Thats an argument you could extend to any sort of hierarchical structure: Why have a federal government why not just give all that tax money to the states.
The truth is consolidated power in one proficient director can and does have advantages.
If someone has made a billion dollars in their life chances are they are exceptionally good at managing money, it also means they are really good at delegating to others effectively. That means they know when to hire people to run a factory for them, but they also are going to be pretty good at knowing when to fire them and have them replaced with someone who would do a better job.
the numbers chosen are an exaggeration of course.
The point is, staying rich, rather than giving it all away, enables you to do far far more good if that is your intention.
The point your missing is that how much money you can make is dependent on howmuch you made. making 1 million when you have 999 is going to be much easier than making 1 million when you have 0.
An altruistic rich person who stays rich will do far more good in a life time than an altruistic person who gives away any money they dont personally need and thus never becomes rich.
I dont think it has anything to do with pride or showing off for many (some). Its just that keeping the money means they can generate more and help more.
If I have a billion dollars and give 100% away to buy food for the starving if im lucky ive fixed hunger issues for a short while. at best.
However if I have a billion and only spend 1 million a year to feed the hungry and leave the other 999 million that means I can use that money to regenerate what I spent to feed the hungry by next year and do it again, over and over, and help far more people.
Mostly agree, but the more than you need being immoral might need some clarification.
A billionair who uses much of their money to create programs to feed the hungry, even if they still have billions in their bank account is acting perfectly morally as they are using those large funds to generate some good for others. So even though they may own far more than they need to survive, it is all perfectly ethical because it is put to good use, even without exhasting that collection of funds.
States and government are no more or less separate than people and the government. Sure companies can influence government through money, but in the end its the peoples voting power that makes decisions. So the responsibility for the laws and conduct of any democracy rests on its people.
The fact that people can not just grow crops anywhere is a consequence of policies and education, as well as law. The ownership of private property, for example, wouldnt be an issue if there was enough land to go around, there isnt. But there was a time in the USA where private property laws existed and land was free for the taking. Blame population growth and peoples unwillingness to keep the population in heck if you want to really find blame for why we cant all have land.
Resources do equal wealth, but resources are not limited to those on in the earth, nor are all the resources accessible to us. There is a great deal of resources still in the ground no one has access to, by mining those resources only then do they get injected into the population. So the volumn of accessible resources is constantly growing and while there is an upper bound if we limit ourselves to earth it also ignores the fact that as we approach that limit asteroid mining and other techniques will likely be underway as well.
It also is ignorant to the fact that resources are not limited to raw resources. We often consume raw resources and create new more useful resources from it, for example taking silicon and making it into chips. So you have created a greater (more wealth) resource from a resource that represented less wealth by doing so.
That analogy isnt accurate.. It is more accurate to say it is like spending your summer growing tomatoes and instead of giving it to your starving neighbor you can them up and give them to your child, who then uses the canned tomatoes to feed himself or feed a starving naeighboor.
Yea its not "nice" that you had food and let your starving neighboor go hungry and all. But your neighboor is no worse off now than if you never grew that food in the first place.
Accumulating wealth you generated isnt bad, it just isnt as good as spending it obviously. But if you generate a billion dollars and then dig a hole and burry it, you've done no more harm than if you never generated the billion in the first place. In fact you've probably done some good because you probably generated money for others along side generating that money for yourself.
With that said, all money will eventually get spent, even if that may not happen till after the person dies.
@soundofsun I love a good oyster!
Generally wealth generating schemes generate more wealth the more money they have as an input. So generally every step along the way as they generate wealthy they use that to generate more wealth and a large portion of it is used for wealth generation in increasing amounts, sure.
But also some of it, as you suggest, is just money you have personally for whatever you want to spend it on. But since this is money that would have never existed in the system without you having generated it in the first place, then there is no harm or negativity associated with spending it. Especially when you consider that the spending of that money itself ultimately can go to fund other wealth generating enterprises of other people and helps ensure new people come into the game by winning over some portion of your free funds.
