Its nice that they are arresting the police officers involved in the Murder of George Floyd and all. But are we going to see the officer who drove through a crowd and ran over protestors? Or how about the officers that shot rubber bullets at a small child sitting on his front door step after curfew.
Are we going to see arrests for the countless other officers abusing and using violence against the people when it is uncalled for? Is there going to be a change in laws so we see these officers arrested now and into the future?
Or is the far more likely outcome going to be that they arrest just 3 or 4 officers to get everyone to shut up and then it is back to business as usual?
@willjc You need to register a seperate account on PeerTube. but we do protect your QOTO account name on our other services. If someone takes your QOTO account name and uses it on one of our services, sucht hat when you go to register it you can not, we will delete the name so you can have it.
@willjc Hi there, welcome to QOTO
Perhaps, but by virtue of the fact that it is not derivative of BLM itself there is a stronger argument for it as a separate idea that is not defined in relation to BLM or as a counter point to it.
To be fair your expiernces are likely biased by the circles you are in.
While I do agree there are examples where the phrase was tainted by bad actors I would not say the vast majority of people who use the phrase are racist.. some perhaps. Most just seem to want a more encompassing phrase that represents racial unity and solidarity among all races. That has largely been how it has been used when I see it used first-hand. But even my expiernces are likely biased too.
I would add as a phrase its origins are quite old as well. People have been using that phrase for at least hundreds of years.
But it was co-opted by some bad actors so I have no objection to switching up the phrase if it prevents misunderstanding. "Every Life Matters" seems a better choice all around to me as it doesnt appear as a derrivative of BLM anyway, so less likely to be seen as oppositional to it.
The meaning is largely determined by the person using the sloagan.. If a person is clueless as to its origin then clearly the meaning that person uses the phrase with is not dictated by its origin.
As I said I am not promoting ALM as a phrase. It is tainted and not well phrased as it is a derrivative of BLM and therefore exists in relation to it. So I generally dont encourage it as a phrase. I find "Every Life Matters" is more appropriate.
I personally use "Every Life Matters" as my phrasology. but in the example I gave i was talking about the ALM people who generally are ignorant and insensitive to BLM, so it was fitting, even if there may be some positive aspect to their message underneath the garbage.
I dont use ALM specifically because as a phrase it is tainted by some bad apples. It wasnt "started" by anyone, its a phrase that has existed since forever. but yes there are times some bad people have hijacked the phrase no doubt.
I am talking about the concept, not necessarily any organization around it as a sloagan.
There is a reason I avoid using the phrase myself but instead espouse the positive principles it embodies as a phrase.
@penny Oh dont worry I didnt mean to imply that **you** were accusing me of racism. Your fine, you are a bit harsh in your tone, but this is just an emotional and passionate issue for you. I think that abrasiveness may not always serve you well but in my case I am understanding of it, no worries.
I was really just speaking more to the general audience than you specifically. While I would say your interpretation of the other side was a bit tone deaf to their cries, you were not offensive, your good.
@penny Yes I think thats a good definition. Can you also, therefore, see why your own responses (particularly those earlier in the thread) also would be tone deaf to my own perceptions and the people who feel as I do?
There are a lot of people trying to say what I am saying.. many have no racist tendencies of any kind, and are often being called racist for even daring to include general police brutality in the issue (as it effects all races)..
The problem as I see it, many of the ALM people arent listening the the BLM side of things. Which is why it is important for me to highlight when i talk about this that blacks are absolutely suffering 2x - 3x more.. but at the same time the BLM side arent really listening to the ALM side who are claiming we have all been abused by cops and there is a sense of unity in that because we have a common enemy and that message is important to spread too...
Instead all I see is ALM hating BLM and BLM hating ALM and frankly their both tone deaf to the other and from my perspective at their core (when you remove the bad apples using those terms) they are both positive messages that should be side-by-side against a common problem.
@penny Yes I think thats a good definition. Can you also, therefore, see why your own responses (particularly those earlier in the thread) also would be tone deaf to my own perceptions and the people who feel as I do?
There are a lot of people trying to say what I am saying.. many have no racist tendencies of any kind, and are often being called racist for even daring to include general police brutality in the issue (as it effects all races)..
