Show newer

@seroom to me slow moving clocks dilating makes a lot of sense.. the slower you move a clock the less it dilates, but the longer it needs to stay in motion. So it will in the end dilate the same regardless of how fast you move it for the same distance.

That said if we are just talking about preference in terms of what we assume with our equations, then constant c should be prefered for no other reason than it produces the simplest model and gives the same results as more complex models where c is not one-way constant. The simplest model that gives correct results should always be preferred. But just because its preferred doesnt mean it dictates reality :)

@3ammo and yes the conversation was interesting and I'm glad we had it.

@3ammo Yes i think most of this has been dueling definitions and perhaps a little philosophy at best.

My philosophy is that anything that is unknowable and untestable is in all possible states and once and isnt particularly worth talking about "one true reality".. To me the unobservable nature of one-way c is of the same sort as the unknowable nature of variables in the heisenberg uncertainty principle. That is nothing and everything is true at the same time until it can be observed and since it can never be observed it exists in a state of superposition with itself where any arbitrary interpretation is equally valid and true.

@seroom

Also someone recommended this amazing video shortly after my original post.. It says a lot of the same things I have said (though I hadnt seen the video before, its just these are common thought experiments reused in the scientific community anyway)... It explains everything i have been trying to explain with some visualizations:

invidious.fdn.fr/watch?v=pTn6E

@3ammo @Science

@seroom There are many schemes that would all result in consistent clock synchronization.. in fact as long as your scheme preserves two-way light speed and breaks one-way light speed (or doesn't break it) you will have a consistent and equivalent clock synchronization scheme that works.. and thats the key here. Now if there is some reality and one-way c has some asymmetry, or symmetry, then only one of the many schemes may result in clocks truly being synchronized (though this is impossible to know or ever do).. but the point is any of the infinite schemes that picks arbitrary asymmetries for c will result in clocks that will give meaningful consistent experimental results, so we really don't have to care about "true synchronization" which is unknowable anyway.

Did you see my earlier example where i showed two scenarios, one with symmetric c and the other asymmetric c and both using a time synchronization approach that assumes symmetric c, and how both scenarios in both universes give the apparent same results? Thats an important one.

@seroom

Now your hitting on the crux of the problem. The problem comes from the inehrent fact that clock synchronization is not about actually synchronizing clocks in any reality... it is about creating a convention which when applied to clocks will give you consistent experimental results. Thats the key in all this. When we synchronize clocks in the typical einstein convention for it the result is such that experiments will give consistent results regardless of if c is symmetric or asymmetric, so the problem becomes moot.

@3ammo @Science

@3ammo

> What I am saying is that we are not allowed to make statements like "In reality, c is anistropic, but whenever we measure it it looks like everything is symmetric". That statement is not forbidden because we have an experiment that contradicts it (we already established that it's compatible with measurements), but because it's logically incompatible with the framework we already chose. Why is logically incompatible? Because it asserts that there is a fundamentally anisotropic physical effect, without a theory behind it. If we decide to put a theory behind it, then that theory will have to conform to the symmetry *because we said so*. If it does, then it will have some isotropic signal.

So we somewhat agree here. I do agree that no one could ever say "in reality one-way c is anisotropic", theory or no theory in not even testable and will not contradict existing theory if true anyway so not even theoretically testable.

What I am saying, which is more important really is that for the exact same reasons you cant say "in reality one-way c is anisotropic" you **also** can not say "in reality one-way c is isotropic", for all the same reasons, there is no theoretical framework you could use to prove it.

So my point all along has been "It is fundamentally unknowable due to the physical laws" and since the theoretical laws are a description of the physical laws it is also unknowable in theory.

So to take my point back another step, not only is the isotropy of one-way c unknowable, but whatever it does in reality (be isotropic or anisotropic) you will never have a way to discern one from the other. It is inherently unfalsifiable. Which is also why the idea that it is isotropic is merely a convention, it makes our math easier and any assumption of its nature gives the same results so we pick the one that is mathematically the easiest to do.

@freemo @Science I continue to believe you are mistaken. From Wikipedia "the speed of light is isotropic, meaning that it has the same value regardless of the direction in which it is measured. Observations of the emissions from nuclear energy levels as a function of the orientation of the emitting nuclei in a magnetic field (see Hughes–Drever experiment), and of rotating optical resonators (see Resonator experiments) have put stringent limits on the possible two-way anisotropy."

@seroom

I am not mistaken, this is well established cannon in the scientific community regarding the speed of light, this isnt something I made up. There is a whole wikipedia article on it. To quote the wikipedia article linked below:

When using the term 'the speed of light' it is sometimes necessary to make the distinction between its one-way speed and its two-way speed. The "one-way" speed of light, from a source to a detector, cannot be measured independently of a convention as to how to synchronize the clocks at the source and the detector. What can however be experimentally measured is the round-trip speed (or "two-way" speed of light) from the source to the detector and back again. Albert Einstein chose a synchronization convention (see Einstein synchronization) that made the one-way speed equal to the two-way speed. The constancy of the one-way speed in any given inertial frame is the basis of his special theory of relativity, although all experimentally verifiable predictions of this theory do not depend on that convention.[1][2]

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-way_

@3ammo By the way the above quote from wikipedia reinforces/agrees with what ive been saying, that the one-way speed of light as a constant is a mere convention and not a postulate or theory about any reality, as one-way speed of light is not measurable.

@Science

@3ammo Another very relevant quote from that wikipedia article which basically repeats what I keep telling you:

"Using generalizations of Lorentz transformations with anisotropic one-way speeds, Zhang and Anderson pointed out that all events and experimental results compatible with the Lorentz transformation and the isotropic one-way speed of light must also be compatible with transformations preserving two-way light speed constancy and isotropy, while allowing anisotropic one-way speeds."

