@david Only time ive seen this happen is if an instance is suspended or unreachable at the time the DM is sent. I usually get all my DMs anyway
@timorl If someone is being efficient at protesting, but are just as devoted to it, then the amount of sacrfice (including investment of time/hard work) they put in wont be any less. It is just that they will get more results for the same input of effort.
If someone protests outside for 5 hours and reaches twice the number of people that is an increase in efficiency. However if you can reach twice as many people and therefore choose to put in half the effort, then clearly the cause isnt as important to you as it is to someone who would have worked twice as long at the same efficiency.
@timorl I wouldnt say we should demand it of them, I agree.
But how much sacrafice a person makes should be used as an indication as to how serious they think the problem really is.
Talk is cheap, action isnt.
I dunno, there is no doubt greta has a lot of attention. But I dont really know of anyone paying attention to her who wasnt already a Climate Change Activist. Everyone I know of who was on the fence is still on the fence.
It seems to me her effect has largely been harmful, it just appears otherwise because ther eis a large group of activists who are raising her up. But yea literally anyone I personally know who was swayed one way or the other by her explicitly was mostly turned offby her approach and didnt support it.
Just look at this thread for an indication. I've had several people reboost my posts in this thread so far, and the others who have spoken up seem to be, for the most part, in agreement with me.
Whenever I bring this up I tend to get the same reaction, a bunch of people saying the same, that they were driven off by the anti-education message from Greta.
There is a **lot** of dislike for greta out there, there is damn good reason for it. But of course her supporters will pain it off like its just a bunch of conservatives or something, when it isnt. She is driving off a **lot** of people who were otherwise supportive of the climate change agenda.
I wouldnt say her message is anti-education so much as her actions have an anti-education effect.
@timorl You'd have to watch her videos from that. But she pretty explicitly uses the phrasing "every friday" quite often when refering to the strike.
Every friday a bunch of kids following her instructions and walking out of school, hanging out with some friends on the steps for a few minutes, then going home is going to have a hard time getting my respect. There is nothing on any level redeemable about that.
They are different, and those difference should be considered. but it isnt irrelevant. No one is looking at these kids going "oh wow, look how important it is to them we should change"... well no one except the people who already supported climte change activism for a while now.
the fact remains no one is going to take any protest action seriously (accept those already supporting the cause) if the whole basis is a movement to avoid self improvement, hard work, and education. "I am going to stop learning things until people do what I say" is about the worse way to protest imaginable. It makes you look uneducated, it means you encourage behavior that hurts the cause (lack of education is what got us into this mess) and overall indicates you are doing it for selfish reasons rather than to enact change itself.
Literally everything about the way the protest is designed is a failure. If I am any indication it certainly isnt helping either, I've withdrawn a **lot** of money I used to donate to this cause as a result and am no longer very active for similar reasons.
@timorl I'm aware of the other points... making a short video once and "talking to people", are not what I would consider all that much work. Sounds like your really stretching it.
Its not that striking on paid vacation is a "problem" its just that it isnt a strike and wont enact change.
No thats not what I said at all. I said there must be some sacrafice for it to be a "strike" not for it to be a protest, those are different words. What they are doing is not a strike, but it is a protest, jsut a very poorly designed one that makes those protesting look bad and is counter productive to the cause.
@timorl The official site for the strike has a google doc on their site with detailed instructions on how to strike. It basically says on the day of the strike you walk out of school, then "do what you feel is right" they list some examples of what that might be, one such example is a "quick" chat/rally on the school steps before going home for the day, which is the optiont he vast majority of students take, they walk out of school, hang out for a few minuteson the school steps, then go home
If kids were actually getting arrested for this, or facing repercussions such as not getting into college I might agree with you.
However the response has been almost entierly to just let them. Many colleges have already told them anything related to this protest on their record wont effect them getting into college and I have not heard of any significant reports of truancy officers acting on this in any way.
If this were an actual thing and there was some concern fromin from the kids Id be likely to agree on this point.
