Show newer

@khird The reader wouldnt be verifying the reviewers individually, I agree that would be unworkable.

The solution would have to lie in a network of trust. So, for example, a user might specify they trust people with PhD's from acredited institutions with 20 points of default trust, and then one additional point for every successful publication they have in a third party journal, and an additional 5 points for each article they have published on QOTO that has passed my personal criteria for acceptance.

You set up the categories of "trust" and then those criteria are used to determine what passes for the individual.

Peer-review being anonymous can be a possiblity and optional. The identiy need not be public as long as the system itself knows the person and can evaluate their credentials.

This is what I meant when I said the approval process needs to be "fuzzy".. it has to use some trust network where a person can generalize groups or categories of "properties" as being things that increase or decrease one's trust in the person.

@oloke While I dont doubt that is true I would love to see a list of whatever examples come to mind.

The state thinks people are apathetic dumb sheep. They are right...

I have been thinking about writing a webapp that would enable QOTO to become the first "open, distributed, scientific journal".. I am still thinking about how I am going to go about it but the idea would be a scientific journal that anyone, regardless of credentials or pre-approval, can submit articles and peer-review and ultimately the acceptance or rejection of an article will happen without a centralized authority.

In all liklihood acceptance will be "fuzzy" in that it will be up to the reader to decide if the groups which approved of the article through peer review have sufficient credentials that you trust them. So the key will be in designing a way to make that work.

Ideas are welcome of course.

Remember, if you see someone drowning, first laugh out loud, then bacon, then and only then call 911!

@funny

Just some info for aspiring scientists.. If you have papers you've written of a scientific nature but are either not suited for a scientific journal or you simply dont want to go through the rigour, you can still get a DOI for your publication and associate it with your ORCID. which is good if your trying to build up your reputation and improve the catalog associated with your ORCID.

Check out zenodo.org/, anyone can get an account in a few minutes and then your all set to upload your documents which will immediately be assigned a DOI. Though of course the submissions are reviewed and if they arent of a scientific nature may be taken down.

I just tried it out by uploaded an old paper I wrote that was basically a one page how-to on doing rotations in an arbitrary number of dimensions. You can check it out here at my shiny new DOI:

doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.5027318

@jmw150 metamath is definately not just a database. It is a special language you can use to write proofs and have a system automatically verify the validity of a proof as well as render the proof as a webpage.

That ability to confirm the validity of a proof is what I usually hear people talk about when they have mentioned metamath.

@AmpBenzScientist

Its how i was taught too, but i have forgotten so much of the derivation and find it hard to dig up sometimes. Thus id like to document it somewhere in a wiki format.. a wiki of derrivtions and cheat sheets.

@josemanuel
The lack of apparent depth of carious periods is a bit deceiving too..i mean we have this idea that everything old must be epic and serious and grand... Truth is a lot of midevil writing is littered with childish things like fart jokes and chastity belts (never existed just a very old and long running joke).

The old epics arent without their own sort of silliness but just as it is often lost on readers.

For example people who read midevil texts often take chastity belts to be a real and literal thing, the fact that it was middle-age slapstick comedy in written form is lost on readers and they figured such belts existed.

The farther you go back the less obvious the intended joke is and the more likely you are to take it seriously and in the process be naive to rhe childish humor. Even the translator may have missed it and left it out of the context entierly.

@jmw150 I heard of metamath before.. i really should try and get into it.

@josemanuel The thing is the 1200 CE version shouldnt be taken at face value, nor should reading anything that is that old. There is generally all sorts of implied symbolism or references a modern reader will miss. So something that may appear stupid and not well thought out is actually quite brilliant and once you dig a bit deeper.

@yellowbeard Story of my life... i should be doing real work and not contemplating reinventing math :)

Part of me wants to reconstruct all of math up to calculus from scratch and document it all and then create a knowledge map so someone can see how any advanced idea is derrived from the most elementary ideas.

Partly I want to do this for myself just because I have a hard time remembering some derrivations, particularly in calculus where you have to go back to limits to show it.

@josemanuel Are you sure you havent confused the ring cycle with the earlier work on which it was closely based (in part) titled Nibelungenlied?

Nibelungenlied (poem from the 1200) has many of the same events revolving around siegfried and includes a scene where he bathes in dragon blood. The ring cycle itself, as i recall, leaves that out.

That said the scene in the ring cycle is remarkably similar where he still consumes some of the blood accidentally and is imparted with powers.

@lucifargundam You like your books like you like your women I see.. well used, in good condition, and very old.

@AmpBenzScientist

Damn, you mean to tell me the AMS wont be accepting my submission afterall?

@math

@stevenroose Nothing experimental, and im not sure if you reported it, but you were in the comments. It was an issue related to yay so nothing too experimental.

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.