@whirli The problems blacks face is a issue, no doubt.. But its only a small blip in the overall issues we face. The dilution happens when we look at that small blip and presume it is the root of or the whole problem.
We need tos hift our thinking to see the whole problem and recognize that blip as part of it.
There is nothing wrong with BLM, it should be a voice. But especially given the current issue regarding police brutality, it isnt representative of the problem as a whole.
@qxinfinity Donations and ill cover it personally as needed.
@qxinfinity Areas where the roads are blocked and cars arent allowed to enter due to riots in the case of philly.
@timorl The key here is that it follows **perceived** incentives, not actual ones.
Therein lies the problem. In modern society perceived incentives are significantly disconnected to actual ones by most of the masses.
Those who are capable of accurately evaluating incentives and following them have largely come out of poverty and are middle or upper class by adulthood. Those who cannot generally act in self-defeating ways and never really make it in any direction.
You quoted something and then disagreed with something unrelated to the quote you just made...
The TV often ignores when cops murder non-blacks, ok fair.. Since when is the TV a member of BLM...
**people** say other lives dont matter all the time. That is not, however, the stance of the BLM in any official capacity what so ever.
No one is saying BLM suggests all lives dont matter. But again the school chess club analogy... when everyone is getting punched in the face your going to pretty ineffective if your rally cry focuses ont he small minority getting punched and doesnt try to address that people are getting punched as a whole. You simply wont rally people int he same way or be more effective in doing so.
See that point about fixing the black problem helps everyone, that is the reverse of my thinking..
If we see this as a predominately racist problem (and there are racist elements dont get me wrong) then we look for solutions to address racism to solve it. But screening officers for past racism, for example, might cause the number of black lives killed to come closer to the number of white people killed, but by in large the problem isnt solved, you still have massive numbers killed.
However if we recognize the problem is police brutality and that the racism aspect of it is not the central point (though certainly worth being pissed over all the same).. then we can seek actual solutions that solve the real problem. This is when you start looking more into if the police officer has violent tendencies towards anyone (not just blacks) for example and might look at their overall kill ratio that includes whites. The end result would be you get actually violent cops off the street and while you didnt address the racism issue directly, it still solved the problem of violence to everyone, including blacks.
I guess that depends. Animals arent likely to unify along humans to try to stop the problem. So picking such a phrase isnt going to do much good.
The point of ALM vs BLM is to show that even though the problem may effect blacks 40% more than people in general, it still effects the general population to a huge degree. So we should pick unifying language and not argue about who is getting fucked over slightly more than someone else.
Its like some bully in school goes around and punches everyone in the chess club in the face every day, but billy he punches twice every time he seems him.. it is silly to try to rally the chess club to fight back by going "billy's life matters" and makes way more sense to go "Chess club unites!"
If that is the case (I admit i dont know) then I agree, pulling IA agents from the police department itself would be self defeating.
Yea sadly im not sure it would work with americans, they have too much tunnel vision.
Certainly a bit of a tangent, but assuming it was a sereious point I wouldnt even agree. But then again im one of few meat eaters who thinks meat eating is immoral.
@alex Not sure if you mean it as a mockery or not, but as absurd as it sounds I do agree. I have always said i would be totally ok with a law that made all consumption of meat illegal. But I doubt that would ever happen (I know ironic coming from someone who isnt even vegan, but I do admit it is an immortal choice I make by my own views).
How would that independence be implemented differently than it currently is? They are already independent in the sense that they are autonomous from the groups they investigate. What would you change exactly?
Yes BLM is fine for addressing black issues. I am asking mostly about good phrases that talk about the abuse of all races, by police, but in a way that doesnt dismiss any black issues by doing so...
PoliceThePolice I think could work, though I dont think it really explicitly shows a multi-racial unity in the message, which is important. We need some message that emphasizes the fact that all races are being hurt by government abuses specifically the police. To me "PoliceThePolice" doesnt really emphaize the "all races are effected" clause and thus lacks the unity needed
Thats my point.. We need a message which 1) does not downplay what happened to blacks adn 2) is inclusive of the fact that this happens to all races and is a unified threat... BLM doesnt do that, ALM doesnt do that. I'm open to suggestions.
@LukeAlmighty Thats just it, All Lives Matter has no momentum. Its reputation as a phrase has been spoiled by it being used more as an anti-BLM phrase than an independent movement that it has no momentum at all
@LukeAlmighty what about "lives matter" implies only some? .. but ok, Ic an easily meet your demand. You would then presumably be ok if the phrase used is "Every Life Matters"?
@LukeAlmighty Your last message before this one we did agree, it wasnt gas lighting. The things you stated in that message were all statements that on their surface I agreed with. dont be a pompass ass.
Now this message which I am replying to now.. we agree on point 1 as stated (though as I said Lives Matter is likely more tactful and means the same thing), but otherwise either response, since they both mean the same thing, is entierly appropriate in my mind
to point 2, we also agree.
to point 3, no we dont agree there. BLM is not organized. People who have used that banner have acted as terrorists, others have not (and even decried those who did at times).
Your final point becomes moot since we dont agree on the third point.
Jeffrey Phillips Freeman
Innovator & Entrepreneur in Machine Learning, Evolutionary Computing & Big Data. Avid SCUBA diver, Open-source developer, HAM radio operator, astrophotographer, and anything nerdy.
Born and raised in Philadelphia, PA, USA, currently living in Utrecht, Netherlands, USA, and Thailand. Was also living in Israel, but left.
Pronouns: Sir / Mister
(Above pronouns are not intended to mock, i will respect any persons pronouns and only wish pronouns to show respect be used with me as well. These are called neopronouns, see an example of the word "frog" used as a neopronoun here: http://tinyurl.com/44hhej89 )
A proud member of the Penobscot Native American tribe, as well as a Mayflower passenger descendant. I sometimes post about my genealogical history.
My stance on various issues:
Education: Free to PhD, tax paid
Abortion: Protected, tax paid, limited time-frame
Welfare: Yes, no one should starve
UBI: No, use welfare
Racism: is real
Guns: Shall not be infringed
LGBT+/minorities: Support
Pronouns: Will respect
Trump: Moron, evil
Biden: Senile, racist
Police: ACAB
Drugs: Fully legal, no prescriptions needed
GPG/PGP Fingerprint: 8B23 64CD 2403 6DCB 7531 01D0 052D DA8E 0506 CBCE