Exactly. If Greta's message was to go to school at 6am and instead of being inside in a warm class room they were actually standing outside in the cold and rain every friday with signs then I would be a lot less critical.
@timorl I can think of a **lot** of things young adults could be doing that is both more effective and would represent an actual strike.
The most obvious and straight forward would be if they spent those fridays standing outside the school holding signs all day rain or snow cold or dry.. but aside from a few exceptions on a few days that isnt the form it is taking.
Second adults could do the same things as kids, they could jsut not go to work on fridays to strike and not bother standing outside with signs.. They dont because it wont enact change as readily as being visible and outside to protest. It is no different for kids, the fact that they are taking fridays off and not actually making any sacrafices themselves only shows they are not committed to the change, if they were they wouldn't be taking the lazy way out so often.
There are also countless other ways I could think of they could be striking that might be worthy of some respect... for example every friday they could refuse to use any fossile fuels, no electricity, refuse to get in any cars to go anywhere. Walk to school, take their bike to school that day, dont charge or use their phone, or their computer on that day. funny none of that is part of the "protest" either, most kids I've seen just sit at home in an airconditioned house.
Another form could be if instead of protesting during school they did it on the weekend. A hunger strike every friday to monday is going to turn some heads real fast.
There are literally countless ways that i can think of infinitely more effective (and effective) at protesting then to choose not to educate yourself everyday. That isnt putting any pressure on adults, its not taking anything away from anyone that would exert pressure. Its literally nothing more than being lazy and skipping out ont he responsibilities you already want to skip out on.
@timorl No I wouldnt, but I also dont see those two as comparable.
With work the person striking has a need for that job, they are making a sacrifice (giving up pay) in order to enact change.
Kids playing hookie, however, are doing exactly what they want to do. Most kids dont want to be in school and would be more than happy to find a reason to get a day off.
Thats like calling it a strike if you take the day off work to go get ice cream and binge watch netflix. It isnt a strike if you are doing what you find enjoyable and make no sacrifices.
Moreover the thing you strike from is also the entity you wish to change. The strike intending to exert pressure on the institution you withhold your services from. So striking from school simply makes no sense in that regard either.
Fair intelligence can be a curse as much as it can be a gift.. but they are kids so refering to it as a gift is likely a bit more positive and encourage for them then to explain the more nuanced nature of their abilities and what it may mean for them.
@kravietz Yea I keep wanting a third-party choice since the Dems seem unlikely to produce a candidate I can vote for. I'd rather not vote for Trump if i can find anyone half decent. Sadly so far I can not.
@kravietz The issue isnt tht **she** skips school, thats not at all part of the issue. The fact that she has a voice that people listen to and is telling millions of other girls and boys to skip school though is a VERY different thing, and unexcusable.
There is also a huge difference between occasionally skipping school and doing so every single friday.
Jeffrey Phillips Freeman
Innovator & Entrepreneur in Machine Learning, Evolutionary Computing & Big Data. Avid SCUBA diver, Open-source developer, HAM radio operator, astrophotographer, and anything nerdy.
Born and raised in Philadelphia, PA, USA, currently living in Utrecht, Netherlands, USA, and Thailand. Was also living in Israel, but left.
Pronouns: Sir / Mister
(Above pronouns are not intended to mock, i will respect any persons pronouns and only wish pronouns to show respect be used with me as well. These are called neopronouns, see an example of the word "frog" used as a neopronoun here: http://tinyurl.com/44hhej89 )
A proud member of the Penobscot Native American tribe, as well as a Mayflower passenger descendant. I sometimes post about my genealogical history.
My stance on various issues:
Education: Free to PhD, tax paid
Abortion: Protected, tax paid, limited time-frame
Welfare: Yes, no one should starve
UBI: No, use welfare
Racism: is real
Guns: Shall not be infringed
LGBT+/minorities: Support
Pronouns: Will respect
Trump: Moron, evil
Biden: Senile, racist
Police: ACAB
Drugs: Fully legal, no prescriptions needed
GPG/PGP Fingerprint: 8B23 64CD 2403 6DCB 7531 01D0 052D DA8E 0506 CBCE