Show newer

@obi

The issue is jsut that "he is not a scientist" was never meant to say "you should only listen to scientists"... it was intended, as newark said, to mean "He isnt making precise statement here, it is rhetoric" Where I emphaized saying the infection is "more prevelant than we thought" doesnt mean much in any specific sense because they arent actually comparing it to specific figure .. more prevelant than who thought, higher than what figure?

the point is, what was being said had no value due to its lack of precision. Mentioned a scientist didnt say it wasnt an appeal to authority but rather pointing out that non-scientists are often so impercise with their words as to useless, as was the case here

@namark @realcaseyrollins

@Shamar let me know if it crops up again.. first I heard of it this happening.

@Shamar is it possible you set some sort of filter on the homefeed without realizing it?

@david You would need to be a bit more specific on what topic of course you want to do.. if its going to be math/science stuff I can recommend the MITx stuff.

@namark

Very well said. I wasnt saying the statement itself was wrong, only that it is too vague to evaluate from a scientific perspective. Scientists are precise in their wording with good reason though as you point out.

Thanks for clarifying my stance, I agree.

@obi @realcaseyrollins

@realcaseyrollins

Those arent words spoken by a scientist.. your welcome to beleive it or not, but do **not** try to claim this is something the study or scientists said. It is a layperson's interpritation of it, and not really a technical statement.

notice the words "preliminary" and "suggests" as well, also notice they dont even say who "previously thought" it.. are they talking about popular opinion? Its not a very technical statement but if they are just saying that a bunch of americans sitting home drinking beer thought the virus wasnt as wide spread as it is and this study is evidence they are wrong.. well sure thats fine.. but its not really a surprise to scientists who havent really made much of an assertion either way how wide spread it is, most admit we dont have the data to say that yet.

@obi

@realcaseyrollins

The study does not say that, only the news which reported on it did.. so no "scientists" are saying that, its not even a scientific statement (how do they measure the percentage people "thought" had it, and are you talking about people who had coronavirus or people who had COVID-19)...

I think what your really trying to say, but lack the scientific verbage to express it is... coronavirus doesnt always manifest as COVID-19, it has a high incidence of asymptomatic carriers... which is entiery true (and what a lot of scientists would agree with including the ones who did that study). but you have to understand in technical language your saying something very different than "COVID-19 isnt very deadly".. both because coronavirus doesnt always cause COVID-19 because it means something slightly different, and also because of reinfections.

Also its a lot easier to know that asymptomatic carriers are high than it is to actually claim 5% of the population had the virus... so your kinda getting yourself stuck in the weeds in multiple ways here.

@obi

@realcaseyrollins

Everything aside there is another thing important to note..

The percentage of people who die from this strain of Coronavirus is a very different thing than the percentage of people who die from COVID-19. This is especially important when we realize reinfection is a very real possibility right now.

@obi

@realcaseyrollins

The study **does** mean what it says, it just doesnt mean what **you** say it means.. the fault isnt in the study or its claims, its in your interpretation of it.

@obi

@realcaseyrollins

Depends.. it has long been the case that laypeople reading studies, or even news media outlets reporting on them, have done more harm than good. Its pretty common for the media and laypeople to draw incorrect conclusions that professionals might know better not to do.

The study **is** valuable, it just doesnt draw any conclusions on its own and will simply be part of a bigger puzzle as time goes on. But the lay person is likely to draw premature conclusions from it anyway.

Among scientists its a huge gripe about how people and the news tend to report on studies. Its almost always wrong.

@obi

@realcaseyrollins

False positives happen for numerous reasons. technical inaccuracies of a test (such as detecting antibodies from another source or similar) can be one, but it can also include things as simple as human error, cross contamination, and countless other reasons.

The reason it is called the false positive paradox is exactly because of the reaction you are exhibiting now.. it is counter intuitive to what your instinct tells you when interpreting such a test.

I usually find when dealing with counter intuitive logic it can be helpful to think about it in the most extream case to help you see why it is the way it is... imagine some imaginary disease that is very rare, no one knows how rare it is though (just as we have no clue with coronavirus how common it really is).. so we develop some test to test for the disease so we can figure out how common it is.

Now lets say, for simplicity, we know due to human error or whatever other error inherent int he testing process that 1% of the time the test will say someone has the disease when they really do not (false positive). Lets also assume that in reality (though unknown to the scientists) only one person in the entire world actually has the disease, or for simplicity sake, no one does.

So armed with our 99% certain test we test the entire population of the world in an effort to determine how wide spread the disease is. What result would we get?

Well according to our 99% reliable rest 78 million people in the world have the disease (we tested 7.8 billion and 1% of them got a false positive).. Since we dont know the actual number of people in the world who had the disease, or even the the false positive rate of the test going in, we will happily conclude the disease has reached 78 million people even though in reality the disease is non-existant.

In other words.. the test is only actually helpful to us if we know the incident rate in the population and the false-positive rate of the test.. without these additional data points the test doesnt tell us anything of value.

@obi

@realcaseyrollins

The link i provided explained why the False Positive Paradox means that we cant draw conclusions from the test results without other types of data needed to calculate the true-positive rate.

We would need to first know the actual incidence of the virus in the population along with the false-positive rate of the test, with those two pieces of data then we can conclude meaningful results from the test.

Basically your working backwards, your trying to use a test to determine incident rate when you need to know the incident rate first in order to interprit the results of the test. which is exactly why we need other types of data which we dont have before this particular data comes useful.

@obi

@realcaseyrollins

Well that wasnt really the conclusion in the first place.. thought by whom?

All the experts up until then and still now at the moment would say the same thing.. we dont know the number infected very well.

@obi

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.