Show newer

@khird

I agree, but since the offending user is using ban evasion they are no longer able to... see our section on federation policy.

The offending user has now used at least 7 different accounts on different servers to avoids band included the three mentioned, all of which refused to address the problematic account.

@design_RG @mngrif @arteteco

@leyonhjelm

No its not that at all. Its far more basic than that. Just look at his vocabulary for example or his sentence structure. Its clearly some sort of developmental disorder or something. At least with regards to his ability to speak if nothing else.

@AtlasFreeman

@leyonhjelm

If you say so. I think his lack of intelligence is rather obvious. But hey, to each their own.

@AtlasFreeman

@stevenroose

Some cmparisons make sense, some dont...

H1N1 caused half a million deaths world wide, it was a big deal. Maybe you heard it by one of its other names like Swine Flu or Bird Flu?

It killed way way more people than COVID-19. In fact its the whole reason they wound up developing flu vaccines.

@sda

@stevenroose

Well my OP was to point out that I thought trumps coronavirus response was pretty good. He did far far more than past leaders have done with past infections (comparing to obama's handling of H1N1 for example).

By comparing numbers its to show that very point, that we can talk about ur opinions either way, but even the numbers seem to suggest america isnt doing a horrible job.

@sda

@stevenroose

Good advise. Obviously over time we try to normalize these numbers for exactly that reason.

But it isnt completely useless. Especially when we see huge gaps, the bigger the gap the more telling it is, even then it is still suggestive and not proof of anything. But not useless.

@sda

@stevenroose

By the way, side note.. I am working on exactly that.. Why do you think i have the data sets here that I was able to quote from.

I had introduced a logistic function some years ago that models spread of a disease.. takes R0 as an input and the herd immunity as the carry capicity and lets you inject members representing people arriving via plane into the population..

I'm using that and comparing it to the numbers we see now to verity the model.

But I'm also drawing my own personal conclusions from that and other things Trump has said or done that ultimately is shapping my opinion of Trump

@sda

@stevenroose

I'm making an educated evaluation of the figures and the situation. My qualifications allow me to analyze the data and understand the risks of that.

I do agree sharing peer reviewed work is ideal. Sadly there is very little of that at the moment so the best we can do is try to take the data and make some preliminary judgements on it.

If the argument is just that we dont have good data yet, I agree, I am not claiming we do. But if we are going to judge the USA response, which you seemed just as quick to do relying on extremely bias and unscientific media, then its a good a place to start as any.

The simple fact is, Trump, despite his usual incompetence with so many things, has done an excellent job in terms of the decisions he has made. All the numbers lean us towards agreeing with that so far.. If those numbers change against him as time develops so might my opinion.

@sda

@stevenroose

Well consider it is my profession with decades of expiernce, and much of which worked with diseases... no I cant.. why should I?

@sda

@stevenroose

I am leaving the metrics to the staticians.. I am a professional data science with a good deal of expeirnce working with infectious diseases both for the Dod, FEMA, and McKesson...

So yes I agree, lets leave it to people like me with actual qualifications :)

@sda

@stevenroose

Again we have yet another fallback metric, number of people being treated.. yet again america is way ahead of the game on numbers there. the number of people we have in hospitals is much lower than other countries...

As I said none of these numbers by themselves mean much. But the fact that the USA is many orders of magnitude ahead on literally every metric combined with all the other factors does paint a compelling picture.

@sda

@stevenroose

In the end the fact is no matter what standard metric we use to evaluate how bad it is in the USA compared to europe they all show the same thing.. that USA is well ahead of the game.

No surprise europe is crying about how bad Trump is.. they have to blame someone for their own screwup I guess and who better than Trump.

@sda

@stevenroose

yup in which case we would have to fall back to looking at other numbers, such as number of patients actually being treated for it in a hospital (we call those suspected cases) .. we dont look at any one metric. In this case ssuspected cases int eh usa is much lower.

When looking at suspected cases you DO however use per capita, for the reasons you mentioned earlier. the per capita suspect cases int he USA is extremely low compared to other countries as well.

Again demonstrating the excellent handling of the situation so far in america.

Though my main concern is that the administration can only reall y have a strong ifluence at stopping it at the borders. Once int he wild it mostly relies on how strongly the citizenry obeys the social distancing. I dont have high hopes on americans in that regard.

@sda

@stevenroose

Let me try to break it down.. You would be right if the goal was to try to test the whole of the USA. Then of course if that is the metric then you absolutely would look at tests per capita..

However that is not the goal of any country, obviously, and thus not the measure of interest.

What was being discussed is "does the USA have a lower incident rate than other countries" in other words, are we ahead of the curve at slowing down the spread.

For that we would look at numbers infected, or to get an incident rate the percentage of people infected out of the number of people tested.. which for the USA is very very low.

This indicates that compared to europe that the total infection is rather low

@sda

@sda That sounded sarcastic, glad to hear it isnt. But I still dont think you have the proper information to decide either way based on our earlier statements.

I'm fine dropping the convo though.

@stevenroose

It might make sense to look at tests relative to the population in a different context. not in the context we were discussing.

No you are completely wrong. If we are trying to show a populace has a lower infection rate we care about incidence rate, so the ratio of infected vs tests issues, population doesnt factor into these calculations.

I'm not making this up as I go this is standard data science in a epidemic situation. Its the ratio of tested to infected that matters if we are talking about what country has a greater infection rate.

@sda

@sda yes.. because we had discussed a side point, specifically why the USA had so few cases and if the usa was testing effectively, we were addressing that side point.

You tried to debunk my point with a counter point, which i then debunked...

Not sure why we are having this meta discussion you were there, did you really have that much trouble following along. Seems straight forward to me why it was stated.

@sda

Well considering the netherlands is barely testing at all I wish we had walk up or drive through tests here honestly.

@stevenroose

@stevenroose yup, the world has went completely off their rocker insane when it comes to propaganda these days. Especially when its so trivial to debunk it.

@stevenroose

It makes no sense to calculate it per capita for a few reasons..

1) the intent isnt to test everyone in the nation, that is impractical. The point is to test people suspected of being sick. So per capita makes no sense

2) the context is very important here. This was brought up specifically because sda claimed that the only reason the USA shows significantly fewer cases than other countries is due to the fact that the USA is testing less. Yet we are testing 20x more than the netherlands and many times more than most countries and yet still show much much lower numbers. Which directly contradicts the assertion.

Context is everything when it comes to statistics.

@sda

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.