Show newer

@Coyote usually if a study is funded by the government then it often, though not always, wont be behind a paywall. It is public and therefore not for private infrastructure.

When a study is private it means they couldn't get government funding and they are therefore paying for the study with that paywall (albeit after the fact).

@Coyote No thats not remotely true. Funding in the vast majority of cases must come on the condition that the funding is received no matter the outcome of the study. Moreover you do not get funding specifically for favorable studies. Thats just not how it works.. Why do you think there are paywalls? You are paying for the studies, and the fact that the vast majority of those payments are subscriptions to all studies (not just the ones that agree with your biases) you can not, even if you wished to, pay for studies to be favorable.

Obviously there are always a few exceptions of fraudulent studies. But they are rare and few between and the community is quick to expose them.

Whenever a study **is** funded by a company or entity with a personal interest in the outcome it absolutely must be stated in the study itself and the conflict of interest exposed.

If you ever actually worked on peer reviewed publications in any capacity you'd understand most of what you said is not at all applicable. Most scientist will happily make 1/10th of what they could make just to ensure their work is objective and without backally deals.

@Coyote Yup, paywalls on research is a tragedy and many researchers agree on that. But keep in mind that isnt so much the researchers fault, they need to make a living. The problem is most research in the US is done for profit and very little is 100% government funded. If americans were more willing to use their tax dollars on science rather than other wastes of money then we could actually make more research public.

@freemo

that's cool, I don't know why, but it remined me of this (non-sequiter, just cool) thing:

"The result is a motorcycle that looks more like an organic exoskeleton than a machine. That was a very deliberate design goal for APWorks, which programmed the algorithm to use bionic structures and natural growth processes and patterns as the basis for developing a strong but lightweight structure"

https://www.greencarcongress.com/2016/05/20160522-airbus.html

Due to bandwidth limitations, I offer only an example of "organic" skeletons grown using AI to fill in minimal material for maximum structural strength... AI, being "organic" in fabrication with artificial materials is fucking cool. (even with more basics too, like out of aluminum).

It wasn't long ago, it seems, but in the 1990s I watched a guy do a talk on OLED tech and we all just went "cool, some day we can hang our TV on the wall like a picture" and went home to tell my friends who didn't believe me.

When you think of the shit we will have in 20 years, if you are smart, you instantly know, it's going to be totally different, and better in a way you haven't even thought of yet.

@Moon

Neither do I.. unfortunately I do care about getting shot by a cop who cares about legality :)

@10grans @akeno @madmike @Coyote @Andrii

@Moon

Scihub is good, though far from complete and legality is questionable for sure.

@10grans @akeno @madmike @Coyote @Andrii

@Coyote

Aaron Swartz got in trouble beause he mass downloaded with the intent to redistribute.. If you do data analysis but dont mass download, or if you download only things you intend to read then you should be good.

@10grans @akeno @madmike @Andrii

@Coyote

There are subscriptions to larger collections of journals. They just tend to be a bit more pricey... for that though a public library is your best bet.

@10grans @akeno @madmike @Andrii

@Coyote

I hear ya.. two suggestions.

1) pick just a single high quality journal and pay for the subscription. Some journals arent that expensive 100$ for a whole year or something.

2) go to a library, a good library, especially one at a university, will give you free access to many journal databases.

@10grans @akeno @madmike @Andrii

@Coyote

Yea that explain it.. keep in mind anyone can start a journal and do peer review, not every journal does **good** peer review or quality work... there are junk journals and then there are good journals.. this is why you cant just blindly go "this is peer reviewed therefore its fact". you kinda need to know the quality of the journal it comes from as well as what other studies on the same subject say, and even look at how old a paper is.

But yea.. get access to a journal. you dont need an expensive subscription either.. there are relatively cheap subscriptions if all you want is a single specific journal in digital format. If you get a good journal I think you will appreciate the value they produce.

@10grans @akeno @madmike @Andrii

@Coyote

On that we agree. I 100% support the idea that whether i think your choices are idiotic or not when it comes to your body they are you choices to make. If you get sick or die you are the only one who is going to suffer, so you have the right to choose your own fate.

