Show newer

@derek

While these are all legitimate questions to ask, and exemplify why truly distributed networks are a real challenge, they arent impossible to solve.

Generally with distributed networks the answer to most of this is "the data is stored with your peers when offline".

Somehow (depending on the protocol devised) there are multiple copies throughout the mesh of any data. The redundancy of this is high enough to garuntee the data persists and as nodes go down and redundancy is lost the other copies in the network replicate to keep the redundancy consistent.

When you come on line, presuming its a new client without a copy of your own data, it then finds your data in the network and reconstitutes it locally

@original_fractalator@mstdn.io @realcaseyrollins @Locksmith

@johnabs There is no "off topic" on this server. We are a STEM server in the sense that you need to be a STEM professional or student to have an account here. We do not, however, require you only post about STEM, nor do we encourage it.

Discussion about politics are welcome and feel free to make such posts as often as you'd like.

@original_fractalator@mstdn.io

PArtly correct, but two problems here.. 1) your leaving out that one is a subcategory of the other (distributed is a subset of decentralization, not seperate and distinct from it)... 2) your also mincing terms, or rather, Casey is. I'll try to explain.

First you have the terms for types of network topologies. This is, how the authority of nodes in a communication network are ordered. You have a few relevant types here:

* Star network: this is the type of topologies facebook or twitter employee a simple client-server architecture

* Tree network: this is what the fediverse is, but having only a 2-level tree, clients, servers, and then the servers are all on the same level.

* Mesh network - This is where every node has equal authority and the nodes interconnect and relay between each other with equal authority

Next you have the categories of centralization, these are similar except in this case each is a subset of the other. It mostly fits the diagram you described but has the subset nature I mention

* Centralized - We all know what this means

* Decentralized - Any network with any degree of decentralization, both tree networks and mesh networks are types of decentralized networks.

* Distributed - Any network where there is no centralizations of anykind. **all** distributed networks are decentralized networks, but **not all** decentralized networks are distributed. A mesh network, is both a decentralized and a distributed network, a tree network is a decentralized network but not a distributed one.

Lastly we have the protocols themselves, which often line up with the above categories but dont always:

* client-server - such protocols are almost always centralized and star-servers but do not need to be so. There is a clear distinction between a server in authority and a client. For example a database in a master-slave configuration where clients can connect to either a master or a slave would technically be decentralized despite being client server

* federated - A type of client-server architecure where the authority (federated servers) do not have central control, but clients yield to the authority of a specific server. So it appears centralized from the clients perspective, but is mesh from the servers perspective.

* peer-to-peer - in this architecture there is no sense of a server, the server functions and client functions are both servered by a peer

Its important to note here though that peer-to-peer does **not** always mean distributed, or mesh, though it often does. For example the Gnutella protocol is a peer-to-peer server but the peers negotiate for their right to serve as indexing node, as well as a seed node. As such Gnutella protocol is an example of peer-to-peer that operates in a non-distributed decentralized tree-like network

@derek @realcaseyrollins

@realcaseyrollins Peer to peer **is** decentralized, one of many types of decentralization.

I suspect what you meant to say was "federation" instead of "decentralization" (both federation and peer to peer are two categories under neat decentralization).

@snow @natse @snow_wintermute @scaria_law @dv8

I also only tagged the wrong snow by accident in my post. I meant the one at wintermute obviously, not the alt account. So the point is moot.

@wpo care to share their reasons and if possible the new and old one? I am just hearing of this now.

@FailForward

> Regarding the suspensions, yes I noticed on those conversations that it’s sometimes very ideological. Yet, they sometimes speak about users harassing others, i just wondered how often does that happen.

Do you have an example of someone complaining of harassment? We tend to take that very seriously and I can only think of maybe half a dozen such incidents. In all cases though it was resolved, its pretty rare.

One of our rules to help protect others from harassment that we are very strict on is the whole "no ban evasion" rule. If a user mutes you or blocks you and we find out you intentionally open an account somewhere (QOTO or anywhere else) to avoid it and harass someone then we are not going to let you stay on QOTO. So there shouldnt really be any outstanding instances of harassment unless a moderator was simply never told about it.

> Technically speaking I wonder about instance merveilles.town. This seems to be a community of makers there. They list qoto.org as suspended, which they explain means that any interaction with users from qoto is impossible. Yet I see toots from such users and I am able to check those people’s timelines. So is the suspension somehow unidirectional? If I for instance send a message to such an account, will it arrive?

Are you sure it is a suspension and not a silence? The way you describe it it sounds more like they silenced QOTO which is unidirectional and still allows users from that instance to follow QOTO users, they just wont see their content until they do.

> Also I am curious, why specifically this suspension happened?

This is the first im hearing about that particular instance suspending us. I try to reach out to any instance that does and ask them what issues they have and see if its something I can resolve. So I usually remember instances where that is a problem. I will try to reach out them.

To me it says a lot about an instance if they suspended us and I never even heard there was a problem. If an instance suspends another without reaching out to the moderators to try to get a concern resolved or even creating a single report on an incident somewhere, well not sure how they expect us to be aware of problems. Says a lot of an instance will just skip right to suspending another without at least reporting first.

@users

@Xoktz subtractive manufacturing simulation/dry run to see how it will run once you load it onto the machine I take it?

@FailForward

> I hang around here since about a month and I wonder where are all these people(?) Local timeline is fairly slow for the amount of users. Even if just 10% of all the accounts were somewhat chatty people (~1500?), we should see way more chatter all around. What is then going on here?

A combination of factors there, some signup for accounts and never speak (perhaps they just want to look around), others post unlisted, others are spam accounts that wind up being suspended.

A more useful number is to look at the active users (people who are posting or commenting in some form). I believe its around 1.5K or something like that. I think that number is anyone who posted or was active in the last month.

> Also, I am curious what are those numbers of users dropping every now and then in the plot? Are these some automatic deletes? I am just curious.

Spammers. Recently one of our mods has went on a crusade to remove all old accounts going back a few years that were spammers that got through the cracks. Mostly accounts that were created, never posts, and have spam and links in their descriptions. Over the course of a few weeks, mostly in bursts, he has removed many hundred such accounts. Thats why you see big dips in certain places.

We also remove spammers more regularly as we catch them, more often the accounts that post spam rather than just have it as a description. so you will see smaller dips take place periodically as we go through new users and try to find any spammers that are more recent.

> Finally, I also wonder about all this chatter about banning/suspending (whatever terminology is technically correct) qoto.org. According to local timeline, these are pretty innocuous toots. So what are those thousands of accounts which do not post publicly doing?

This sort of chatter is normal and common for almost any instance, though QOTO we tend to address it head on and share such incidents so our user base tends to be more aware of it is all.

Generally this comes from a very small group of instances that have a very long list of instances they block and pretty much block everyone and everything. Most of it isnt a block suggested because of QOTO content but actually because we allow our users to view an uncensored version of the fediverse. There is a movement amongst this small minority of servers to effectively block any server that doesnt themselves block (and censor its content from our users) bad servers. But this pattern cascades out so if you federate with a server that federates with a server that federates with a server that is a bad apple they will demand you get blocked by proxy. A sort of "punishment" for not censoring I guess. The end result of that is they basically demand you as a server censor 90% of the fediverse lest be blocked by them.

Overall its such a small number of servers, and their demands so excessive, that no one tends to really care much about them at this point. Despite this I still make it a point to comment on such threads and share them when I see them so our community is aware of it.

@users

@biomedmax

I feel like that is something that really has to be done by a person.. I volunteer, for science!

@Science

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.