Show newer

@a1batross

You probably could have reverted the deletion then and cited the vote and ultimately would have won.

@admin @mukt

@hansw@mastodon.social Its not in terms of nutritional value, but I just take a vitamin for that. It also isnt the best in terms of saturated fat for sure, but that has little to do with weight loss and more to do with cholesterol levels (and mine are good). From a caloric intake perspective its good though.

@hansw@mastodon.social Exercise is good for overall health, and of course helpful for weightloss, no doubt.

From what doctors tell me and my own expiernce diet is 70% of any weight loss and exercise is 30% if we are just talking about impact on the scale itself.

With that said exercise is critical for heart health and many other things so it has importance beyond just the scale as well.

@admin

youll have to point me to the rule that claims that. I have never once in all my years editing wikipedia seen someone gain priority on an edit based on seniority without invoking a vote first.

@mukt

Since starting my diet i have lost 8 lbs in 5 days so far. This has been my lunch every day, a handmade bagel with mexican Oaxaca cheese and some potassium salt, toasted. Dinner is usually a hamburger with cheese and bacon. That's all i eat in a day, no breakfast. About 1500 calories a day.

@admin

While anonymous users can make edits they cant vote. So ultimately they have no power to enforce disputed changes.

@mukt

@admin

I'm not claiming it isnt a messed up system and hard to change.. But a dictatorship garunteed by technological means is impossible to change short of legal means (which almost never happens).. If the owner ofa subreddit wishes to be malicious 100% of the community can disagree with him and it still wont change the power he has over that subreddit.

@mukt

@mukt That wasnt what I said..

here is what I said

1. democracy is better than dictatorship.

2 Large groups voting in a democracy are easier to change than small groups in a absolute dictatorship position.

@mukt
Youd have to point out where the circular path is, not seeing it.

@mukt In this case the large group, since the large group works within a democracy and each person has only one vote..

The small group is a dictatorship with absolute power. No matter how many people disagree with them their power remains the same.

So in this case the small group is far more difficult to change than the large group.

@mukt the difference is that injustice done by a group of voters in a democracy voting against proper interests (the gang) has mechanisms for change. Its a democracy so you are free to create your own coalition of people who agree with you and then you have your own "gang" you can use to overthrow the other. There is a path and a mechanism there for you to fix the injustice.

However when it is done by a dictator, and a relatively small number of them, there is no such mechanism. You are beholden to their tyranny without any way to enact justice against it.

@mukt

Ganging up to a win a vote is kinda the whole point of democracy :)

@admin

@mukt

Even a powerful cabal though cant circumvent democracy entirely. If you push for a vote you will usually get one and the cabal gets the same vote as everyone else.. The issue is just that they tend to command a lot of respect and have strong influence on the votes. But hey, thats democracy for you.

@admin

@mukt

I've been in some disputes I strongly disagreed with too. I do agree wikipedia can often be unfair and biased, it does happen.

But at the end of the day I keep coming back to the fact that at least their a democracy, maybe not a great one, but its a step above pure dictatorships at least.

@admin

@mukt

did you revert the edit? Wiki pedia allows you to revert edits and you can continue to rerevert it up to a set number of times, something like 2.. So in short you can boycott the change and your boycott would be honored.

Only way they can force the edit to go through despite your boycott is if a third person comes in and takes a side, in which case majority rules. If things get out of hand you can have a vote in the talk pages, and it mostly comes down to majority rule..

You say you tried bringing it up on the talk page and it got deleted as "not a forum"... but was this done by someone with authority?

I'm a wikipedia editor and I can come in and try to push the debate in the right direction. Often its a majority rules system so you can always just ask for assistance whens tuff like this happens.

In my eyes wik8ipedia is at least a democracy, no one is a dictator. Reddit however is dictator run which makes it less pleasant to me when you have mad mods since the power is concentrated with a few.

@admin

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.