@denza252

@Coyote

It depends, PhDs accomplish a hell of a lot in theory, they just suck at building the results you'd see.

I code a lot of machine learning stuff.. a HUGE portion of stuff ive implemented that has been extremely powerful was just me taking a PhD paper with some shitty code but a brilliant idea and turning it into a proper library.

Anyone who straddles the line between PhD and engineer and gets the computer science journals like ASIST or ACM will tell you its a constant stream of new, novel and useful (though often specialized) Ideas... yea 75% of it might be stupid stuff that is just interesting, but the other 25% has value.

I get the feeling you either read really shitty journals or dont really read specific journals at all (and just come across random articles that are the exception more than a the rule)... I urge you to go out, get a subscription to a well respected high quality journal in a field you can understand, and actually go through each months or quarters issue and one by one check out the papers.. they tend to all have a lot of value.

@10grans @akeno @madmike @Andrii

@Coyote

If you ever want to see a paper that is behind a paywall and you dont wish to get a subscription just email the author. 98% of the time they will happily send you a free copy of the paper.

@10grans @akeno @madmike

@Coyote

That data is not yet in a form that is particularly compelling. It tells you nothing unless you at a minimum normalize against the background. At a simple glance nothing about that happens to be alarming.

@denza252

@Andrii

No one should assume someone is automatically correct due to letters on their name.. however if those letters come from an accredited university, and one person has them and another doesnt, and both sides assert some fact without actually teaching you what you need to know to prove that fact (perhaps because it is too complicated in the time given).. youd be a fool not to go with the person who has been trained all else being equal.

With that said if someone has some letters after their name and has accomplished nothing past university, and someone else has no letters after their name and has published 20 ground breaking papers on the topic that have been peer reviewed and shown to be correct as well as novel, then by all means you should be trusting the guy with no letters.

In the end when it comes to decided who is a more reliable source on any topic it isnt about the letters on their name but rather how much they have accomplished in their respective field that has been proven to be right by other experts and which demonstrates their abilities.

@10grans @akeno @madmike @Coyote

@Coyote

I mean, science and peer review is way more reliable than just winging it.. but like everything it wont be perfect and you absolutely need to apply judgement and not just take everyting blindly... Its important to understand how strongly a papers conclusion is shown, what biases the author has, and how many other studies done in different ways show similar results. From that you form a picture.

The problem is sometimes with just a fraudulent paper but thats the exception far more than it is the rule. More often its simply that a paper shows weak but supporting evidence for something, doesnt make any false claims and even clearly points out how weak the evidence is, but because the media doesnt know the first thing about reading or understanding science, and neither does the general public, you get some bullshit interpretation of the paper sounding like settled science on an issue that is still very much still being researched.

@10grans @akeno @madmike

@Coyote

You can almost never draw causation when it comes to medications and single cases. We just dont have the means. We do it with statistical correlation and that means looking at large groups of people.

Ideally what should happen, and what usually does happen. Is her hospital visit is flagged when it is seen it happened right after a vaccine and is added to the FDA database of all people who had serious medical issues with a potential but unknown link to the virus. Then if enough people show the same problems, enough that it is higher than the background rate, then they will usually look into it more deeply and look at better data and do better studies and either pull the vaccine or add it as a warning and a side effect.

Thats exactly how it went down with AZ, blood clots were seen to be happening at a higher rate than usual, was concluded it was due to the AZ vaccine,a nd it was added as a warning to the drug and some countries adjusted their approach to administering it as a result.

One person will never tell you anything useful though.

@denza252

@akeno

LOLOLOLOL

You: "Here listen to this guy who got a PhD in 8 months from a guy in a trench coat in a back ally talk about how viruses arent real".

Me: "That dude isnt a Phd"

You: "Barghblahdf youa re a fraud, a Scientologist, you dont know what your talking about. How dare you insult a real doctor who knew what he was talking about"...

LOL ok there buddy. you lost the high ground the second you tried to sell a college drop out who only got in on a scholarship playing tennis as a reliable source in the first place. Sorry but your opinion of me has 0 value.

@Coyote @madmike

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.