The problem as I see it, many of the ALM people arent listening the the BLM side of things. Which is why it is important for me to highlight when i talk about this that blacks are absolutely suffering 2x - 3x more.. but at the same time the BLM side arent really listening to the ALM side who are claiming we have all been abused by cops and there is a sense of unity in that because we have a common enemy and that message is important to spread too...
Instead all I see is ALM hating BLM and BLM hating ALM and frankly their both tone deaf to the other and from my perspective at their core (when you remove the bad apples using those terms) they are both positive messages that should be side-by-side against a common problem.
Leonie, who is the admin of a nice instance I appreciate -- https://Koyu.space/about/
...has posted a nice idea this morning, screenshot added here.
That we should have a new hashtag, #InstanceAdminDay :
* to offer thank yous and appreciation for the work, expense and effort they pour in to keep these services running.
* many times covering the costs out of their pockets.
* and mostly not shown the recognition for all of that
I think it's a GREAT idea, and fully support that. I wrote a Long post here yesterday, showing similar appreciation for the unique openness shown by our local Qoto.org admin and founder.
I also posted a nice LP (my usual is Long Form, as you know), just a few minutes ago, showing appreciation for Nolan Lawson's work, as both a fedi admin and author of an outstanding client.
As an active and opinionated #FediReporter who was dismayed by recent events, including the attacks on Leonie's personal reputation by despicable people, I am joining this.
Let's make it happen. Show some love and kudos to your favourite admins and site staff.
Thanks for all your work, Leonie.
Koyu.space is a wonderful instance, I recommend it to any discerning user looking for a nice Glitch-Social instance.
@koyu 's OP is at : https://koyu.space/@koyu/104291205207421914
@penny I did not use the phrase "just as important" either.
Which is why i never said we need to talk about something. I did say it is harmful to progress not to however.
In fact I have reiterated multiple times and even stated in my original post that not only are BLM supporters correct for bringing their perspective of the issue to the larger debate, but that it should be only one aspect of the larger debate.
Only that we cant have tunnel vision for just that one aspect and expect it to be a positive result.
@penny I never claimed anyone **needed** to do anything. Its a free country you dont even **need** to recognize a problem exists at all.
What I did say is by not talking about or addressing the big picture you arent going to properly solve the problem.
Having blinders to the full problem and focusing on one aspect of it is not how you win politicial movements. Thats exactly what americans have been doing for years and they keep making things worse not better. I see the exact opposite of that statement to be true, the radicalizm towards singular problems and polarization to one end of the spectrum on every single issue we try to discuss as a society is exactly why the USA is gettign worse year after year.
Well again, we are talking in pure analogy. I'd say the debate is over this point as it isnt going to generate anything useful beyond the points we have already raised.
Thank you for your input.
Jeffrey Phillips Freeman
Innovator & Entrepreneur in Machine Learning, Evolutionary Computing & Big Data. Avid SCUBA diver, Open-source developer, HAM radio operator, astrophotographer, and anything nerdy.
Born and raised in Philadelphia, PA, USA, currently living in Utrecht, Netherlands, USA, and Thailand. Was also living in Israel, but left.
Pronouns: Sir / Mister
(Above pronouns are not intended to mock, i will respect any persons pronouns and only wish pronouns to show respect be used with me as well. These are called neopronouns, see an example of the word "frog" used as a neopronoun here: http://tinyurl.com/44hhej89 )
A proud member of the Penobscot Native American tribe, as well as a Mayflower passenger descendant. I sometimes post about my genealogical history.
My stance on various issues:
Education: Free to PhD, tax paid
Abortion: Protected, tax paid, limited time-frame
Welfare: Yes, no one should starve
UBI: No, use welfare
Racism: is real
Guns: Shall not be infringed
LGBT+/minorities: Support
Pronouns: Will respect
Trump: Moron, evil
Biden: Senile, racist
Police: ACAB
Drugs: Fully legal, no prescriptions needed
GPG/PGP Fingerprint: 8B23 64CD 2403 6DCB 7531 01D0 052D DA8E 0506 CBCE