you have to keep in mind our only rule is users of a server must respect the "right to disengage". We have that federation rule for reasons that go well beyond anything to do with administrators or mods (that only played a role in this particularly instance).
Its mostly a rule about ban evasion. If someone blocks you or exits a conversation then there is an expectation a user from another server wont try to evade that block.
If this were simply a single user harassing me I likely would have just muted that user until it was over. but this was orchastrated across dozens of users with an attempt to evade the mute I put in place and insert themselves into my notifications after I asked to be left alone.
If this had happened to a user rather than a moderator the consequence would have been the same, defederation if the server admins didnt intervene.
That account isnt actually used for moderating. We use it for announcements only, its an unmonitored account.
In theory i suppose we could have every moderator have their own sock puppet for that purpose though. But its tricky, moderation is ideally pro-active and not just reactive. In other words we dont just respond to reports but try to defuse situations as they develop ideally.
It would be worth considering, but it also means that we would open our userbase up to all sorts of spam and attacks if we made that a general rule, at least in theory.
Keep in mind it is only a silence not a suspension. Our users are still free to follow spinster.xyz accounts if they wish. It just means that if you arent following an account or a specific conversation then a spinster account can not show up in a users notifications without the user responding to or following the spinster account first.
@design_RG The 4% is probably about where the active and interested user count was before, minus random foreign accounts.
I have no problem with a 4% figure. Though it does mean we will quickly drop out as being seen as a "leader" in the fediverse community as other instances over take us in user count.
whether we care about that or not is another matter.
@design_RG Current trend is probably closer to 4% of applications wind up being accepted.
As of yet I dont think we have rejected a single application that was actually filled in. Virtually all rejections were due to having no text or what text it has is clearly spam or a single word.
** Just checked my mod email – 5 new applications, and TWO of them with responses.
I am ecstatic, friends. Thank you!!! Welcome !
[ repost - edited image, removed IPs.]
Agreed, me and the other mods tried several times at the time to explain this.
Alex knew damn well claire was muted at the time for over 24 hours before I had to escalate. But clearly Alex either has a faulty memory or is intentionally manipulating the situation. Luckily the conversation is in the public.
But once a person gets to that point I already know they are a lost cause.
As was stated at the time and multiple times now. I had muted the conversation for over 24 hours and harassment continued, to the poitn clair even got other people to contact me on her behalf on spinster...
Again this is why you got silenced as a server, specifcally because clair avoided a mute over the course of more than 24 hours.
Its really our only rule WRT federation. If a user asks to opt-out of a conversation then a user must honor it.
Spinster as a whole didnt honor that rule, and even after over 24 hours of being muted the harassment continued. Thus they got a silence, and like i said it was well deserved.
Yup we have only ever silenced two instances, and spinster.xyz is one of them, and with good cause.
Because the hope was that in knowing that clair was acting illegal (contrary to the CAN-SPAM) act, and others on their server they may wish to respond accordingly.
Our lawyer asked us to disengage and i asked our lawyer if they could contact alex and help them with their ToS if Alex wished to help them come in compliance with the law.
I made this very clear in my follow up message.
At first there was a back and forth, Claire responding to me or me to her in the early parts of the conversation was not the issue in the least.
Then at one point I said I was exiting the conversation and asked to no longer be tagged. At that point I did not respond to Clair for several days (as she was muted) yet she continued to tag and harass me through dozens of threads and encouraging other people to do the same.
It is only the period after I disengaged with clair (which as i said was over 24 hours later) and the harassment continued that it was even an issue.
As we discussed at the time, I could not have a mute on an entire server since I'm an administrator. I have to evaluate and rule on accusations made and to do that I have to be able to view threads and potential harassment.
So I muted the whole server personally for 24 hours to let it die down but as a rule neither me nor the other moderators can keep any server on personal mute indefinately.
Please stop mis representing the situation. clair opened several dozen threads once I muted hers and got ddozens of people from your server to also continue the harassment once It was asked to be left alone.
It constituted spam in every respect, it wasnt a single user. Even after a personal mute on your server for over 24 hours ocne I unmuted the server the harassment was continuing. Which ultimately led to your whole server being defederated.
I did mute the thread. over the course of several days the individually continually opened new threads to harassed, got several dozen other people to open new threads to harass, etc.
At one point I did a personal block ont he whole server for 24 hours, then when I removed the block the flooding instantly picked up again.
The only reason we had to silence the whole server is exactly because muting was not effective.
Here you can see where I responded shortly after to reassure him my comment was **not** a threat to sue. Our lawyer told us to not engage in the conversation and that we needed to revise our ToS, our lawyer was also extended to help alex, if he wished, be informed about what part of his ToS is against US law.
But as can be seen from my follow up I made it very clear that my comment did **not** imply any legal action was going to be taken
Notice the time stamp is only about an hour later, so we very quickly made it clear it was not a threat of legal action.
No we never threatened to sue you. Are you not going to even provide the follow up where I reassured you that the comment I made was not a threat of being sued or any legal action? One moment ill screen shot it.
I told you, because I was asked what I would do if MKULTRA decided to start using VPNS on our server to continue death threats against me or others... I suggested lawyers might get involed against MKULTRA should he exhibit violence **on** the QOTO server. I never suggested a lawyer would be involved against P in anyway.
Well I cant predict the future. But I gave no indication a lawyer was going to be involved against P in any way.
Jeffrey Phillips Freeman
Innovator & Entrepreneur in Machine Learning, Evolutionary Computing & Big Data. Avid SCUBA diver, Open-source developer, HAM radio operator, astrophotographer, and anything nerdy.
Born and raised in Philadelphia, PA, USA, currently living in Utrecht, Netherlands, USA, and Thailand. Was also living in Israel, but left.
Pronouns: Sir / Mister
(Above pronouns are not intended to mock, i will respect any persons pronouns and only wish pronouns to show respect be used with me as well. These are called neopronouns, see an example of the word "frog" used as a neopronoun here: http://tinyurl.com/44hhej89 )
A proud member of the Penobscot Native American tribe, as well as a Mayflower passenger descendant. I sometimes post about my genealogical history.
My stance on various issues:
Education: Free to PhD, tax paid
Abortion: Protected, tax paid, limited time-frame
Welfare: Yes, no one should starve
UBI: No, use welfare
Racism: is real
Guns: Shall not be infringed
LGBT+/minorities: Support
Pronouns: Will respect
Trump: Moron, evil
Biden: Senile, racist
Police: ACAB
Drugs: Fully legal, no prescriptions needed
GPG/PGP Fingerprint: 8B23 64CD 2403 6DCB 7531 01D0 052D DA8E 0506 CBCE