Show newer

@frank87

> A few years ago there was a lawsuit about theft of weapons in MMRORPG. And yes the exclusive ability to control the objects was a mayor part of being a possession.

Please show me the specific legal decision and original wording that reflects this assertion. I'd be happy to consider it.

It seems to me your just getting it backwards. If you legally possess something the law gives you some level of control over it. It does not however mean you must prove you have control over something in order to own it or that loosing such control means you no longer own it.

I gave several such examples to that point, renting a car being a good one. The owner keeps legal ownership and therefore from the law (not the other way around) has a right to control that car in certain limited ways (such as recall it to their possession)... but by renting out that car they give away far more control than they retain. The person they rent to decides where it goes, when it goes there, what route it takes, pretty much has complete control over the car for the time of that rental. Yet the owner does not loose ownership simply because they give away control.

@SteveTheDragon

@Faket

Sorry you were insulted, I do not approve of that.

It sounds like you are describing libertarianism (local government has all the power, federal governments dont exist other than as a coalition and is voluntary)... libertarianism isnt anarchism, it sounds like your just mixing up terms.

> So, are free license like GPL, MIT ok?

Are you asking me what is "ok" as in, a good thing to have, or what is compatible with various forms of economics and governments, they are two very different things.

Anarchism doesnt dictate what is ok or what isnt.. It just garuntees no one will ever be coerced into doing anything they dont want to and can never force someone to do something they dont want to. Everything else is free game.

So from an anarchism perspective open source licneses cant exist regardless if they are "ok" or not, because they coerce people to follow the terms of the license.

> Without them people could use the code and make them proprietary, which would coerce users.

how would that coerce users? They couldnt make it propritary in the typical sense under an anarchism either. In other words, they could not render an EULA that said "you are not allowed to make copies of this and give it away".. such an EULA could not exist in an anarchism anymore than an open-source license could.

What a programmer **can** do in an anarchism however is compile their software, never distribute the source code in the first place, and add DRM to their software so if a user tried to give the software away for free they would find they would be unable to. They can then charge people for it. THAT would be compatible with anarchism since no one is being coerced, I am simply offering to sell you some bytes that you would have a hard time redistributing, your welcome to try, but im welcome to put in measures to prevent you...

So it would effectively be proprietary, but again not the form your used to seeing, and not enforced by license.

@SteveTheDragon

@Faket

No where in the statement you just quoted did I claim it was "no rules"...

Anarchism by definition means that it is not permitted for a hierarchy to exist in which an individual can be coerced to do or not do anything they do not want. That is the defining quality of anarchism. To quote wikipedia on the definition of anarchism:

> Anarchism is a political philosophy and movement that is sceptical of authority and rejects all involuntary, coercive forms of hierarchy.

So that means rules are allowed, but **only** rules that outlaw one person coercing another in some way. It is this reason murder can be illegal in an anarchism (it is a rule), because murder is the ultimate coercion of someone (you are forcing someone to be dead who doesnt want to be).

By this fundemental definition of anarchism, however, it also means that you can not issue licenses for yoursoftware as doing so would coerce the users of that software to have to following your rules, creating the two things anarchism is against: a hierarchy (you as the rule maker) and coercion (the terms of the license).

Therefore in an anarchism a person would be well within their rights to ignore any open-source license and use the software however they please, so long as they dont use it to coerce other people.

@SteveTheDragon

@Faket

Why are you using quote marks. No one said that (other than you just now).

@SteveTheDragon

@maheshmanish This feels a bit spammy.. your first post is to a link you personally profit from? If you were already an active contributor it might not be an issue but this looks like its against our rules, unless you'd like to try making a new first post?

@ricardo

Exactly open-source is more capitalism than lack of open-source.. The fact that market is free enough to let you undercut it at your discretion is the very capitalistic.

@frank87 @SteveTheDragon

@frank87

What confusion?

Your argument doesnt make sense to me

> What does ownership mean in this case. You can't own the Linux kernel. It's impossible to have control over it, as soon an it's on other people's devices.

