Dont ask questions you dont want thoughtful and complete answers on. Its not my responsibility to cater what I write to someones poor reading skills/speed.
Wrong, it is bad when it happens fast, good when slow. But you are welcome to believe wrong things, you dont need my approval.
You are welcome to think that, you are wrong, but your welcome to think it all the same.
Well for starters they arent taking wealth out of US dollars, no more than someone is doing so when they take US dollars and invest in anything. They are doing exactly what I said responsible people should do, that is, invest their US dollars rather than hoard it. Since bitcoin is a growing technology still being adopted it is a growing asset and not acting like a fiat (yet)
But to answer your question, why bitcoin (or other cryptocurrency for that matter).. simple, because they add function that doesnt exist, just like any technology. They allow for instant transfer of money across borders, unlike the hassles of something like western union. It enables trustless contractialization of money (no reliance on courts and lawyers but instead using systems like Stacks to enforce money contracts), and enables automatic, garunteed, and provable accounting. No one in their right mind is buying up bitcoin simply because its some fixed fiat and nothing else.
It is always when a person doesnt have a leg to stand on in their argument they resort to personal attacks.
I have had more than enough success predicting economic events and profiting off them to have proved my understand of economics. You're welcome to disagree of course, but it doesnt appear based on understanding, just your personal dogma (which is why your having a fit when your dogma is debunked).
No, inflation causes asets to **gain** value while money to **loose** value.. No one takes money out of an economy when there is healthy inflation, they move it from money to aset wealth and profit off the inflation directly.
1) its not a debt centric economy, money is invested and you gain, you need not go into debt.
2)the people at the low end do not hold money or any other form of wealth, likewise their wages rise to match the inflation on average. So they are not harmed by inflation. (as was shown earlier with the average hourly rate vs inflation chart)
> There is truth to the fact that encouraging people to invest their wealth rather than save it puts capital into the economy, but people could already do this with savings banks.
No this is actually the very point your disputing. Inflation encourages investment, you take that wad of cash and put it into the economy so it can work to build things and pay wages... putting money into a bank causes that money to be loaned out, so puts someone in debt on the other side. So in fact using the bank system to just sit on a wad of cash is a "debt-centric economy" where as inflation where people are storing their money in mutual funds or other low-risk investments is far less so a debt-centric economy.
Great so your againsted fixed dollars and agree inflation is better than a fixed dollar. then we agree, all done here.
And yes you can have it both ways where too much inflation is harmful and too little is harmful. Many things in the world behave that way, it is called non-linearity.
We've already seen the evidence this is just plain wrong. We used to fix the dollar so it wouldn't inflate and it devastated our economy. Thankfully we stopped.
Of course it makes it non-liquid... but we need to be clear on what that means. If your money is in an IRA then that means it takes a week to get to your money instead of 10 seconds. Thats fine, as I said responsible money management means you have some small amount of cash on hand (whatever you may need to cover you over a weeks time) and the rest is non-liquid but easily liquidated.
> IRA has a maximum contribution limit, that doesn't make it a great mechanism for savings.
Its part of a savings plan, not the only. You should be making the max contribution to your IRA if you make enough to do so, beyond that you use a regular brokerage account and ensure you still use low risk mutual funds.
> The way savings usually work in our banking economy is people used to put it into a bank, for it to be loaned out, and interest to be paid back on it to keep it above inflation, and even make a profit.
This wasn't a great system, but it was better.
You certainly can do that, use a bank and put it in a CD (long term) or high-yield account (short term) to just barely break even on inflation. But thats very irresponsible and ultimately means you will just break even on inflation and not benefit, which doesnt make inflation bad for you just makes it neutral. While most more responsible people will have their money in investments.
> A better system would be savings in a secure currency, or a strengthening currency, rather than a weakening currency where people have to run just to keep up with the devaluing of their money.
You can do that, but no it is neither good for the economy or responsible for the masses to do that. Some will who are just paranoid but the last thing we want is stagnant wealth people hoard, that isnt good for your pockets or society. Currencies that dont undergo low rates of inflation kill economies, and we have seen that in the past when we had exactly that with the gold standard.
