex.
But to carry it to its full completion, the woman in this scenario also has privileges the man doesnt have, those stemming from her whiteness and straightness in this case, so she is also privileged.
Which is the point im getting at. We can talking about characteristics that carry with it privilege, but we cant make generalizations about everyone who has those characteristics being a privileged individual overall.
We cant say "All men are privilaged people" but we can say "being a man carried with it privileges"
@moonshine@freespeechextremist.com
I agree, that is also **exactly** what I'm trying to say, so thank you.. A **person** is not privileged overall (or if he is it isnt the result of any one quality). Individual features can be said, in a generalized way, to carry with it privilege or not. But one can not say that all people who hold said property are therefore privileged (because as you said there is not overall privilege score).
Christmas has officially started int he Netherlands!!!!
Again not sure a black gay man is a privileged person in a patriarchal world, but you could say "him being a man adds to his privilege while his other qualities detracts from his privilege", that I could agree with. But to just say he, as a person, overall, is privileged just for being male, im not sure that is accurate or even a good way to view it.
Sure, I certainly agree that historically speaking blacks got the short end of the stick and women tended to have less power than men, no doubt about that.
I myself opose all discrimination regardless of color, creed, or environment. I find that if i take that stance, and one group happens to be more oppressed than the other, than naturally I will come to their defence more often, since it happens more often, so no need to make the distinction in the first place.
Well in a sense that is what I was trying to say. If we talk in general terms, not about specific people I think its totally valid to say "males are more privilaged than women"
But my point is the second we talk about individuals and make statements that "all males are privilaged people and all females are non-privilaged people" then it becomes false.
Its a fine generalization, but it becomes dangerous the second we start assuming the generalization applies to specific people, just as generalizations tend to do.
Jeffrey Phillips Freeman
Innovator & Entrepreneur in Machine Learning, Evolutionary Computing & Big Data. Avid SCUBA diver, Open-source developer, HAM radio operator, astrophotographer, and anything nerdy.
Born and raised in Philadelphia, PA, USA, currently living in Utrecht, Netherlands, USA, and Thailand. Was also living in Israel, but left.
Pronouns: Sir / Mister
(Above pronouns are not intended to mock, i will respect any persons pronouns and only wish pronouns to show respect be used with me as well. These are called neopronouns, see an example of the word "frog" used as a neopronoun here: http://tinyurl.com/44hhej89 )
A proud member of the Penobscot Native American tribe, as well as a Mayflower passenger descendant. I sometimes post about my genealogical history.
My stance on various issues:
Education: Free to PhD, tax paid
Abortion: Protected, tax paid, limited time-frame
Welfare: Yes, no one should starve
UBI: No, use welfare
Racism: is real
Guns: Shall not be infringed
LGBT+/minorities: Support
Pronouns: Will respect
Trump: Moron, evil
Biden: Senile, racist
Police: ACAB
Drugs: Fully legal, no prescriptions needed
GPG/PGP Fingerprint: 8B23 64CD 2403 6DCB 7531 01D0 052D DA8E 0506 CBCE