Show newer

@p

The delete and redraft isnt for your sake.

You can usually assume such changes are minor, if you already read it, you can assume you dont need to read it (when I redraft). If I add new information, rather than corrections to wording, it would have been as a seperate post.

@realcaseyrollins

@p

Its tiring that I need to spend most of my time in any discussion with you correcting invalid assumption you make about what is said...

for starters

> I don't know, I see you jumping in with stuff that wasn't under discussion.

Yes, that's how conversation works, people bring new ideas into a conversation that are either discussed or passed up

> That was not a law and it was not a standard created by a company for its own use

I specifically said "I'm talking about laws or practices". Standards set across an entire industry and enforced nearly universally among that industry is relevant.

If you want actual laws there are countless number of those as well, the sedition act of 1918 forbade certain language that was "disloyal, profane, scurrilous, or abusive language", it was repealed in 1920

> I don't know why you're focusing on arguing that I'm dumb

I never once said you were dumb.

Again please stop putting words in other peoples mouth and then arguing against something that was never said, it is tiring

> rather than trying to make your case

I made my case in the first post. My case was that we should stop trying to sell the narrative that censorship only goes one way and instead focus on trying to understand the cases where censorship was recinded so we can better apply that to the cases we have to deal with today.

My point was that the absolutist thinking that you are promoting when talking about this subject is ultimately harmful to the purpose of decreasing censorship, as absolutist one-sided thinking tends to be, and we must look past it if we are to have a positive impact on our mutual goal of reducing censorship.

@realcaseyrollins

@p

This all seems rather clueless of what was said and just based on your own assumptions...

> Unintentional censorship was not being discussed.

You're right it wasnt, I didnt mention anything about the censorship being unintentional. I'm talking about laws or practices that were very intentionally designed to create censorship that were later revoked.

Hays code would be a prime example of this. It was intentionally designed as a tool of censorship, later revoked. There are countless other examples.

You also seem to assume that I am somehow ok with censorship laws on the notion that we can repeal them later, again a faulty assumption. I'm all for someone opposing a censorship law before it gets passed, obviously this is more efficient than trying to correct it after the fact. but such absolutist thinking, as you tend to engage in, isnt particularly helpful in a world where we are already battling with censorship in many countries. Having insight into how and why past censorship has been abolished is crucial to fixing things. However if we were to take what you said at face value then it would be hopeless, despite history being against you in that regard (in many ways the USA is less censored today than it was in the past).

@realcaseyrollins

@p

You seemed to entirely miss the point. I made no claims as to how often it happens. though I did point out your claim of it "never" happening is obviously false, but that isnt the point.

The point is we have countless examples of laws that were used to censor and later repealed explicitly because of their abuse as a tool to censor. We should not take the absolutist view that it never happens because in doing so people become less educated on when it does happen and how we can learn from it to ensure it happens again.

Your last statement is of course a somewhat useful modification to your earlier assertion though. You added to the "things never get less restrictive" with a new clause "unless the people pushing for restrictions go away".. while I'd say that is common sense, the law will follow what the people want the law to be, it does hint at a very high level how and why we might otherwise fight to reverse censorship. It mostly boils down to changing the minds of some group of people. Not always the ones pushing for it though, but still, it boils down to censorship will always reflect the level of censorship people push for. so we reverse it by changing the minds of the people (and have at times in the past).

But to me most of that response is just not saying anything useful, we have to look at how and why those minds were changed WRT past laws if we want to have a similar effect.

@realcaseyrollins

@p

While I rarely ever support censorship it is good to note censorship has historically "went the other way" as well. We have numerous examples of laws that create censorship being later repealed and the censorship disapears.

There is something to learn from these incidents so we can strive towards less censorship in the future.

@realcaseyrollins

@vnarek I dont need to customize my formatting tool as readily as I might a linter. But even then being able to customize it would be important to me. A prime example is how it handles long lines that need to be wrapped. I usually like to set a higher limit to trigger word wrapping than what tends to be default. Often I may do no wrapping at all and leave it to the dev to wrap it manually.