We are talking about inflation, not negative interest or even necessarily printing new money. These can be related concepts but need not be.
> If you think that someone's wealth slowly losing value due to inflation then you fundamentally do not understand what economics are, or are for.
Wrong, inflation **grows** wealth.. it diminished fiat, big big difference. A persons **wealth** (so long as they arent hoarding fiat) grows with inflation doesnt diminish.
> Worsening the buying power of the dollar only hurts the Economy long run and all suffer except banks.
Again wrong, the buying power of the dollar isnt what is relevant.. everyone has more dollars with slightly less buying power. The overall buying power is higher not lower. There are effectively more dollars in circulation.
> keynesian Economics are shit.
This isnt about keysian economics, inflation is a good thing (when slow and healthy) in multiple economic model systems.
I mentioned 3 options, 2 are long term (for retirement) savings: Roth IRA and 401K, they **only** have fees to withdraw pre-retirement. The 3rd an IRA does not have fees to withdrawl and would be where you put savings where you'd want access to it should you need it.
> Holding wealth over a long period of time is vital to the prosperity of the people, and making it accessible in the form of a stable currency is a keystone in that.
Yes it is vital, but not in the form of currency and no we do **not** make it available in that form (and never have), I have mentioned 4 ways you can hold wealth over long periods, all of which are healthy for the economy as they enable that money to build new wealth rather than stagnate. People hoarding money is not what we need, that is not what money is for.
Yes, savings, for a responsible person, takes the form of a IRA or Rother IRA, or 401K, typically invested in stable low-risk mutual funds. If your eally want to keep savines as cash with garunteed returns you can do a CD which will still give you more returns than inflation but just barely (its not a wise investment but it is an option if you insist on holding cash for any reason)
They dont need to be bankers, they just need to know some basics, including not keeping large quantities of cash over long periods of time.
When did I say money runs dont happen? Not keeping your assets s money though protects you from it. Golds value doesnt go down when money runs happen it goes up.
"People having to manipulate"
No one has to manipulate anything. Just dont hoard money, other than that your fine. Keep it as gold if you want something that is like money but relatively wealth stable.
You can keep saying inflation is a cancer all you want, but youll still be wrong.
Never said your suppose to just spend money on anything.. No one should be buying fancy expensive shoes they dont need or other expendables. I said responsible money use means **investing** this means at a minimum a mutual fund, that IS using money for productive ventures...
Point is the **last** thing you should be doing is hoarding wads of cash.
No one with any money wants to hoard cash without investing. When inflations happens no one is running to outside countries to put their money in fiat, it just isnt what the reality is. Inflation means the price of assets is going up, anyone with half a brain therefore converts their money to assets (local assets), there is no reason to move their money out of country when the inflation is benefiting them here.
Jeffrey Phillips Freeman
Innovator & Entrepreneur in Machine Learning, Evolutionary Computing & Big Data. Avid SCUBA diver, Open-source developer, HAM radio operator, astrophotographer, and anything nerdy.
Born and raised in Philadelphia, PA, USA, currently living in Utrecht, Netherlands, USA, and Thailand. Was also living in Israel, but left.
Pronouns: Sir / Mister
(Above pronouns are not intended to mock, i will respect any persons pronouns and only wish pronouns to show respect be used with me as well. These are called neopronouns, see an example of the word "frog" used as a neopronoun here: http://tinyurl.com/44hhej89 )
A proud member of the Penobscot Native American tribe, as well as a Mayflower passenger descendant. I sometimes post about my genealogical history.
My stance on various issues:
Education: Free to PhD, tax paid
Abortion: Protected, tax paid, limited time-frame
Welfare: Yes, no one should starve
UBI: No, use welfare
Racism: is real
Guns: Shall not be infringed
LGBT+/minorities: Support
Pronouns: Will respect
Trump: Moron, evil
Biden: Senile, racist
Police: ACAB
Drugs: Fully legal, no prescriptions needed
GPG/PGP Fingerprint: 8B23 64CD 2403 6DCB 7531 01D0 052D DA8E 0506 CBCE