Yes im sure...
The frame of reference is the observer not the thing he observers.
By your deformed logic everything is a single frame of reference so long as the observer can saee it, including the other observer.
Thats not how it works and its a reflection of just how grossly uneducated you are.
I will not continue to argue with someone willfully stupid.
Told ya that even after the equation was derived, followed his rules, and disproved him wrong, he would still try to cry fowl and make up more excuses. Dogma only at this point.
Shouldn't be surprising he tries so hard to avoid the experimental evidence all of it disproves him and not a single one supports him. So he pretends they dont exist and just acts like a fool and thinks it will get it somewhere.
@zeccano
What you just said makes no sense. You said it isnt in another frame of reference, but thats bullshit, anything with vleocity different than yourself is in a different frame of reference, as is anything with a different acceleration, or even something in a different physical location.
Some of those frame of referntces are similar some are less similar, but everything has its own frame of reference.
I am done debating with you, you have truly reached insane levels of absurdity and sickness to still assert this nonsense even after i showed you the math playing at your own damn rules.
So which is it, concede, or keep lying to yourself. I satisfied all your demands as you asked and proved you wrong, on your own terms. What you do next defines if you are capable of growing as a person or not...
@CCoinTradingIdeas Nos that I did exactly what @zeccano asked and derived the relatiistic mass for him, using the equations of his choosing, and shows it is non-0... which he claimed to be impossible to do mathematically...
What do you think the chance is he will admit he is wrong and start trying to learn actual relativity (or at least tell people its real!)?
I'll take some bets...
NOTE: for those who cant read the below equations (they aren't rendered) you can follow this link to see: http://mathb.in/38381
Here you go a full derivation from the math equations you started with to the one I provided you several times...
axioms (given by you, agreed by physicist):
\[E = {m}_{rel} \cdot {C}^{2}\]
\[{E}^{2} = {p}^{2} \cdot {C}^{2} + {{m}_{rest}}^{2} \cdot {C}^{4}\]
De Broglie's Equation for the momentum of a photon:
\[p = \frac{h}{\lambda}\]
Formula to convert wavelength \(\lambda\) into a frequency:
\[\lambda = \frac{C}{f}\]
Simplify given axioms:
\[{({m}_{rel} \cdot {C}^{2})}^{2} = {p}^{2} \cdot {C}^{2} + {0}^{2} \cdot {C}^{4}\]
\[{{m}_{rel}}^{2} \cdot {C}^{4} = {p}^{2} \cdot {C}^{2}\]
\[{{m}_{rel}}^{2} = \frac{{p}^{2} \cdot {C}^{2}}{{C}^{4}}\]
\[{{m}_{rel}}^{2} = \frac{{p}^{2}}{{C}^{2}}\]
\[{m}_{rel} = \sqrt{\frac{{p}^{2}}{{C}^{2}}}\]
then use de broglie's equation for the momentum...
\[{m}_{rel} = \sqrt{\frac{{(\frac{h}{\lambda})}^{2}}{{C}^{2}}}\]
\[{m}_{rel} = \sqrt{\frac{\frac{{h}^{2}}{{\lambda}^{2}}}{{C}^{2}}}\]
\[{m}_{rel} = \sqrt{\frac{{h}^{2}}{{C}^{2} \cdot {\lambda}^{2}}}\]
Now convert wavelength to frequency...
\[{m}_{rel} = \sqrt{\frac{{h}^{2}}{{C}^{2} \cdot {(\frac{C}{f})}^{2}}}\]
\[{m}_{rel} = \sqrt{\frac{{h}^{2}}{{C}^{2} \cdot \frac{C^2}{f^2}}}\]
\[{m}_{rel} = \sqrt{\frac{{h}^{2}}{\frac{C^4}{f^2}}}\]
\[{m}_{rel} = \sqrt{{h}^{2} \cdot \frac{f^2}{C^4}}\]
\[{m}_{rel} = \sqrt{\frac{{h}^{2} \cdot f^2}{C^4}}\]
and bam you arrive at the equation for the relativistic mass of a photon.
\[{m}_{rel} = \frac{h \cdot f}{c^2} \]
NOTE: for those who cant read the below equations (they aren't rendered) you can follow this link to see: http://mathb.in/38381
Here you go a full derivation from the math equations you started with to the one I provided you several times...
