Show newer

@snow When people have a blank domain name they almost always have a blank avatar too. Thats the whole point, they do it intentionally because its cool to be anonymous. Its a popular trend.

@namark

I never said GPL doesnt do what it intends to do. It intends to be viral and force others adopt their ideology. Thats also why its failing and people stopped using it.

So yea maybe you see it as a good thing because you see money as evil. Thats fine, but the GPL is dying and good riddance to it.

@kick @mewmew @StaticallyTypedRice@mastodon.social

@snow The color of the ticker tells you the server the person is on but not the identity of the person itself.

Two people on the same server both with blank display names (very common) would be indistinguishable from each other.

@snow How would you be able to identify someone with a blank display name?

@snow Yea but now users with generic display names (as many people like to do) cant be identified at a glance. Granted its an edge case but thats the reason I didnt implement it this way.

@namark

I explained several times. It prevents you from including in free and open-source projects with incompatible licenses (virality).

We covered this with the XFree example where they had to bar all GPL code from their distribution because its viral nature made it legally impossible to incude the software in the same package as other permissive licenses.

@kick @mewmew @StaticallyTypedRice@mastodon.social

@snow This should really be a server side edit so we can just parse the part after the second @ and leave the user name

@georgia

The analogy fails because public property, unlike software, can not be infinitely replicated.

If i sell public property you are deprived of your original property.

If i take free software, add non-free components and sell my non-free components then I have not taken anything from the people, they still have their free software and are still free to use it.

Someone making money doesnt mean someone else somewhere must be deprived of wealth. Money/wealth is not a zero sum game.

@kick @mewmew @StaticallyTypedRice@mastodon.social @namark

@georgia

software which ontains unfree and free code is still unfree. Nothing wrong with unfree sofware existing. It does not however make the free software I released any less free. It just doesnt infringe on other peoples freedom to make money either.

@kick @mewmew @StaticallyTypedRice@mastodon.social @namark

@namark

I do not see GPL as giving me freedom quite the opposite given its crippling, locked-in viral nature.

@kick @mewmew @StaticallyTypedRice@mastodon.social

@georgia

permissive licenses arent unfree, so moot point. If someone takes your code and changes it they can not preent your original code from being free. The only portion that is "unfree" is the part they themselves wrote and contributed. So they are not making the free part unfree, they are simply adding an unfree part on top of a free part. So yes, that is freedom, freedom to do exactly that.

@kick @mewmew @StaticallyTypedRice@mastodon.social @namark

@r

I'm aware of his personal opinions. Good share. Doesnt change the fact that the viral nature of the GPL caused huge issues and the need for a policy to reject it.

By his own logic what would have also been better for the project is if people didnt use a viral license to make those contributions he had to reject in the first place. So even then the issue was the GPL license and had they used a different non-viral license it would have been a non-issue.

@kick @mewmew @georgia @StaticallyTypedRice@mastodon.social @namark

@georgia

Nope my metric for good is maximum freedom, of which GPL violates that, yes I know you disagree, no repeating yourself again in another way wont change my mind.

@kick @mewmew @StaticallyTypedRice@mastodon.social @namark

@namark

Seeking money doesnt make you bad and it is no garuntee you are anti-freedom. If someone takes my open source product and adds something of value on top of it and wants to sell the product they created, let them. I'm not so bitter that I am going to wrongfully mistake that as a bad thing.

@kick @mewmew @StaticallyTypedRice@mastodon.social

@kick But I'm out, once the personal attacks start I know there is no good reason for me to stick around. Please don't continue to tag me, thanks.

@kick No I'm an actual Open-source contributor who was involved with it and many similar issues with software throughout the years.

There are really good writeups explaining exactly what I just said, I suggest you read up on the history a bit before you dig yourself in too deep.

@georgia

Yes your just repeating yourself now. I have no doubt you think it is a good thing, I also have no doubt that it isnt a good thing.

@kick @mewmew @StaticallyTypedRice@mastodon.social @namark

@kick XFree used to be a mix of GPL components and BSD like components, the virality of the GPL became an issue, at one point they tried to modify the BSD components to make them compatible with the GPL however there were still concerns about the compatibility and now the XOrg foundation policy is to completely reject GPL components from its distribution and ensure none of the code they distribute contains GPL components anymore. You can no longer contribute your own code to the distribution releases if it contains GPL licensing structure.

@kick

Yes your correct it was from XFree, my mistake. And no its not a lie what you just said is 100% what I said

"because xfree86 was incompatible with the GPLv2,"

Yea because of its VIRAL nature it wasnt compatible with permissive licenses.

Yes the XOrg foundation after that made a strict policy that all their software must use permissive licenses and copyleft (like the GPL) licenses would no longer be permitted. Now XOrg is no longer GPL in any of its core tools.

@mewmew @StaticallyTypedRice@mastodon.social @namark

@georgia

You can call it whatever you want, feature, bug.. The point is it prevents free and open source from functioning well. It has the same failing as communism, there must be 100% compliance and use of the license or else the license does more harm than good.

Not something I have any interest in arguming. I'm more than happy to see it is being abandoned as as a license as it should be and the open-source community can get back to being productive and not infected by viral licenses for much longer.

@kick @mewmew @StaticallyTypedRice@mastodon.social @namark

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.