Ownership refers to the person who owns the program. you then go into "impossible to control".. thats unrelated to ownership. Ownership does not require one have control over a thing, only that legally it is theirs.

In fact we have plenty of examples where we have seen this not to be true. Microsoft owns windows, and they have no trouble legally exercising that ownership.

in fact we have countless examples of someone else owning something you control, cars (rentals, leases), renting a home.

This whole argument tries to assert things that are true and easily disproven. so its a bad starting point.

> It's not the software that is property, it's the copyright.

copyright is just a technically term for "owning the software" so not really changes anything about what is being said here. Yes the person who **creates** the code has rights over how it is used, thats what is meant by ownership.

> That's the right, managed by all the licences. People working on free software, don't want to go into the business of monetising copyright.

This also is fundamentally incorrect. I open-source virtually all the code I write. I also make a lot of money directly or indirectly off of my open-sourced code. A great many people and companies monetize their copyrights and there are many ways and models to do this within the open-source domain.

> Monetising copyright is a specialised business, and it hinders development. It makes economical sense to make free software and make a living installing it or running it.

While I obviously wont agree that monetising is bad, as we covered open-source includes the ability to monetize as many businesses do, I will agree of course that open-source is good and generally helps everyone economically. More importantly however this isnt the point. You are basically arguing that open source is good for everyone (I agree).. but that does nothing to counter my original point that open-source is fundamentally capitalism in that it goves the author to choice to open-source or not, and under what terms.

@SteveTheDragon

@Faket

You dont get to define what anarchism is, it already has a definition.
@SteveTheDragon

@Faket

In anarchism you can not enforce people to do what you want by law.. so while anarchism might allo wyou to put some arbitrary text at the top of your code that sounds like a license, it does not give it any legal authority.

In anarchism if someone obtains your code with an open-source license attached they are allowed to completely ignore your license and use your code however they want.

@SteveTheDragon

@Faket

Anarchism can very well look chaotic, but there are forms that arent. But in all its forms it holds one thing in common, there is never a coercive form of hierarchy.. as in, no law that dictates what your not allowed to do (though some might argue some fundemental restrictions on that).

Perhaps your confusing anrarchism iwth libertarianism, which is where there is a hierarchy and laws but it is minimalized and localized.

Also for the record anarchism and libertarianism are government forms. capitalism is not, not exactly. You can have a capitalistic anarchism, in fact anarchy by default would be capitalistic (as in having a free market).

@SteveTheDragon

@Faket

No, in anarchism you wouldnt have licenses at all, there would be no laws and no licenses. Anyone could take your code and use it however they please, with or without your consent.

@SteveTheDragon

@SteveTheDragon thats not communism or socialism, it is capitalism. Capitalism allows people to give things away for free, and it is their choice under what terms they do so (that is the key). The fact that you can pick 20 different types of open source licenses, or none at all, is capitalism.

If it were communism you wouldnt even have the option to decide to open source your code, the government would just take it from you and then set whatever demands on you they wish on your own code.

@SteveTheDragon thats not communism or socialism, it is capitalism. Capitalism allows people to give things away for free, and it is their choice under what terms they do so (that is the key). The fact that you can pick 20 different types of open source licenses, or none at all, is capitalism.

If it were communism you wouldnt even have the option to decide to open source your code, the government would just take it from you and then set whatever demands on you they wish on your own code.

@akeno

LOL always enjoy watching the morons moroning... please continue while i watch and laugh.

@nubigo @Atlas

@trebach@tilde.zone

I never claimed he was obligated personally to put in that effort, or that anyone should. Though what I am claiming is that people shouldnt be blocking those instances at an instance level because it prevents those who do want to invest time into making the world a better place from being able to do so. This is made far worse when instances even go so far as to block an instance for not blocking an instance.

Block them and dont put in the effort if you want, that is fine, but when you actively start telling other people they cant interact with them as well thats the point you've crossed the wrong line IMO.

@TonyStark @zleap

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.