@vnarek As long as those opinions are in line with the standard practices of the language and can be customized, then yes, i prefer my linting and formatting tools to be opinionated

@freemo @admin you're sounding like Bacon's (translated) novum organum (lesswrong.com/posts/te8gXf9fXb). I think I found it in a toot somewhere around here

@admin I agree few people would, thats the point, they should, they could, they wont.

I do agree that most people would dismiss it out of hand but that again goes back to what I said before. If your whole mentality in doing that research is so you can prove others wrong and yourself correct, then you've already done it wrong.

People should be willing and eager to do that level of research regardless of if they intend to share ti with even a single person. They should be doing it for themselves simply as part of their process for forming an opinion, even when that opinion wont be shared.

@EVoCeO

Depends on how you define tipping point. If it is a point where perminant damage has occured and stopping pollution will leave us with damage, then yes we have passed it. Areas are already deserts as a result of climate change that likely would have been fertile otherwise. they wont just revert if we get our act together.

If by tipping point you mean a point where a run-away reaction begins where green house gases are released due to the already existing climate change, and as such stopping our own pollution wont help due to these runaway sources, then no we havent reached that tipping point and most models have the tipping point decades into the future thankfully.

There are a few such models that describe a tipping point, for example the releasing of methane from frozen sources, as well as the release of green house gases sequestered in deep ocean sources. But all of these are thankfully decades away from being triggered. But we are on our way there.

@oranje@cybre.space

@oranje@cybre.space

Well weve already seen some improvemetns, so yea. but a few months of reduced pollution probably wont fix the problem.

@EVoCeO

@admin I'm not sure I agree. Most people are plenty capable and could have the attention span to critically review their sources. Most just dont because there isnt much societal pressure to do so.

Those who are well researched dont generally get much more respect, in fact often the opposite.

It is a societal issue rather than capability itself.

@freemo This is phenomenal. Ya, I don't think there is a chance we can hit the breaks on this. I found this the most interesting aspect of temperature increase. Unless we develop a mobile rebreather we won't survive the hydrogen sulfide environment naturally generated by ocean bacteria in warmer waters (obvious result of climate change).

"Once the oxygen is gone, the oceans become the realm of bacteria that obtain their oxygen from sulfur oxide compounds. These bacteria strip oxygen from the compounds and produce hydrogen sulfide. Hydrogen sulfide kills aerobic organisms.

Humans can smell hydrogen sulfide gas, the smell of rotten cabbage, in the parts per trillion range. In the deeps of the Black Sea today, hydrogen sulfide exists at about 200 parts per million. This is a toxic brew in which any aerobic, oxygen-needing organism would die. For the Black Sea, the hydrogen sulfide stays in the depths because our rich oxygen atmosphere mixes in the top layer of water and controls the diffusion of hydrogen sulfide upwards."
-from article

sciencedaily.com/releases/2005

Here is a small occurrence which I think heard is seasonal. This is the most recent event. experienced in San Diego, Ca. USA
latimes.com/california/story/2

@EVoCeO If we stopped all pollution and carbon loading 100% tomorrow, I think we would avoid most of the effects long term.

Not saying that is practical but the point is I do feel it is avoidable given humans take the right steps quickly enough.

The reason I agree with you in that it isnt likely to be stopped is because I do not think humans will take the steps needed, its just too drastic in most peoples minds I guess.

Interesting Fact of the Day:

Current climate change is happening at a pace 6.2 times faster than the climate change that resulted from the asteroid impact that killed the dinosaurs.

We have had 1.06 C change in about 150 years. The dinosaurs experienced a 4.5 degree change over 4,000 years. So for the dinosaurs it changed at a pace of 0.001125 C per year for us it has been about .007 degrees per year. So current climate change is happening 6.2x faster than it did during the extinction of the dinosaurs.

@admin

Agreed. But I think the point of the meme is not that one should provide that level of evidence to convince others, but rather that you should provide that level of evidence for yourself, when determining your convictions.

I think when your mindset is to disprove your own assumptions then it is an easier barrier to break than when someone else from the outside is trying to do it.

@2ck

So apparently Kiss from a Rose is performed better by a bunch of random seals than by Seal :)

My god I havent laughed this hard in a while.

youtu.be/G76nKGWRLPU

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.