axioms (given by you, agreed by physicist):
\[E = {m}_{rel} \cdot {C}^{2}\]
\[{E}^{2} = {p}^{2} \cdot {C}^{2} + {{m}_{rest}}^{2} \cdot {C}^{4}\]
De Broglie's Equation for the momentum of a photon:
\[p = \frac{h}{\lambda}\]
Formula to convert wavelength \(\lambda\) into a frequency:
\[\lambda = \frac{C}{f}\]
Simplify given axioms:
\[{({m}_{rel} \cdot {C}^{2})}^{2} = {p}^{2} \cdot {C}^{2} + {0}^{2} \cdot {C}^{4}\]
\[{{m}_{rel}}^{2} \cdot {C}^{4} = {p}^{2} \cdot {C}^{2}\]
\[{{m}_{rel}}^{2} = \frac{{p}^{2} \cdot {C}^{2}}{{C}^{4}}\]
\[{{m}_{rel}}^{2} = \frac{{p}^{2}}{{C}^{2}}\]
\[{m}_{rel} = \sqrt{\frac{{p}^{2}}{{C}^{2}}}\]
then use de broglie's equation for the momentum...
\[{m}_{rel} = \sqrt{\frac{{(\frac{h}{\lambda})}^{2}}{{C}^{2}}}\]
\[{m}_{rel} = \sqrt{\frac{\frac{{h}^{2}}{{\lambda}^{2}}}{{C}^{2}}}\]
\[{m}_{rel} = \sqrt{\frac{{h}^{2}}{{C}^{2} \cdot {\lambda}^{2}}}\]
Now convert wavelength to frequency...
\[{m}_{rel} = \sqrt{\frac{{h}^{2}}{{C}^{2} \cdot {(\frac{C}{f})}^{2}}}\]
\[{m}_{rel} = \sqrt{\frac{{h}^{2}}{{C}^{2} \cdot \frac{C^2}{f^2}}}\]
\[{m}_{rel} = \sqrt{\frac{{h}^{2}}{\frac{C^4}{f^2}}}\]
\[{m}_{rel} = \sqrt{{h}^{2} \cdot \frac{f^2}{C^4}}\]
\[{m}_{rel} = \sqrt{\frac{{h}^{2} \cdot f^2}{C^4}}\]
and bam you arrive at the equation for the relativistic mass of a photon.
\[{m}_{rel} = \frac{h \cdot f}{c^2} \]
@Absinthe Can never be too safe
No one leaves any backdoors opens, it is simply that these ideas are hard to explain to lay people, physicists talk to each other in a more technical language.
The fault you see is because you refuse to learn the language to describe these things
@zeccano Sure thing, thats easy.
@zeccano Why have you still not answered about the equations you provided, you want the derrivation of relativistic mass or not!?
I would e-mail dr. licoln just so he can tell you that you are wrong (He will likely respond to a fellow scientist like myself). If he tells you relativity is real will you believe him.
Also waiting for you to respond to this:
I presume you agree with the two axioms you already stated earlier for our derivation (you provided):
\(E = {m}_{rel} \cdot {C}^{2}\)
and
\({E}^{2} = {p}^{2} \cdot {C}^{2} + {{m}_{rest}}^{2} \cdot {C}^{4}\)
Correct, if so I will be happy to use these as our axioms for the derivation.
@Sphinx there arent too many things that end in the word pie that arent good.
Ok I now have some time to help you understand the real positive value of relativistic mass.
Which equation would you like me to derrive from? I believe you had a math question, it got lost in the thread, what was it?
Not exactly what he said, only that it is a way of thinking about it that doesnt lead to good intuition. It is real and positive mathematically and works if you know how to use it. But it is not real mass it is perceived mass (it acts as if it has tat mass when in motion).
This is pretty much all that he was saying.
By the way you asked for the equation for relativistic mass that gives a real positive value, I already provided this equation to you:
@zeccano
I just watched it, he never said relativistic mass was 0 in that video,
Jeffrey Phillips Freeman
Innovator & Entrepreneur in Machine Learning, Evolutionary Computing & Big Data. Avid SCUBA diver, Open-source developer, HAM radio operator, astrophotographer, and anything nerdy.
Born and raised in Philadelphia, PA, USA, currently living in Utrecht, Netherlands, USA, and Thailand. Was also living in Israel, but left.
Pronouns: Sir / Mister
(Above pronouns are not intended to mock, i will respect any persons pronouns and only wish pronouns to show respect be used with me as well. These are called neopronouns, see an example of the word "frog" used as a neopronoun here: http://tinyurl.com/44hhej89 )
A proud member of the Penobscot Native American tribe, as well as a Mayflower passenger descendant. I sometimes post about my genealogical history.
My stance on various issues:
Education: Free to PhD, tax paid
Abortion: Protected, tax paid, limited time-frame
Welfare: Yes, no one should starve
UBI: No, use welfare
Racism: is real
Guns: Shall not be infringed
LGBT+/minorities: Support
Pronouns: Will respect
Trump: Moron, evil
Biden: Senile, racist
Police: ACAB
Drugs: Fully legal, no prescriptions needed
GPG/PGP Fingerprint: 8B23 64CD 2403 6DCB 7531 01D0 052D DA8E 0506 CBCE