Absolutely yes, somepeople will have an easier time generating wealth than others.
The point of this post is not "The system is perfect there is no inequality".. the issue is "Billionaires are not inherently a bad thing and do not, in and of themselves, represent an injustice done to others"
The idea "capitalism is immoral" just tells me you are probably too indoctrinated by dogma to be able to discuss the subject objectively.
Whether they are slaves are not is a matter of semantics, but what made them slaves in china's policies, largely china's lack of desire to help educate them and give them marketable skills so they can support themselves. So whether they are a slave or not is secondary tot he fact that they are in the position they are in because of China's policies, not NIKE's.
While in theory a minimum wage worker could forage or grow crops , again, they are not prevented from doing so by NIKE or any other mega corperation. Again that is the government and clearly unfair policies.
@rholb resources is really just another word for wealth.
As I said a billionair **can** take wealth but they also may not. It also isnt always the fault of the billionaire even if they do benefit from an unfair situation.
While the NIKe executives using slave labour may be a good example of immorality it isnt really an example of them stealing wealthy. The labour they use is at market value, those people would have had no work if NIKE didnt use them, so instead of them starving to death slowly they gave them some (unfair) amount of wealth to ensure they die more slowly, or maybe even just barely life. This is unfair, but since those people did not have the opportunity to use their labour to make wealth otherwise, it isnt an example of stolen wealth.
Obviously the solution there lies in China not educating their people in the first place so they werent subject to that slave labour, not with NIKE. If china had done their job NIKE would have been in a position to pay them much more as their market value would have been higher.
Its important to differentiate between doing soemthing that is immoral and whether wealth is actually being stolen or not.
Not really, if the wealth you have is generated and you can demonstrate you are exceptionally good at generating wealth, then it is not hoarding a festering pile, your existance is in fact a service to others and the nation by allowing you to have so much wealth since you can continue to generate more wealth for everyone (including yourself) more so than other people (who have not proven their abilities) might be able to do.
@mikelga Yea, the difficulty is, of course, in knowing the value of your purchases and decisions. That isnt always easy.
Not really, it only seems that way until you start trying to model actual economies and make predictions. It breaks down really fast when you try to take that assumption and actually prove it out through models.
The fact is, if we want to accurately model how money flows and changed over time we inevitably wind up with massive wealth generation at every level.
It is really just that its very hard, perhaps impossible, for most of us to see past the indoctrination that has been drilled into most laypeople suggesting money as a finite pie is somehow remotely accurate, in practice, it is not.
Jeffrey Phillips Freeman
Innovator & Entrepreneur in Machine Learning, Evolutionary Computing & Big Data. Avid SCUBA diver, Open-source developer, HAM radio operator, astrophotographer, and anything nerdy.
Born and raised in Philadelphia, PA, USA, currently living in Utrecht, Netherlands, USA, and Thailand. Was also living in Israel, but left.
Pronouns: Sir / Mister
(Above pronouns are not intended to mock, i will respect any persons pronouns and only wish pronouns to show respect be used with me as well. These are called neopronouns, see an example of the word "frog" used as a neopronoun here: http://tinyurl.com/44hhej89 )
A proud member of the Penobscot Native American tribe, as well as a Mayflower passenger descendant. I sometimes post about my genealogical history.
My stance on various issues:
Education: Free to PhD, tax paid
Abortion: Protected, tax paid, limited time-frame
Welfare: Yes, no one should starve
UBI: No, use welfare
Racism: is real
Guns: Shall not be infringed
LGBT+/minorities: Support
Pronouns: Will respect
Trump: Moron, evil
Biden: Senile, racist
Police: ACAB
Drugs: Fully legal, no prescriptions needed
GPG/PGP Fingerprint: 8B23 64CD 2403 6DCB 7531 01D0 052D DA8E 0506 CBCE