@3ammo By the way on the wikipedia page on this topic which i already linked there is a section that shows the lorentz transformation generalized for asymetric c and should become immediately obvious why it would result in the same observed laws of physics as we would expect and see.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-way_

@3ammo No you dont... no matter what theory you have that explains why the light is asymmetric doesnt change the fact that symmetry of space will always be observed. Any theoretical experiment that can be verified experimentally, if you arbitrarily change light to be asymetric without any framework, it can be at random, ijust needs to preserve two-way consistency, if you do this the experimental nad theoretical results will **always** be the same as when the light is symmetric.

Therefore you do NOT need a theory to explain why the light is asymmetric in order to keep the symmetry of the observed space to be the same, the symmetry of the observed space is guaranteed to be preserved so long as the two-way speed of light is preserved. This is the very reason it is untestable in the first place.

@3ammo Agreed, you will certainly learn from that process and it might connect the dots for you as to why an asymetric speed of light would be impossible to test and would in no way change the observed universe

@seroom

I am not mistaken, this is well established cannon in the scientific community regarding the speed of light, this isnt something I made up. There is a whole wikipedia article on it. To quote the wikipedia article linked below:

When using the term 'the speed of light' it is sometimes necessary to make the distinction between its one-way speed and its two-way speed. The "one-way" speed of light, from a source to a detector, cannot be measured independently of a convention as to how to synchronize the clocks at the source and the detector. What can however be experimentally measured is the round-trip speed (or "two-way" speed of light) from the source to the detector and back again. Albert Einstein chose a synchronization convention (see Einstein synchronization) that made the one-way speed equal to the two-way speed. The constancy of the one-way speed in any given inertial frame is the basis of his special theory of relativity, although all experimentally verifiable predictions of this theory do not depend on that convention.[1][2]

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-way_

@3ammo By the way the above quote from wikipedia reinforces/agrees with what ive been saying, that the one-way speed of light as a constant is a mere convention and not a postulate or theory about any reality, as one-way speed of light is not measurable.

@Science

@3ammo As I already said even if light is asymmetric it doesn't break the isotropy or homogeneity of space anyway necessarily. So even if we agree that that **theory** is true and extends to light symmetry (which is nothing more than an untestable hypothesis) it still doesn't show light must be symmetric.

@3ammo You could just accept it due to the fact that it is accepted by the body of scientists as true who have already done that work. Though I do encourage you to do the exercise for your own knowledge.

@3ammo My point is you can literally make up any theory no matter how nonsensical and so long as that theory only has the result of effecting the one way value of c you can not disprove it no more than you can prove c to be symetrical.

I could for example say "Well space just happens to be asymetric by its very nature, there is in fact a special orientation and space itself is deformed in such a way to give these results" If i say that it wouldnt disagree with any evidence we have and is just as plausible as saying space-time is inherently symetric.

take a step back and look at the already existing asymmetry we see in special relativity. If i am on a ship moving away from some other ship, I will always see the clock on the other ship move more slowly than mine. This is true no matter which ship did the accelerating that caused the movement. So from my perspective on the ship it would appear (incorrectly) as if i am in a special frame of reference and/or that there is some prefered orientation to the ship. But we also know the same would be viewed from any other frame of reference and that round-trip the symmetries resolve and we only have a one-way paradox (not unlike our current discussion). The difference is in this case we can actually see an asymmetry, in the case of light that is hidden from us. Its only because the asymmetry resolves itself on round trip that we consider the paradox solved, because it effectively produces consistent results that can be tested.

So why does one asymmetry bother you anymore than the other? There is no framework to suggest to you light has symmetry anymore than there is a framework to tell you it is asymmetric.. so you have no reason to prefer symmetry

@3ammo and no, gravity wouldn't change. A lorentz transformation modified so c is asymmetrical would result in the same experimental results as a symmetric c.. the math would be needlessly more complex, but the final testable results would be the same.

If this were true than the asymetry would be testable, which it is not. All your doing is obscuring it in more complex situations and hope something will work out and change the results.. yet it never does if you do the math.

@3ammo

> qoto.org/@3ammo/105963064680177147, the "isotropy" of the speed of light is also directly related to our notions of space symmetry (among other things). This a statement about the world.

two problems with this.

1. space symmetry holds true for many things, but none of them in any way rely on a symmetry of speed of light. If light is antisymmetric then space can still be isotropic in all the ways we have observed it to be. you are referring to the cosmological principle and all it states is "When viewed at a large enough scale the universe will look the same to all observers"... this principle holds true even if c is asymmetric.

2. we never defined how c is asymmetric, nor did I state it is just some arbitrary direction in space, the asymmetry could arise through all sorts of rules (none of which is testable mind you). For example it could be that light travels faster in the direction you are moving than the opposite. In relativity fashion therefore the direction of the asymmetry is opposite for each of the observers in a clock synchronization experiment, yet due to the reasons mentioned before once this is resolved by a full round trip to compare clocks the asymmetry cancels out and you get what looks like symmetric results. In fact this example is very much in line with what we see with time dilation and special relativity how the act of making a round trip resolves the twin paradox as the acceleration to reverse direction resolves the paradox.

The point your missing (I think) and that is so important to this is that if an asymmetry exists it can not be distinguished from a symmetry in part to the impossibility of measuring light one-way. It is of a similar nature as trying to know two complimentary properties in QM, not only is it impossible, that impossibility is fundamental.

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.